Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Status
Not open for further replies.

ccfcwelshlad

Member
Joined
25 Jul 2013
Messages
4
Reaction score
0

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Hi All,

Seems that you will be taking our young centre-back on loan until the end of December, following our acquisition of Steven Caulker today.

Strong and relatively mobile lad, still has plenty to work on, but has shown plenty of promise.

Seems like something was agreed after yesterday's game and he was accordingly left out of squad at Port Talbot tonight.
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

He wasn't no6 last night was he?
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

I don't think this is the greatest signing if I'm honest. We have had an entire summer to get a permanent centre back as cover / competition for Dean and Craig so a youngster a couple of days before the season starts does not seem a great option. If he turns out to be the next Beckenbaur, then I apologise in advance. ;)
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Big lad - 6'5. That's a big plus. I wonder if he's left footed?
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

I don't think this is the greatest signing if I'm honest. We have had an entire summer to get a permanent centre back as cover / competition for Dean and Craig so a youngster a couple of days before the season starts does not seem a great option. If he turns out to be the next Beckenbaur, then I apologise in advance. ;)

Surprised at you Les. Never had you for one of those who would be underwhelmed at a signing before he has pulled on the shirt. Looks to have a good pedigree to me, just not ready for Prem yet.
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

I don't think this is the greatest signing if I'm honest. We have had an entire summer to get a permanent centre back as cover / competition for Dean and Craig so a youngster a couple of days before the season starts does not seem a great option. If he turns out to be the next Beckenbaur, then I apologise in advance. ;)

I agree. Would have preferred someone with more experience. I'm a bit underwhelmed by the signing. Sorry. :shrug:

Three days to the new season. :bound:
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

On the face of it this is underwhelming but he's a big unit that we needed, and presumably won't be first choice. Not bad bearing in mind he was breaking in to the defence of the team that won the Championship comfortably last season.

Yes, I'm being optimistic. Wanted someone with experience at centre back, but perhaps Venta and Craig have enough experience between them :rosetintedglassessmilie:
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Surprised at you Les. Never had you for one of those who would be underwhelmed at a signing before he has pulled on the shirt. Looks to have a good pedigree to me, just not ready for Prem yet.

I just think that we have had all summer to make a permanent signing with some experience and we end up bringing in a youngster a couple of days before. 2 months ago we were signing Darren Ward - that obviously fell through but that's a long time to not find an alternative.

I'm sure he'll be just fine as player but it seems a stop gap whereas I was expecting someone with considerable experience to join the club in that position this summer.
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Surprised at you Les. Never had you for one of those who would be underwhelmed at a signing before he has pulled on the shirt. Looks to have a good pedigree to me, just not ready for Prem yet.

Perhaps we've been spoiled by the quality of our signings this summer?

I was expecting someone who had made quite a few more than 14 professional appearances.

He was Cardiff's Young Player of last season.

Welcome to the club, Ben. :hat:
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Played 14 times in their championship year and signed until 2016 too. 6'5" so adds a bit of presence. Also, this presumably allows us to retain a chunk of the playing budget to put to use on further transfers/allows us to strengthen during the January transfer window. I'm happy for Craig and Dean to continue, so for this guy to play understudy seems prudent to me.

No point splashing cash on permanent transfers just for the sake of it.

Edit - apparently not 6'5" then!
 
Last edited:

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

I thought we'd been chasing Liam Moore from reports - maybe we've given up

The lad was Cardiff's young player of season last year and tipped by Mackay as future captain. Sounds good to me
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

NOT signing Darren Ward was, in my opinion, a great bit of business!

Watch the highlights of the play-off game when he has to take a step backwards to steady himself before slicing the ball into row Z!!
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

I just think that we have had all summer to make a permanent signing with some experience and we end up bringing in a youngster a couple of days before. 2 months ago we were signing Darren Ward - that obviously fell through but that's a long time to not find an alternative.

I'm sure he'll be just fine as player but it seems a stop gap whereas I was almost expecting someone with considerable experience to join the club in that position this summer.

