RESPONSE FROM RON
Ron Noades has asked me to post the attached...
I read the Grapevine Bulletin Board on Monday and it was nice to see the medium being used for an intellectual discussion about Brentford's problems that are somewhere near reality.
First of all, congratulations to the Action Group who did the survey in the Feltham area but you need to get the Hounslow Chronicle to publish the results of the survey and also pass them on to the Local Authority. The contributors have also identified one or two of the problems facing the Club. We obviously would be delighted with a 25,000 capacity stadium but we don't need that now, although perhaps we need to be able to get to it ultimately. Bearing in mind a planning brief exists, written by the Local Authority, for the Feltham Arena with a capacity indicated of 8,000 this idea of a 25,000 capacity is something that can only come from those who have the power to grant the planning consent. I don't believe that if Brentford Football Club had made an application for that size of stadium on the Feltham Arena at any time in the past that it would have been approved; there would be enormous traffic problems and at least you have identified how much money would need to be spent on roads and access in and out of the Arena. You cannot do it without buying additional property and only the Local Authority can do this because of their compulsory purchase order powers. I would never have suggested this capacity for this site if we already owned it and were looking for an approval both on the grounds of transport and access. Clearly over a long period of time, with other properties acquired and the goodwill of everyone, it can be done but it is a decision that has to be made at all party level and they have to give approval. No individual could substantiate this capacity on this site without additional properties being acquired, therefore it is realistic for Brentford to apply for a lower capacity which is why we hope to get the 8,000 up to 13,500.
One of you asks why it cannot be a phased development like Wycombe which is exactly what we have been thinking ourselves. Let's have the Local Authority approving the 25,000 stadium that we can build in stages as the transport problems are solved. Access is wanted from the Feltham Town area so that people arrive by train and bus and not cars and therefore it will need to be widened for the large development but might be suitable today for a lower capacity. The acquisition of additional properties is outside of Brentford's control and powers and as the site has to go out to be sold to the highest bidder, it is not logical for us to make the planning application and then find somebody else has bought it. On the other hand if we had an option to buy the site we would of course be quite happy to deal with the planning but it would still be logical to phase the construction.
The second interesting subject on the Bulletin Board is the average attendance discussion and at least the fans are saying themselves that if we stay at Griffin Park on these attendances, the Club will simply fade away into the lower reaches of football. Of the clubs with lower attendances than ourselves, Oldham have tied up with Leeds United, Cambridge has a new stadium planned and so do Bournemouth and Colchester whilst Oxford has one under construction. The fans are right about the additional revenue because the stadium produces additional income so that we can improve players' wages and build a team which in turn will improve attendances. The reason is that the stadium income is not dependent on results on the pitch. 100 executive boxes are worth 5,000 extra average attendance and you can sell 100 boxes to local businesses if the facilities are nice for their guests. Function rooms can operate all through the week, not just once a fortnight. Once again Wycombe Wanderers is a perfect example ~ they started off with a low capacity which has been added to as required and they now have had some 'house full' signs on 10,500. It is ridiculous saying there are teams above us with worse grounds than ours, I don't know any teams above us with no car parking and only one bar that is not planning to move.
When I got Wimbledon into the League, our off the pitch income paid all of our outgoings without any gate receipts ~ we had a Sportsman's Pub and Gold Digger lotteries and you could not get to a seat in the ground without going through a bar; we also had a nightclub which doubled as a lounge on match days. At Selhurst Park we built thirteen function rooms and the catering turnover was £2.5million a year. In effect the gross profit on the catering compares with the entire year's gate receipts at Griffin Park.
I am glad the Gillingham Chairman confirmed what I have been saying and I have stopped complaining about our supporters not coming to games simply because gates are down throughout the League and all the clubs now have the same problems, ours are just more acute than most because Griffin Park offers nothing other than turnstiles. Good stadiums mean high income and less dependency on crowds and unless you have a guarantee of regular income not linked to the vagaries of success and attendances you cannot budget with confidence on the level of outgoings you can afford.
Woking is an option which we may need or may not but it is prudent to have it and lower gates at Woking are not relevant if it's a short term situation to ensure the Club has a future and bearing in mind our average gate at Griffin Park we are rather like Wimbledon were when they left Plough Lane, they hadn't really got very much to lose like us?
If Brentford are to have a future we must have a new stadium and I think you should sit down with me to try and achieve what we need in order for the Club to be re-launched to survive in a football industry that is changing daily. I am quite happy to argue constructively with anyone about what, how and why but I think the Club has been fading away for years otherwise why would it have built a block of flats at each end of the ground instead of developing the ground ? It has simply been selling bits and pieces here and there to reduce trading deficits until now when it hasn't got any bits left to sell. Stop worrying that we are going to run off with the proceeds of Griffin Park because you will see how we are going to protect these for the Club which we can do with Martin Lange's agreement and in any event if that was a long term aim of any Director we certainly would not be trying to move the freehold back to the Football Club ~ that simply defies logic and this single act alone should show clearly our intentions for the Club's long term benefit. On the other hand I will try to achieve what I want to achieve with an eighteen month deadline from now as I intend to retire at the allowed age. If I cannot deliver what I think is required to preserve the Club's future with the support of the fans and Martin Lange then there is no point being in charge of something that is fading away. I will be interested to see who, by their actions, support Brentford and want to see it financially viable and competitive; as far as I am concerned anyone that's against the route that we have decided on has to put up an alternative viable option that works or simply must have an interest in Brentford ceasing to trade.
I read the Grapevine Bulletin Board on Monday and it was nice to see the medium being used for an intellectual discussion about Brentford's problems that are somewhere near reality.
First of all, congratulations to the Action Group who did the survey in the Feltham area but you need to get the Hounslow Chronicle to publish the results of the survey and also pass them on to the Local Authority. The contributors have also identified one or two of the problems facing the Club. We obviously would be delighted with a 25,000 capacity stadium but we don't need that now, although perhaps we need to be able to get to it ultimately. Bearing in mind a planning brief exists, written by the Local Authority, for the Feltham Arena with a capacity indicated of 8,000 this idea of a 25,000 capacity is something that can only come from those who have the power to grant the planning consent. I don't believe that if Brentford Football Club had made an application for that size of stadium on the Feltham Arena at any time in the past that it would have been approved; there would be enormous traffic problems and at least you have identified how much money would need to be spent on roads and access in and out of the Arena. You cannot do it without buying additional property and only the Local Authority can do this because of their compulsory purchase order powers. I would never have suggested this capacity for this site if we already owned it and were looking for an approval both on the grounds of transport and access. Clearly over a long period of time, with other properties acquired and the goodwill of everyone, it can be done but it is a decision that has to be made at all party level and they have to give approval. No individual could substantiate this capacity on this site without additional properties being acquired, therefore it is realistic for Brentford to apply for a lower capacity which is why we hope to get the 8,000 up to 13,500.
One of you asks why it cannot be a phased development like Wycombe which is exactly what we have been thinking ourselves. Let's have the Local Authority approving the 25,000 stadium that we can build in stages as the transport problems are solved. Access is wanted from the Feltham Town area so that people arrive by train and bus and not cars and therefore it will need to be widened for the large development but might be suitable today for a lower capacity. The acquisition of additional properties is outside of Brentford's control and powers and as the site has to go out to be sold to the highest bidder, it is not logical for us to make the planning application and then find somebody else has bought it. On the other hand if we had an option to buy the site we would of course be quite happy to deal with the planning but it would still be logical to phase the construction.
The second interesting subject on the Bulletin Board is the average attendance discussion and at least the fans are saying themselves that if we stay at Griffin Park on these attendances, the Club will simply fade away into the lower reaches of football. Of the clubs with lower attendances than ourselves, Oldham have tied up with Leeds United, Cambridge has a new stadium planned and so do Bournemouth and Colchester whilst Oxford has one under construction. The fans are right about the additional revenue because the stadium produces additional income so that we can improve players' wages and build a team which in turn will improve attendances. The reason is that the stadium income is not dependent on results on the pitch. 100 executive boxes are worth 5,000 extra average attendance and you can sell 100 boxes to local businesses if the facilities are nice for their guests. Function rooms can operate all through the week, not just once a fortnight. Once again Wycombe Wanderers is a perfect example ~ they started off with a low capacity which has been added to as required and they now have had some 'house full' signs on 10,500. It is ridiculous saying there are teams above us with worse grounds than ours, I don't know any teams above us with no car parking and only one bar that is not planning to move.
When I got Wimbledon into the League, our off the pitch income paid all of our outgoings without any gate receipts ~ we had a Sportsman's Pub and Gold Digger lotteries and you could not get to a seat in the ground without going through a bar; we also had a nightclub which doubled as a lounge on match days. At Selhurst Park we built thirteen function rooms and the catering turnover was £2.5million a year. In effect the gross profit on the catering compares with the entire year's gate receipts at Griffin Park.
I am glad the Gillingham Chairman confirmed what I have been saying and I have stopped complaining about our supporters not coming to games simply because gates are down throughout the League and all the clubs now have the same problems, ours are just more acute than most because Griffin Park offers nothing other than turnstiles. Good stadiums mean high income and less dependency on crowds and unless you have a guarantee of regular income not linked to the vagaries of success and attendances you cannot budget with confidence on the level of outgoings you can afford.
Woking is an option which we may need or may not but it is prudent to have it and lower gates at Woking are not relevant if it's a short term situation to ensure the Club has a future and bearing in mind our average gate at Griffin Park we are rather like Wimbledon were when they left Plough Lane, they hadn't really got very much to lose like us?
If Brentford are to have a future we must have a new stadium and I think you should sit down with me to try and achieve what we need in order for the Club to be re-launched to survive in a football industry that is changing daily. I am quite happy to argue constructively with anyone about what, how and why but I think the Club has been fading away for years otherwise why would it have built a block of flats at each end of the ground instead of developing the ground ? It has simply been selling bits and pieces here and there to reduce trading deficits until now when it hasn't got any bits left to sell. Stop worrying that we are going to run off with the proceeds of Griffin Park because you will see how we are going to protect these for the Club which we can do with Martin Lange's agreement and in any event if that was a long term aim of any Director we certainly would not be trying to move the freehold back to the Football Club ~ that simply defies logic and this single act alone should show clearly our intentions for the Club's long term benefit. On the other hand I will try to achieve what I want to achieve with an eighteen month deadline from now as I intend to retire at the allowed age. If I cannot deliver what I think is required to preserve the Club's future with the support of the fans and Martin Lange then there is no point being in charge of something that is fading away. I will be interested to see who, by their actions, support Brentford and want to see it financially viable and competitive; as far as I am concerned anyone that's against the route that we have decided on has to put up an alternative viable option that works or simply must have an interest in Brentford ceasing to trade.