The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

B.U.G.S.

INVALID EMAIL
Joined
20 Jan 2006
Messages
1
Reaction score
0

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

BUGS welcomes the news that Bees United is now the major shareholder in Brentford Football Club. It has been a long and difficult journey for all concerned – all that is except for Ron Noades.

When Ron Noades took over control of Brentford Football Club in the summer of 1998 he remarked on his luck in finding a club outside the Premiership with little or no debt, and pledged to fund it. Initially this funding appeared generous; having first appointed himself team manager on an salary of £168,300, he bought for himself an impressive squad including spending £750,000 on Hermann Hreidarsson from Crystal Palace.

Brentford supporters were oblivious to the fact that there was no “funding”, instead he borrowed against Griffin Park drowning the club in debt. He deliberately ran the club at a loss and re-structured the company ownership so that he could write off the losses he was making at Brentford against profits he was making at his other leisure and property companies – reducing his overall tax bill.

Brentford supporters have calculated that Ron Noades and his other companies benefitted to the tune of £2m from the raping of Brentford Football Club from group taxation relief, inter-company services, accountancy charges. Deducting the £850k that he paid for the club leaves him at least £1m in front and the £1m “loan” that he has made to the club is some of this profit. BUGS calls on Noades to drop this debt that is actually the money of the supporters.

Once he had banged up against the club's overdraft limit he refused to pay the March 2003 wage bill claiming he wasn't going to “fund” the club any longer. Instead he dumped the problem on supporters' group Bees United, and it was supporters monies that went towards the payroll in exchange for two directorships.

Noades's legacy is a club with £9 million of debt and a club where fans are left to rattle buckets to pay off his legacy. Noades and Altonwood clearly feel that they have no reason to help tidy up the mess which they created.

In this the aftermath of the takeover we want to remind everyone that the future of Brentford Football Club is still in the balance. This situation was created by Ron Noades and Altonwood and whilst Brentford Football Club struggles to pay-off this outstanding debt Ron Noades and Altonwood will not have lost a penny. In fact he is still insisting on full repayment on one £250,000 loan despite purchasing the same debt from former Chairman Tony Swaisland for only £230,000.

Brentford Unofficial Group of Supporters (B.U.G.S.)
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Ron noades... will not go to heavan :nono:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Thank you for that...BUGS.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

It certainly not Graham Haynes as the author. ;) :D
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Nice and clear... what a **** :mad2:

Cannot wait for the day he dies so we can have one hours clapping before a match :bound:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Is BUGS related to Winston Bee?
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

80% of the worlds living species have 6 legs - FACT :computer:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

B.U.G.S. said:
...Brentford supporters were oblivious to the fact that there was no “funding”, ...

Personally I was not oblivious to the fact at all, and I therefore was not impressed when he spent our money on the players. I even said so at the time.

Noades made no secret of the fact that he was guaranteeing our overdraft rather than putting real cash into the club.

It may sound harsh but all the warning signs were there. We were too busy cheering at being top of Div 3 (or 2 or 4 or whatever the one above the conference was called then) to pay attention to the fact he might leave us high and dry.

Lets hope we've learnt our lesson, and when the new regime make the hard choices to secure our future they don't immediately get slated by the fan base who are dissapointed at the sale of Tabb, DJ, Sodje or whoever...
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

David Merritt said:
Personally I was not oblivious to the fact at all, and I therefore was not impressed when he spent our money on the players. I even said so at the time.

Nobody likes a smartarse. :D
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Good Summary B.U.G.S.

Now if we could only get this published in the national press............


:fishing:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Lokster said:
Nobody likes a smartarse. :D

I can't claim to be that smart - I didn't stop him doing it. :sad:

I just think we need to look in the mirror at times - the Noades years don't leave us fans smelling of roses either. Thats changed as supporters have got more organised and we now own the club:D . I just hope it continues.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

nocoat said:
Nice and clear... what a **** :mad2:

Cannot wait for the day he dies so we can have one hours clapping before a match :bound:



Unfortunatley you cannot kill the undead.....:eek:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

I quite like noades now and he could have sold us down the river last yr when the deadline expired but he never did, so fair play to the man.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

David Merritt said:
Noades made no secret of the fact that he was guaranteeing our overdraft rather than putting real cash into the club.

Another quick history rewrite. :rolleyes:

Noades insisted that he would be "funding the Club" when he arrived in June 1998. At the 1998 AGM held in December he again stated that he was "funding the Club". At the same meeting he was forcing through a resolution to increase the borrowing powers to £6million and I asked why he was doing this if he was "funding the Club".
Noades didn't answer the question but said to the shareholders "I have just signed Hreidarsson and am giving you a team to be proud of and this is what I have to put up with". Several shareholders were telling me to "Sit down and shut up"

It took another year when the May 1999 accounts were released in December 1999 that it became clear exactly what he was doing and where this was going to lead us and it was about then that I started to post on the GPG trying to tell supporters what was happening and where in my view we were gonna finish up. I subsequently wrote an article in TITS which so enraged Noades that he threatened to sue me which would have been perfectly alright with me.

Don't come on here telling me that Noades made no secret of it.......it was dragged out of him when it got to the point that he couldn't deny it as it was clear to anyone with access to the audited accounts. I don't recall getting that much help from you at the time in putting the Signy's of this world and other supporters straight if you now tell us that you were aware all along of what was happening.
 
Last edited:

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

nocoat said:
Nice and clear... what a **** :mad2:

Cannot wait for the day he dies so we can have one hours clapping before a match :bound:

Oh, what a ****ing party We'll all have that day.:sorted: :bound:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Dangerous said:
I quite like noades now and he could have sold us down the river last yr when the deadline expired but he never did, so fair play to the man.


Thats what i like dangerous a bit of controversy!!!!!!!!!:sorted:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

abee said:
... At the same meeting he was forcing through a resolution to increase the borrowing powers to £6million ...

So presumably that means it wasn't secret then? Or was it a "secret resolution"? :confused:

Have I done something in a previous life to offend you abee? You seem to take most things I post as some kind of personal attack, and haven't responded to my offer to chat. (the offer is still there if you want to)

I'm not saying Noades was explaining nice and clearly that he'd be able to walk away leaving us with all the problems, but the warning signs were there all along. Perhaps rather than saying "Noades made no secret..." I should have said "It was no secret...", but you can hardly accuse me of being a Noades-apologist.

Far from trying to re-write history I was trying to make sure we remembered it, including the bits we'd rather forget.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Dangerous said:
I quite like noades now and he could have sold us down the river last yr when the deadline expired but he never did, so fair play to the man.

What Drugs are you on. wake up, we're going down that river now . why the ****ing hell am I paying a standing order and chucking my hard earnt into a bucket? Because that thieving bastard Noades raped our football club.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

David Merritt

I will tell you one thing I don`t blame the fans one bit for not smelling a rat or not dissecting BFC financials with anything other than "I know it`s bad but at least Mr Noades said he is funding the club". This message was being communicated by official sources and by some extent respected figures outside of the club.

I think your comments are a little unfair, but I have learn`t now to be very wary of Greg Dyke.;) :D
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Dangerous said:
I quite like noades now and he could have sold us down the river last yr when the deadline expired but he never did, so fair play to the man.

Should there be an irony smilie at the end of this?
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

David Merritt said:
So presumably that means it wasn't secret then? Or was it a "secret resolution"? :confused:

Have I done something in a previous life to offend you abee? You seem to take most things I post as some kind of personal attack, and haven't responded to my offer to chat. (the offer is still there if you want to)

I'm not saying Noades was explaining nice and clearly that he'd be able to walk away leaving us with all the problems, but the warning signs were there all along. Perhaps rather than saying "Noades made no secret..." I should have said "It was no secret...", but you can hardly accuse me of being a Noades-apologist.

Far from trying to re-write history I was trying to make sure we remembered it, including the bits we'd rather forget.

It wasn't a "secret resolution". He increased almost immediately the borrowing powers of Brentford Football & Sports Club Ltd from £2million to £6million. That tripped my wires and I suspected but couldn't prove at that time that he was just borrowing against the ultimate security of Griffin Park.As I have posted it was not until the 1999 accounts were sent to the shareholders that what I had suspected was confirmed. As you wish to be a non-executive director of BFC you may care to comment on how you view the role of the BFC non-execs in this matter who happily went along with what Noades was doing to the great detriment I insist of Brentford Football Club and its future. I am interested because if successful in the election you will be working with Rogers and Herting so your views on how they conducted themselves during the Noades regime are of interest certainly to me if not others.

I don't want to chat with you thank you very much but I have no personal problem with you trying to now get onto the BFC board. I certainly have not taken any post of yours as a personal attack on me but you are the only supporter/director candidate who has been posting regularly so of course your opinions and views attract my attention.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Ace Face said:
This message was being communicated by official sources and by some extent respected figures outside of the club.

I never thought I would hear that from you! I thought you'd been cynical for years!!?

Don't get me wrong - I'm not saying this is all our fault - or anything like it. Noades controlled the club, Noades... did whats best for Noades(!). But we'd just come out of the W£bb era where W£bb controlled the club and... did whats best for W£bb! It shouldn't have been that much of a surprise, even if we didn't know/understand/guess the exact detail of how he was doing it.

Blame the fans - not at all. Realise that as fans we should wake up, smell the coffee and expect good management rather than big signings - absolutely. We should have realised that about 30 years ago, or 8 years ago, or 4 years ago, or... well hopefully we have realised it now.

Looking in the mirror never does anyone any harm, although in your case I wouldn't recommend it to often! :D
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

I think your comments are a little unfair, but I have learn`t now to be very wary of Greg Dyke.;) :D[/QUOTE]
You and me both Ace.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

David Merritt said:
I
Looking in the mirror never does anyone any harm, although in your case I wouldn't recommend it to often! :D

:sorted: lol Mirrors are banned in my house.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

abee said:
...As you wish to be a non-executive director of BFC you may care to comment on how you view the role of the BFC non-execs in this matter who happily went along with what Noades was doing to the great detriment I insist of Brentford Football Club and its future. I am interested because if successful in the election you will be working with Rogers and Herting so your views on how they conducted themselves during the Noades regime are of interest certainly to me if not others...

I sincerely hope it is of interest to everyone given the state our finances are in.

In answer to your question, I agree with you that what happened during those years was to the detriment of the club(/company), and therefore I think that every director of the company should have voted against them. Noades would have just forced it through with a shareholder resolution, but thats besides the point - I would be interested to see their justification that spending that amount of money in that short a period was ever going to return a profit.

Business is all about taking risks, and you can't criticise someone for taking a risk just because with hindsight it didn't pay off. What you CAN criticise is when people take risks where they haven't thought through the implications, where they haven't done their sums, or when they take the word/direction of someone who has a conflict of interests because he (Noades) is lending the cash.

What worries me is that this recent saga re the business plan recently indicates that there isn't a lot of risk planning now either. The important thing about a budget isn't so much the figure as the risk profile around the figure. I found it very difficult to distill fact from the rumour and conjecture, but it sounded to me that either they didn't have a handle on the risk profile, or that they weren't tracking the actuals very well (or both).
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

excellent article and summary! :sorted:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

David Merritt said:
Business is all about taking risks, and you can't criticise someone for taking a risk just because with hindsight it didn't pay off.

Yer kidding right? Business is about taking calculated risks, and if it doesn't pay off, where's the contingency plan?
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

I had to laugh reading the papers today to see that Noades was banned from ‘supporting’ Crystal Palace
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Leicester Bee said:
Yer kidding right? Business is about taking calculated risks, and if it doesn't pay off, where's the contingency plan?

:imwith: I thought business was about minimising risk. :confused:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

BUGS has said what BU can't due to the Noades gagging order :(
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Les Beeavinu said:
:imwith: I thought business was about minimising risk. :confused:

Leicester Bee - if you quoted the next sentence in my original post I think we are of like mind.

Les Beeavinu - no, you are wrong. Profit comes from risk. The riskier the venture, the more profit you expect in return for you taking the risk. Start with risk-free (government bonds) and move up from there. The issue is not about whether a venture is risky or not, its whether the likely returns outweight that risk. What us unforgivable is not scoping out the risk properly before you make a decision.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

nocoat said:
Nice and clear... what a **** :mad2:
I see where you're coming from, but my take on it is that he is a f ucking c unt.

Or possibly a pig shagging ars ehole.

Or perhaps an evil turd-burgling wa nker.
nocoat said:
Cannot wait for the day he dies so we can have one hours clapping before a match :bound:
I agree.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

David Merritt said:
Leicester Bee - if you quoted the next sentence in my original post I think we are of like mind.

Les Beeavinu - no, you are wrong. Profit comes from risk. The riskier the venture, the more profit you expect in return for you taking the risk. Start with risk-free (government bonds) and move up from there. The issue is not about whether a venture is risky or not, its whether the likely returns outweight that risk. What us unforgivable is not scoping out the risk properly before you make a decision.

I'm very sorry that my opinion is wrong. Undoubtedly, you must be right because you have told me so.

I will remember this when I submit my business case for my £2m project next week. I shall not, as expected, highlight to the investment board that this business case is weak because of the lack of demonstrable ROI but I shall instead explain that they should embrace this risk because the "the riskier the venture, the more profit they should expect in return for taking the risk".

It'll be tricky, but I reckon they might just buy it. That is, of course, unless my VP doesn't take me into a darkened room to kick me around the head first when he hears my strategy.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

David Merritt said:
I found it very difficult to distill fact from the rumour and conjecture, but it sounded to me that either they didn't have a handle on the risk profile, or that they weren't tracking the actuals very well (or both).