Understand where your coming from. Maybe Ward wasn't the only deal that went TU??? What struck me about the McAleny move was that we wanted him a full 12 months before we got him. Do we have someone else in mind that we just can't get at the mo? Who knows?
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Ok, I concede. We definitely need more presence in the centre of defence so if this guy is the answer, I'm happy with that. Central defence is our weakest point of the team imo.
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

View from a Cardiff fan:

Decent prospect in my opinion, got a fair amount of game time last season so Mackay seems to rate him too. Big strong centre half, good header of the ball from the games I've seen him in. Very raw still though, regular game time in the league is exactly what he needs. Will be more useful for you if played alongside a quick centre-back partner as he is on the slow side.
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Is he basically Dan Burn then :sorted:
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

For those 20 minutes or so he was on the pitch on Tuesday, I thought the no.19 was very poor, big, yes, but poor on the ball. I hope he doesn't take a space on the bench for the sake of keeping Cardiff happy......
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Slow, 6 foot 4" sounds like the second coming of the dancing bear folks:)
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

For those 20 minutes or so he was on the pitch on Tuesday, I thought the no.19 was very poor, big, yes, but poor on the ball. I hope he doesn't take a space on the bench for the sake of keeping Cardiff happy......

We haven't signed too many duds lately so I have to give him the benefit of the doubt. Clearly you have seen him and I haven't, time will tell :)
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

so far all Uwe signing has been spot on this season.. it's good news that we have another player in where we are short off..
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Maybe he was on our radar as many are and the management team wanted to take a peak at him on our own turf against our boys before making an approach. Young player of the season is good enough for me. Forshaw was the same before he signed for us permanently. Yes it widely been reported that two bids for Liam Moore were rejected ( thank god - him and Dean were like keystone kops together ) but am sure there is a list of players of equalling abilities that was drawn up for each position and this guy was one of them. Give him a chance like the others and then make a judgement. Richard Lee was abysmal when he first joined and was soon 'Englands number one'
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Jeez, this thread reads as though we're doomed!
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Who can you trust eh? Can someone take a tape measure to Port Vale please.

It's in my bag. Thermos - check, sandwiches - check, rattle - check, transistor radio - check .......
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Perhaps Uwe felt sorry for them after we beat them and signed him to make Cardiff feel as if was not a complete waste of time turning up at GP.
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

So we are now judging him on 20 minutes of a pre-season friendly where Cardiff basically swapped their entire team?

Wow
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Once again the Welsh press have pissed on our fire regarding us announcing a signing or in Moore's case a departure no need for Rebus to throw a tantrum can't see this effecting the game plan for Saturday.I do remember this gangly youngster Tuesday night I was behind the Ealing road second half and commented to a mate that he looked dodgy after trying to play the ball out of defence and ending up being closed down and played a short ball to the keeper who sliced it out of play.Having said that as others have posted he has had a good number of games in the championship for a promoted club and is highly rated by Cardiff.Not sure what sort of signing some fans want as I would think Dean and Craig are first choice pairing so whoever comes in is going to be back up so Nugent looks a good signing as Kevin is our only option if Craig doesn't make Saturday.Once again the club have reacted quickly and positively to address a team issue.
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

...............welcome aboard..............
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Good signing for when the other team has a big physical lump up front. Kevin Davies is now in the division who isn not going to beat us with his pace exactly...
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Good signing for when the other team has a big physical lump up front. Kevin Davies is now in the division who isn not going to beat us with his pace exactly...

phew, some sense.
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

This is the stuff of nightmares.
Me and my Grandad left Griffin Park on Tuesday completely laughing at "their No.19". He was one of the most useless players we said we'd seen in a very long time. Every time he got the ball, he didn't have a clue what to do and 90% plus of his passes were to us.
Now he's signing for us, who's laughing now :cry: x
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

This is the stuff of nightmares.
Me and my Grandad left Griffin Park on Tuesday completely laughing at "their No.19". He was one of the most useless players we said we'd seen in a very long time. Every time he got the ball, he didn't have a clue what to do and 90% plus of his passes were to us.
Now he's signing for us, who's laughing now :cry: x

Come on now....

There were no players that were laughable, a few wayward passes in a pre season friendly.

Any player that has -

Started 1/3 of the games for a top top championship winning in his first season as a pro.

Signed a new long term contract with a premier league team and the manager quoting he is or future captain.

Is more than welcome to the party.

Uwe and warbs are only buying players to better this squad..

The quote on here from somebody saying Leon Legge... Is the only laughable thing I see here.

Brentford together....

