No way Sheffield Wednesday or Derby County fans choose to stay at home and watch Fulham v Sunderland at 3pm on a Saturday afternoon. Or even Wycombe or Exeter fans for that matter. It's an old argument that doesn't hold water in my opinion.
However I'd also argue that the biggest "scrotes" as
@LongLostBee calls them are Sky, TNT and the EPL for forcing people to pay the ridiculous prices that people pay to watch live football on tv. It's an outrageous cost and is way more expensive for us than any other country in the world, so you can hardly blame people for finding a cheaper alternative way of watching their team.