I think you'll find the actuals weren't tracked 'cos someone's PC was fecked up for a few months :rolleyes:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Risk is an interesting subject to debate.

I train staff in my line of work regarding risk.

I work for the National Health Service in mental health and our level of risk takes into account whether someone lives or dies.

Mr Merritt please have a realistic notion for the value of risk and its daily use in society.

I say this not because I'm erring to the left in my social views but because the football club I love is not only a business but a living breathing organism that has a heart and a soul that does not exist in everyday commerce...the rules dont always apply...but the fickle theory of chaos does...read James Gleick then appply risk!
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

GlasgowBee said:
Risk is an interesting subject to debate.

I train staff in my line of work regarding risk.

I work for the National Health Service in mental health and our level of risk takes into account whether someone lives or dies.

Mr Merritt please have a realistic notion for the value of risk and its daily use in society.

I say this not because I'm erring to the left in my social views but because the football club I love is not only a business but a living breathing organism that has a heart and a soul that does not exist in everyday commerce...the rules dont always apply...but the fickle theory of chaos does...read James Gleick then appply risk!

Mr Merrit says that "business is about taking risks". I disagree. Business is about defining a strategy, identifyng the associated risks and providing mitigation. Only then do you have the conditions to continue with your stategy. To do otherwise would result in failure more often than not (which is why it's a risk!)
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Risk is a negative concept, with an unfavourable outcome....successful business use the terms to appear publically favourable when against the odds it wins.

In true business the odds should only be cashed when a win is guarenteed...the public face of a lucky win is only a wink to camera of haha we fooled the f*****s! Good businessmen know they will win (and I have no problem with that....I wish I had the balls to rake in the cash)...but keep the masses guessing and look cute to camera. When you win its a sort of game show "f*** me I didnt know I was gonna win" gesture thats usually fools most.

This is the bit when I usually screw it up and sound like a Reaganite commie but surely a good businessman doesnt need to take a risk but can use the current market to get the best...or are there a bunch of f***wits out there trying to play the part but with f*** all they screw up.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

GlasgowBee said:
Risk is a negative concept, with an unfavourable outcome....successful business use the terms to appear publically favourable when against the odds it wins.

In true business the odds should only be cashed when a win is guarenteed...the public face of a lucky win is only a wink to camera of haha we fooled the f*****s! Good businessmen know they will win (and I have no problem with that....I wish I had the balls to rake in the cash)...but keep the masses guessing and look cute to camera. When you win its a sort of game show "f*** me I didnt know I was gonna win" gesture thats usually fools most.

This is the bit when I usually screw it up and sound like a Reaganite commie but surely a good businessman doesnt need to take a risk but can use the current market to get the best...or are there a bunch of f***wits out there trying to play the part but with f*** all they screw up.

I will read this again in the morning (when I have sobered up) and it might make sense.

:wave: :wave:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

touche...as the turtle once said...I meant one of those reds that reagan used to love so much (add a teaspoon of pathos to taht comment) rather than a member of his inner circle
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

WarrenBee said:
I will read this again in the morning (when I have sobered up) and it might make sense.

:wave: :wave:

I'll rewrite this again when the bottle of red Ive enjoyed by way of celebration at todays news has worn off!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

F*** me BFC are great!
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

GlasgowBee said:
I'll rewrite this again when the bottle of red Ive enjoyed by way of celebration at todays news has worn off!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

F*** me BFC are great!

:D :sorted:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Billy Hunt said:
I see where you're coming from, but my take on it is that he is a f ucking c unt.
.

Hmm, it's a fair comment, I would add though that he is an absolute ****ing ratcunt ****stain.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Les Beeavinu said:
Mr Merrit says that "business is about taking risks". I disagree. Business is about defining a strategy, identifyng the associated risks and providing mitigation. Only then do you have the conditions to continue with your stategy. To do otherwise would result in failure more often than not (which is why it's a risk!)

Exactly. Mr Merritt was spouting from his MBA text books where they are always very good at taking risks with er.........other peoples monies.

I thought that we had had quite enough of these "risks worth taking" experts on the BFC board.

Before David Heath finally agreed to become my nominee on the BFC board it looked as if I may have to do it myself for a short while and I proposed that I was more than happy to share in the "risks worth taking" philosophy on the basis that it was the BFC directors who took the risks with their own monies. That is the budget is set and if the "risks in the budget" didn't come off and that the cash veered off course by say £300k because the er........risks become real liabilities then that £300k was divided by the nine directors and each wrote out a personal cheque as a gift mark you..........not a loan to the Club. My cheque for £33,333.33 for my share would be with the accountant in short order but if anyone wouldn't or couldn't agree then they should stop spouting about "taking risks" and resign from the board.