You Redsssss
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

This is the stuff of nightmares.
Me and my Grandad left Griffin Park on Tuesday completely laughing at "their No.19". He was one of the most useless players we said we'd seen in a very long time. Every time he got the ball, he didn't have a clue what to do and 90% plus of his passes were to us.
Now he's signing for us, who's laughing now :cry: x

I was watching Nugent carefully as whilst as a rule I wouldn't be paying much attention to the opposition mass substitutions in a friendly game I was aware that we had an interest in this player and that he would be playing the last twenty minutes. My take is not that of yours and your grandad. He made some decent long passes to the right and certainly has a physical presence. Uwe following on from scouting reports and Malky Mackay's strong recommendation clearly saw enough to push ahead with a loan signing which makes sense I would think if players in whom we have an interest in signing on contracts are not immediately available. We needed another centre back and we've signed a young promising player who if needed will add height and presence for set pieces at both ends and who has I think fourteen Championship appearances to his credit and that is from a side who were chasing and did achieve promotion i.e. not meaningless end of season games.

What's not to like?? :confused:
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Malkay obviously rates him otherwise wouldnt have played that many games. fingers crossed. i'll b going to vale on sat not knowing any of the team! sob sob x
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

I was watching Nugent carefully as whilst as a rule I wouldn't be paying much attention to the opposition mass substitutions in a friendly game I was aware that we had an interest in this player and that he would be playing the last twenty minutes. My take is not that of yours and your grandad. He made some decent long passes to the right and certainly has a physical presence. Uwe following on from scouting reports and Malky Mackay'
s strong recommendation clearly saw enough to push ahead with a loan signing which makes sense I would think if players in whom we have an interest in signing on contracts are not immediately available. We needed another centre back and we've signed a young promising player who if
needed will add height and presence for set pieces at both ends and who has I think fourteen Championship appearances to his credit and that is from a side who were chasing and did achieve promotion i.e. not meaningless end of season games.

What's not to like?? :confused:

Nothing abee although I think the expectations have changed and some were upset we didn't bid for Caulker!
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

I was watching Nugent carefully as whilst as a rule I wouldn't be paying much attention to the opposition mass substitutions in a friendly game I was aware that we had an interest in this player and that he would be playing the last twenty minutes. My take is not that of yours and your grandad. He made some decent long passes to the right and certainly has a physical presence. Uwe following on from scouting reports and Malky Mackay's strong recommendation clearly saw enough to push ahead with a loan signing which makes sense I would think if players in whom we have an interest in signing on contracts are not immediately available. We needed another centre back and we've signed a young promising player who if needed will add height and presence for set pieces at both ends and who has I think fourteen Championship appearances to his credit and that is from a side who were chasing and did achieve promotion i.e. not meaningless end of season games.

What's not to like?? :confused:

Exactly abee. There wasn't anyone laughable at the game at all and you would have had a particular eagle eye on this lad moreso than any of us. He can't be that bad to be voted young player of the season. People are so quick to criticise without knowing anything about him other than seeing a 20 appearance at our place. If he had been a star man and played above everyones level, he wouldn't be coming on loan to us!! I don't know how you keep your temper abee with people on here, I would be 'don't like it, go support Fulham'
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

Once again the Welsh press have pissed on our fire regarding us announcing a signing or in Moore's case a departure no need for Rebus to throw a tantrum can't see this effecting the game plan for Saturday.I do remember this gangly youngster Tuesday night I was behind the Ealing road second half and commented to a mate that he looked dodgy after trying to play the ball out of defence and ending up being closed down and played a short ball to the keeper who sliced it out of play.Having said that as others have posted he has had a good number of games in the championship for a promoted club and is highly rated by Cardiff.Not sure what sort of signing some fans want as I would think Dean and Craig are first choice pairing so whoever comes in is going to be back up so Nugent looks a good signing as Kevin is our only option if Craig doesn't make Saturday.Once again the club have reacted quickly and positively to address a team issue.

TC will do an OK job in this division. I would have thought that we would be looking beyond that though, surely?

Maybe this lad is the kind of player that could do that. On the negative side; the BBC commentary wasn't very gracious in their assessment of his performance on Tuesday.

As I wasn't there, I have no idea, but his short record looks good.
 

Ben Nugent - loan until end of December

TC will do an OK job in this division. I would have thought that we would be looking beyond that though, surely?

Maybe this lad is the kind of player that could do that. On the negative side; the BBC commentary wasn't very gracious in their assessment of his performance on Tuesday.

As I wasn't there, I have no idea, but his short record looks good.

Best looking short record was The Buzzcocks "Ever fallen in love" on coloured vinyl. Sorry!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom