BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Banana

Admin
Joined
7 Apr 2000
Messages
121,451
Reaction score
86,418
Location
London

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

At the BU Board Meeting tonight the 150 signed requisitions were presented. The Board then resolved to call an SGM for 22nd December to debate the motion that BIAS has been organising the collection of signatures for.

The BU Board then voted 7-3 with 2 abstaining that Graham Hall be given the "right of reply" and that his statement would be included with the SGM notice. I fail to see any constitution rule or right why an individual be given the chance to have a statement (either for or against a particular motion) distributed to members. The motion was submitted in accordance with the constitution and I don't expect the BU Board to make up rules on the fly. The BU Board is again having its cake and eating it - they refused to let Paul Stedman's motion onto the AGM Agenda citing the BU Constitution and now they ignore it when they want to.

Before the Board vote the Chairman was amending the motion proposed by another board member deleting words like "right of reply" and substituting it with "statement" - he then gave the most biased summing up since Rumpole of the Bailey was out of print in favour of Hall getting his revenge in first. The Chairmen then cleverly abstained from the vote - and before you say he has to - he raised his hand and was recorded as one of the two abstainers.

Graham Hall now has the opportunity to write the same number of words as was used in the motion to right a reply. He can introduce new argument, rebutt the motion point by point. There will be no statement included from someone supporting the motion. I'm staggered by the sheer lunacy of it all.

I have informed the BU Board that I may submit a Dispute in accordance with the BU Constitution.

The BU Board did also confirm that a vote on the motion will require a two-thirds majority to instruct the BU Board. However, Graham Hall is bound individually by the BFC Code of Conduct for Club Directors which means that has to abide by a simple majority vote.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Cheer up 'Nana! At least you've made progress to the extent that these matters are
being discussed....I see even Beesotted's web site seems to have woken up to the situation...
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

I am surprised that the BU board don't see the dangers of the motion being defeated. Could be a lively meeting!

PS - I see it has been arranged to clash with the Edgware v Bees match!
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

I can't usually do Thursdays so looks like I may hove to find a proxy?

I would have thought a no confidence motion was fairly self explanatory and wouldn't need a detailed explanation. Had the motion been properly debated last Saturday I have no doubt Hall would have been given the right of reply as well so I don't (personally) see this as a big issue, others may hold differing views.

So anyway when does Callen resign?
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Banana said:
The BU Board then voted 7-3 with 2 abstaining that Graham Hall be given the "right of reply" and that his statement would be included with the SGM notice.

Who voted for and against?
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Luton Bee said:
I would have thought a no confidence motion was fairly self explanatory and wouldn't need a detailed explanation. Had the motion been properly debated last Saturday I have no doubt Hall would have been given the right of reply as well so I don't (personally) see this as a big issue, others may hold differing views.

I agree Luton although I think Hall had an opportunity to reply at the AGM but chose not to say much?

I guess the way this will work is that there will be a number of bullet-points explaining why BIAS has called the motion and that Hall will issue a statement giving his side? No problem with that personally.

Nana - i`m confused about the voting rules on this. I understood that a 2/3rds majority was required (ie SGM), is that right?

I have supported and signed the motion but if it ends up 55-45 or 60-40 in favour what then? Given the views expressed by some supporters at the AGM I fear there could be a fair number of members who wont support it.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

PJ said:
I have supported and signed the motion but if it ends up 55-45 or 60-40 in favour what then? Given the views expressed by some supporters at the AGM I fear there could be a fair number of members who wont support it.
Time for us to get stuck in then I reckon.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Even if he wins the vote, given the significant numbers that will vote against him, anyone of intergrity should see that staying in post is proving divisive. If there is a majority at the SGM, he should resign regardless of the consitution. You can't claim to represent members when members don't support you.

There is an honourable way out here for Mr Hall. 150 of the membership of BU feel he should go. I believe that Mr Hall should consider his position now in light of that fact.
 
Last edited:

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Les Beeavinu said:
There is an honourable way out here for Mr Hall. 150 of the membership of BU feel he should go. I believe that Mr Hall should consider is position now in light of that fact.

Sadly I suspect Hall looks at this and says "OK they've struggled to get 150 - or about 9% - of the members to support this so they must be in the minority. I'll stay thanks very much". :banghead:

Of course what he'll be blinding himself to is the fact that these fans are the ones that care the most and can be bothered to get involved.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Les Beeavinu said:
Even if he wins the vote, given the significant numbers that will vote against him, anyone of intergrity should see that staying in post is proving devisive. If there is a majority at the SGM, he should resign regardless of the consitution. You can't claim to represent members when members don't support you.

There is an honourable way out here for Mr Hall. 150 of the membership of BU feel he should go. I believe that Mr Hall should consider is position now in light of that fact.

Agree 100% Les :sorted:
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

The Joker said:
Sadly I suspect Hall looks at this and says "OK they've struggled to get 150 - or about 9% - of the members to support this so they must be in the minority. I'll stay thanks very much". :banghead:

Of course what he'll be blinding himself to is the fact that these fans are the ones that care the most and can be bothered to get involved.

He was elected with 151 votes
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

The Joker said:
Of course what he'll be blinding himself to is the fact that these fans are the ones that care the most and can be bothered to get involved.

True on both sides though?
From memory the show of hands at the AGM was something like 55-27 in favour but there were 13 abstentions. Who knows how those who abstained will vote :confused:
Les` post above sums up exactly my thoughts. In my view GH`s position is untenable and his comments at the AGM surely cemented this for any doubters.
Brian Burgess has gone on record as saying he will step down as BU Chair should BU not exercise the option, as I suppose in his eyes he will see it as failure. That is accountability and integrity in action. GH appears to follow the opposite chain of thought.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

PJ said:
Nana - i`m confused about the voting rules on this. I understood that a 2/3rds majority was required (ie SGM), is that right? .

That is correct. But section 1 (iii) of the Brentford FC Code of Conduct for Directors specifies a lower threshold of a simple majority. As the vote will have been of the Trust Membership he would be boud to resign under that document.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Les Beeavinu said:
Even if he wins the vote, given the significant numbers that will vote against him, anyone of intergrity should see that staying in post is proving divisive. If there is a majority at the SGM, he should resign regardless of the consitution. You can't claim to represent members when members don't support you.

There is an honourable way out here for Mr Hall. 150 of the membership of BU feel he should go. I believe that Mr Hall should consider his position now in light of that fact.

Agree totally

However unfortuntately the words Mr Hall, Honourable and integreity are a million miles away from being in the same post!

He was well and truly on his way to cooking his goose before the AGM, i believe since then it has (the goose i mean) been burnt to a crisp.

His complete lack of personality, desire, fight and total obnoxiousness in suggesting that he will only resign if BU DO take control indicates to me how little he supports what BU are trying to do. Surely there are some rules and regulations within the context of the consititution of BU that says the person or persons representing it should be commited to its task. From his speech (if you can call it that) at the AGM Mr Hall exposed himself (in m opinion) as being at a conflict of interest with those he is (again i assume) duty bound to represent. Does this not contravene the rules and regulations of a Industrial Provident Society (or somthing ike that)? Is it not some form of gross misconduct or some such that surely means that we are not duty bound to even get a majority? I am more than likely completely wrong on this point and i am i admit very unaware of BU consitution and rules etc (nana im sure you could answer this for me) but something doesnt quite fit for me.. :confused:
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

PJ said:
I guess the way this will work is that there will be a number of bullet-points explaining why BIAS has called the motion and that Hall will issue a statement giving his side? No problem with that personally.
My problem is that I have *never* seen or heard of a dissenting view being sent out with a motion. Let's suppose this was a vote of confidence in the abilities of Burgess - who would write the dissenting view?

The Board's argument for giving Hall this unconstitution right is that those that vote by proxy would otherwise be uninformed. I'm not sure how allowing Hall to send out a document, having seen the resolution, rebutting each point and introducing that (say) his first born is in need of a heart transplant etc. is democratic. The 151 (now) people that have signed the resolution acted in accordance with the BU Constitution - why can't the BU Board act within the consitution as written. That was their excuse for ****ing up the AGM - they had to follow the BU Consitution. Now, when it doesn't suit them, they invent more rules.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Banana said:
My problem is that I have *never* seen or heard of a dissenting view being sent out with a motion. Let's suppose this was a vote of confidence in the abilities of Burgess - who would write the dissenting view?

The Board's argument for giving Hall this unconstitution right is that those that vote by proxy would otherwise be uninformed. I'm not sure how allowing Hall to send out a document, having seen the resolution, rebutting each point and introducing that (say) his first born is in need of a heart transplant etc. is democratic. The 151 (now) people that have signed the resolution acted in accordance with the BU Constitution - why can't the BU Board act within the consitution as written. That was their excuse for ****ing up the AGM - they had to follow the BU Consitution. Now, when it doesn't suit them, they invent more rules.

Surely in a democracy the accused should be given the right to defend themselves. I personnally see no problem with the proposal
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Banana said:
My problem is that I have *never* seen or heard of a dissenting view being sent out with a motion.

Not familiar with how these motions operate, but I think it should be either both "parties" able to explain their position. Or neither party able to explain their position.
Would seem odd to me that people receive a voting form through the post but may have no idea what its all about (if no accompanying literature) :confused: :wave:
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

[QUOTE='Ayes B]Surely in a democracy the accused should be given the right to defend themselves. I personnally see no problem with the proposal[/QUOTE]
There is no "accused". There is a motion.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Banana said:
There is no "accused". There is a motion.
Let me expand on this point.

The motion is exactly that. The Constitution does not differentiate between "types" of motion. The motion to reappoint the Auditors at the AGM didn't have a dissenting view sent out with it for example.

The debate happens at the meeting - not via statements. Hall has been given the undemocratic right to answer last to BU members. The proposers (all 150 of them) don't have the right to answer Hall's statement - how democratic is that?
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

PJ said:
Not familiar with how these motions operate, but I think it should be either both "parties" able to explain their position. Or neither party able to explain their position.
Traditionally, although not in Bees United, that happens with a debate at the EGM meeting

Would seem odd to me that people receive a voting form through the post but may have no idea what its all about (if no accompanying literature) :confused: :wave:
Traditionally, although not in Bees United, they can find out by coming to the EGM and listening to all sides and counter-argument and counter-counter-argument at the debate
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Excellent work Banana.

If you can mobilise those GPG'ers who want Hall out, surely his expulsion is a certainty.

I'll be at the EGM.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Bee H said:
Spot on :sorted:

Hopefully a few of the Beesotted site chaps will now realise what we've been going on about and assist ! :bound:

To be fair, Leicester Bee and Dave Lane have already been quite helpful publicising the motion :sorted:
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Is there a compromise?

There may mixed views on whether Hall should be forced to resign but I think we would all agree that this issue is potentially distracting and divisive at a crucial time for BU. Most people would have resigned to avoid the possible damage to BU, but Hall seems determined to stick it out to the bitter end.

For me the main reason for him to resign is his conflict of interest where he stands to gain from failure of the BU take-over. So, I wonder if there is a compromise we could unite around.

What if Hall made a commitment to resign in January whether the BU take-over was successful or not. This could be backed up by a statement from the BU board that they would ask him to resign and hold a new election whatever the outcome of the take-over. Having resigned he would be free to stand for re-election if he wanted.

This would remove the conflict of interest because he is going whatever happens; keep him available until January (which the board seem to think is important); hopefully satisfy the people who think he is not fit to continue and avoid a potentially disruptive EGM.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

beezy babe said:
To be fair, Leicester Bee and Dave Lane have already been quite helpful publicising the motion :sorted:

granted Doc but some of the posters on the few occasions that I visit the site have been less than complimentary re the GPG mischief makers !

:wave:
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Re: Is there a compromise?

Fell Tel said:
TWhat if Hall made a commitment to resign in January.
Hall's commitments mean nothing to me.

If he's resigning in January and he fully expects BU to takeover the club - then he can resign NOW.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Update time.

I, as a fully paid-up member of the Awkward Squad, raised a Dispute under the BU Constitution that Hall was given the opportunity to issue a statement that would go out to members. I felt that was unfair for many, many reasons.

I spoke to Cllr Girton on the point (who, let's face it, probably has a little more experience of the ins-and-outs of procedure for motions and debates than a lot of us), his observation was that by BU offering Hall this opportunity they had opened the motion to debate and therefore the proper way to handle the situation was for each side to issue a "debating paper" that will be distributed with the motion. Between us we agreed that this would be an acceptable compromise.

The BU Board have agreed to this and therefore I have withdrawn my Dispute.

BIAS, as the original sponsor of the motion, will be putting together a debating paper in support of the motion. There are over 150 proposers of the motion, I expect that all of those proposers are entitled to put their views forward in a debating paper. However, I would suggest that it is better if all argument is channeled through BIAS.

Hall will also be submitted his own "debating paper" that will be distributed with the SGM paperwork.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Now we're going to have a debate! I'm losing the will to live and think I'll go and put my wrists in the oven.

Surely, with the increasing probability that BU will take over 20 January (courtesy of the "mystery local businessman"), Hall is a complete irrelevance. Even a debate is a waste of breath and the best course of action is to ignore him – he is no more, a lame duck, yesterday’s man. Ignoring him is probably a bigger insult to his ego than getting him to resign a week or two early. This motion could possibly turn him into a martyr in some peoples’ eyes. I don’t want to waste any more of my time on this pompous old fart.

Of course, the "mystery local businessman" could turn out to be... G Hall!!! Then we really would have something to debate.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Just to let everyone know that the BU Board, BIAS (on behalf of the proposers) and Graham Hall has agrees that the vote will be taken under the auspices of the BU Code of Conduct for BFC Club Directors. This means that a simple majority (i.e 50% + 1 vote) will be required to carry the motion at the EGM and NOT a 2/3rds majority.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Would the Chairman have to go wilth the staus quo.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

blunstonebabe said:
It is all so sad ---- a very small club tearing itself apart from within again.
I don't believe it's tearing itself apart. This is democracy.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

blunstonebabe said:
It is all so sad ---- a very small club tearing itself apart from within again.

In some ways, I see this as the final purge that BFC needs to rid itself of the many years of mis-management. I hope that finally we will end up with a properly run club that acts , first and foremost, for the benefit of the fans and the local community. If there is a pain to go through to get the right people in place to do this, so be it.
 
Last edited:

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

blunstonebabe said:
It is all so sad ---- a very small club tearing itself apart from within again.



Thats the line the likes of Hall, White, Herting, Finch, McGlashen, King, Rogers and Noades would have you believe and why? Well because if we dont purge, they will shall never really know or understand exactly how they have ****ed things up at GP. How can we get better if we dont understand how sick we really are?

Just wait for the bleating about personal differences being the sole reason behind these issues, its nonsense, its business and if the current and previous BFC's Boards had acted like proper businessmen with half an inch of passion for BFC, we wouldn't find ourselves in this situation.

Let no one forget, that BU for all their faults are not to blame for this sorry mess, the privilege belongs to the likes of Lange, Webb, Noades, Rogers and Co. They are the real villains here, along with all their various lackeys over the last 10 years or so.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Brickie Chap said:
Thats the line the likes of Hall, White, Herting, Finch, McGlashen, King, Rogers and Noades would have you believe and why? Well because if we dont purge, they will shall never really know or understand exactly how they have ****ed things up at GP. How can we get better if we dont understand how sick we really are?

Just wait for the bleating about personal differences being the sole reason behind these issues, its nonsense, its business and if the current and previous BFC's Boards had acted like proper businessmen with half an inch of passion for BFC, we wouldn't find ourselves in this situation.

Let no one forget, that BU for all their faults are not to blame for this sorry mess, the privilege belongs to the likes of Lange, Webb, Noades, Rogers and Co. They are the real villains here, along with all their various lackeys over the last 10 years or so.

:imwith: :sorted:
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

This isn't sad. I think its exciting. It is democracy in action. If it had happened earlier - and to be honest we should have done something like this following the Southampton Ticketing Fiasco - then those who run our club would have realised that they can't behave in a certain way without being held responsible.

As I - almost - said at the BU AGM it's all fine and dandy stating that this is disruptive and that we are creating a blame culture but that's not what this is about. It is about making it clear to those who represent us that they will be held responsible for their actions - or inactions. That they can't treat this club as a nice addition to their CV, preside over cock-up after cock-up and expect to get away with it.

If that puts people off then good. If your afraid of a little responsibility then you shouldn't be getting involved.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Brickie Chap said:
Thats the line the likes of Hall, White, Herting, Finch, McGlashen, King, Rogers and Noades would have you believe and why? Well because if we dont purge, they will shall never really know or understand exactly how they have ****ed things up at GP. How can we get better if we dont understand how sick we really are?

Just wait for the bleating about personal differences being the sole reason behind these issues, its nonsense, its business and if the current and previous BFC's Boards had acted like proper businessmen with half an inch of passion for BFC, we wouldn't find ourselves in this situation.

Let no one forget, that BU for all their faults are not to blame for this sorry mess, the privilege belongs to the likes of Lange, Webb, Noades, Rogers and Co. They are the real villains here, along with all their various lackeys over the last 10 years or so.
:imwith:

This could be Brickie's best ever post :eek:
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Brickie Chap said:
Thats the line the likes of Hall, White, Herting, Finch, McGlashen, King, Rogers and Noades would have you believe and why? Well because if we dont purge, they will shall never really know or understand exactly how they have ****ed things up at GP. How can we get better if we dont understand how sick we really are?

Just wait for the bleating about personal differences being the sole reason behind these issues, its nonsense, its business and if the current and previous BFC's Boards had acted like proper businessmen with half an inch of passion for BFC, we wouldn't find ourselves in this situation.

Let no one forget, that BU for all their faults are not to blame for this sorry mess, the privilege belongs to the likes of Lange, Webb, Noades, Rogers and Co. They are the real villains here, along with all their various lackeys over the last 10 years or so.


Brickie,

Does this mean that you are finally coming around to the right way of thinking... :eek:
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Brickie Chap said:
Thats the line the likes of Hall, White, Herting, Finch, McGlashen, King, Rogers and Noades would have you believe and why? Well because if we dont purge, they will shall never really know or understand exactly how they have ****ed things up at GP. How can we get better if we dont understand how sick we really are?

Just wait for the bleating about personal differences being the sole reason behind these issues, its nonsense, its business and if the current and previous BFC's Boards had acted like proper businessmen with half an inch of passion for BFC, we wouldn't find ourselves in this situation.

Let no one forget, that BU for all their faults are not to blame for this sorry mess, the privilege belongs to the likes of Lange, Webb, Noades, Rogers and Co. They are the real villains here, along with all their various lackeys over the last 10 years or so.

:imwith: :sorted:

A very "we shall fight them on the beaches"-esque post Sir ! :yes:
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Following on from BC's post, a News Feed coincidentally threw up a "this was the week that was ..." piece from 14 years ago. At that time, we were top of League 2 ahead of Brimingham City and West Brom. If anyone wants to question people's motives, you only have to look at the relative history of these three clubs to see why people are passionate about the catalogue of failures that have harmed our club.

Since the FA Cup 6th Round in 1989, there have been a number of opportunities where we could have "kicked on" and established ourselves at a higher level but time and again, mis-management has prevented us from doing so.

We've got a manager capable of taking us forward and I think that supporters are determined to make sure that people who don't act in the best interests of the club, either cynically or through ineptitude, will no longer be tolerated.
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Stuardo said:
Brickie,

Does this mean that you are finally coming around to the right way of thinking... :eek:



I wouldn't say my thinking has really changed that much, maybe not all I get up to/think, gets posted on here ;)

However, I am disappointed that DW wasn't able to, or hasn't yet, delivered what I thought him capable of. As for the others, never thought they were really up to the task and I'd be most surprised if you find any comments from me that disagree with that :sorted:
 

BU EGM: 22nd December 2005

Brickie Chap said:
Nah, I think the one calling you a silly Welsh twit beats it :wave:
Normal Service has been resumed :(


:D
 
Back
Top Bottom