I really thought that we had seen the back of this crap. :(
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

Idaho Bee said:
Good Summary B.U.G.S.

Now if we could only get this published in the national press............


:fishing:


Feed me the whole truth and I think I know someone who could get it done:fishing: pm's welcome:sorted:
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

I don’t mean to offend, but I stick by what I said. Profit comes from risk. This might be MBA text book stuff, but I would welcome someone to disprove it. If you can find a risk-free profitable business I’ll sign up now. The closest I can think of is the local bank (and customers with Barings will tell you even that’s not totally risk-free).

In the absence of these non-existent risk-free businesses, we are left with risky ones. Which ones are riskier than others, and which ones have the greater returns than others, is what business is all about. Investing in the club shop was risky, investing in players is risky, investing in a refurbished stadium is risky, investing in a new stadium is risky… can anyone think of anything we think the club ought to do that is NOT risky? You might come up with great suggestions that you think “guarantee” the club makes money, but there is always a risk that you might be wrong.

GlasgowBee – I can’t comment on how the government puts a value on healthcare – they have my utmost admiration and it is a very difficult decision. For the very reasons you state (heart and soul etc) I WILL comment on how BFC secures its future. That is by making a profit and reducing the debt. If you can find a risk-free way of reducing the debt I’d like to hear it.

Les Beeavinu – I say “business is about taking risks”. You state you disagree, and then state “Business is about… identifying the associated risks…”. I don’t understand where we disagree. As for your investment board, they will look at your ROI, compare it with the risks they see in your strategy, and decide. Which is exactly what I said in the first place.

abee – I disapprove of someone who thinks that the fact they’ve invested money in our club means they can be more flippant about what they do with it. That’s what has got us into this mess, and the whole reason BU ownership should be better than before. You almost suggest that no-one should be on the board who hasn’t invested – is that really what you think? If you think taking risks is “crap” then I’d welcome your views on how you expect the club to pay of its £8m debt with risk-free initiatives.

This whole issue is the reason why I think the club board is so important – they will be making decisions that will impact on the future of the club. Football is a risky business, and it is the board’s job to manage those risks.

There is no point in having a director on the board who cannot contribute to those decisions.
 

The Legacy of Ron Noades – What a Legacy!

David Merritt said:
abee – I disapprove of someone who thinks that the fact they’ve invested money in our club means they can be more flippant about what they do with it. That’s what has got us into this mess, and the whole reason BU ownership should be better than before. You almost suggest that no-one should be on the board who hasn’t invested – is that really what you think? If you think taking risks is “crap” then I’d welcome your views on how you expect the club to pay of its £8m debt with risk-free initiatives.

I have posted before several times that I do not believe that people have a right to be on the BFC board just because they have "bought a seat".

If they truly have the interests of the Club at heart they use their board entitlement to appoint someone who has skills far more suited to the current needs of the Club than has the investor.

This is why I nominated David Heath for a directorship rather than go on the board myself.

I actually said I think that I find your views crap and you just seem to come on here spouting pages from the "MBA for Dummies" manual. I see nothing in your cv or far more importantly your current posts outlining your philosophy that would bring anything to the party.

You seem to be oblivious to the fact that it was taking risks where we could not afford the downside that took us from having monies in the bank to a £9million debt in just over seven years. Of course there are risks and risks and as far as I am concerned my yardstick (and I was doing this stuff when you were in nappies) is I always insist on saying to my General Managers :- "Don't tell me about all of the wonderful money that we are gonna make with this scheme........tell me what is the worst that could happen if (when) it all goes wrong".

I suggest that if Rogers and Herting had used that guide they would have figured out that "the worst that could happen" when they were sleepwalking through Noades "funding" of the Club against the ultimate security of Griffin Park would be an unsustainable debt that can only be repaid by the eventual sale of the only company asset worth talking about i.e. the stadium.

I can argue that I took a "risk" by putting £250k into the Club. By my yardstick I can afford to lose it and therefore the risk is sustainable. If I only had £260k in the bank then it would have been a stupid thing to do.

I was suggesting that people have more of a care with their own monies than with other peoples and that if the directors had to pay for their own mistakes and misjudgements then we wouldn't be hearing so much about the "risks worth taking". If you are proposing to take your "risks" with my £250k then I would sooner have it back please and take the "risks" myself 'cos I am certainly better at caring for my own monies than you. This is not why I put monies into the Club and is not as far as I am aware the philosophy of Bees United. You have a right to your views but I totally disagree with them.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom