BU EGM: 22nd December 2005
At the BU Board Meeting tonight the 150 signed requisitions were presented. The Board then resolved to call an SGM for 22nd December to debate the motion that BIAS has been organising the collection of signatures for.
The BU Board then voted 7-3 with 2 abstaining that Graham Hall be given the "right of reply" and that his statement would be included with the SGM notice. I fail to see any constitution rule or right why an individual be given the chance to have a statement (either for or against a particular motion) distributed to members. The motion was submitted in accordance with the constitution and I don't expect the BU Board to make up rules on the fly. The BU Board is again having its cake and eating it - they refused to let Paul Stedman's motion onto the AGM Agenda citing the BU Constitution and now they ignore it when they want to.
Before the Board vote the Chairman was amending the motion proposed by another board member deleting words like "right of reply" and substituting it with "statement" - he then gave the most biased summing up since Rumpole of the Bailey was out of print in favour of Hall getting his revenge in first. The Chairmen then cleverly abstained from the vote - and before you say he has to - he raised his hand and was recorded as one of the two abstainers.
Graham Hall now has the opportunity to write the same number of words as was used in the motion to right a reply. He can introduce new argument, rebutt the motion point by point. There will be no statement included from someone supporting the motion. I'm staggered by the sheer lunacy of it all.
I have informed the BU Board that I may submit a Dispute in accordance with the BU Constitution.
The BU Board did also confirm that a vote on the motion will require a two-thirds majority to instruct the BU Board. However, Graham Hall is bound individually by the BFC Code of Conduct for Club Directors which means that has to abide by a simple majority vote.
The BU Board then voted 7-3 with 2 abstaining that Graham Hall be given the "right of reply" and that his statement would be included with the SGM notice. I fail to see any constitution rule or right why an individual be given the chance to have a statement (either for or against a particular motion) distributed to members. The motion was submitted in accordance with the constitution and I don't expect the BU Board to make up rules on the fly. The BU Board is again having its cake and eating it - they refused to let Paul Stedman's motion onto the AGM Agenda citing the BU Constitution and now they ignore it when they want to.
Before the Board vote the Chairman was amending the motion proposed by another board member deleting words like "right of reply" and substituting it with "statement" - he then gave the most biased summing up since Rumpole of the Bailey was out of print in favour of Hall getting his revenge in first. The Chairmen then cleverly abstained from the vote - and before you say he has to - he raised his hand and was recorded as one of the two abstainers.
Graham Hall now has the opportunity to write the same number of words as was used in the motion to right a reply. He can introduce new argument, rebutt the motion point by point. There will be no statement included from someone supporting the motion. I'm staggered by the sheer lunacy of it all.
I have informed the BU Board that I may submit a Dispute in accordance with the BU Constitution.
The BU Board did also confirm that a vote on the motion will require a two-thirds majority to instruct the BU Board. However, Graham Hall is bound individually by the BFC Code of Conduct for Club Directors which means that has to abide by a simple majority vote.

