The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Were the club right to sell DJ?


  • Total voters
    393

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

:banghead: let it go man!!! :cry:

Yes.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

It doesn't feel good - but yes.

Having slept on it it's not so bad :cry:

Lil' FB wasn't as bothered as I'd thought he'd be...

"but we need the money Dad & Martin's always saying he wants our players to play in the Prem..."

...if a ten year old can deal with it then :shrug:
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

I have voted yes, or the presumption that

(a) This money will be vital in meeting our obligations with regarding to the the release of the Stadium Improvement Grant

Also, the club would have been absolute w***ers if they prevented DJ from this dream move
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Not many voters so far!
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Banana said:
Not many voters so far!

Too many threads on the same subject, everyone is spread out across the site.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

FarnhamBee said:
It doesn't feel good - but yes.

Having slept on it it's not so bad :cry:

Lil' FB wasn't as bothered as I'd thought he'd be...

"but we need the money Dad & Martin's always saying he wants our players to play in the Prem..."

...if a ten year old can deal with it then :shrug:

I didn't take it that well when I was his age.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Agree with Farnham.

Having slept on the news, I do feel that it was and is very good financial sense to both club and player.

However, I can completely sympathise with anyone who is bitterly disappointed with what has become normal as a Brentford fan and that is to see our prized asset taken away.

The one crumb of comfort for me is seeing Mr Sodje still amongst our ranks.
**Sodj is absolutely indispensable** IMHO.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

It's not a question of money, DJ is worth more than a million to us, but at the end of the day if he wants to move one, it's end of story. You can't blame the club.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

It also sends out a message to all the other promising young hopefuls out there, that Martin will develop their talents and a move to the Premiership is possible, if you have the talent.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

...Yes...........
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

short term NO long term YES
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

I was gutted yesterday but today I feel a lot better.

Sam going as well would have tipped me over the edge but as MA said, he would never stand in a players way and the £500k will help to secure the long term future of the club.

Thanks for the memories DJ. :dj: :dj:
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Head say's yes but heart say's unless Mr Willock brings along his shooting boots (or Lloyd and Rankin find theirs) it could cost us automatic promotion. However as others have pointed out how could we reasonably have stood in his way when Birmingham came knocking and of course we need the money, don't know if we could have rung any more money out of Birmingham or what the sell on clauses are though.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Simon C said:
I didn't take it that well when I was his age.

I haven't taken it that well at my age :)

I think he must get his 'sensible side' from his mum lol
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

My lad crumbled, Iwent out and sunk too many pints in a short space of time and got angry but Sam got me sorted.:sorted:

Yes, Good luck DJ!
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

FarnhamBee said:
...if a ten year old can deal with it then :shrug:

lol @ everyone who voted No :fishing:
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Yes. Apart from the joy and thrill of watching him during his brief spell at the club, DJ got us national headline status twice in four days and all for positive news. He has raised our profile, got us past premiership opposition and shown us a bright glimpse of what this club can be. He's also given us the opportunity to raise much-needed cash for our club and provided a windfall for another club far below us.

DJ's brief visit was magical and the effect was immense. He leaves us on a high and before his glory had a chance to become tarnished. He has demonstrated just what a good job MA and his staff are doing, and we will be taken much more seriously and recognised more widely as a result. I don't doubt that there is plenty more to come from others in the squad and DJ's influence means that when they shine it will be even more brightly.

Good luck to the lad.

[later] I just realised I didn't actually say why I think the club was right to sell DJ. The reason is that they had to—there's no right or wrong. Of course I'd have liked him to stay but that's just not possible in the present circumstances, and I'd rather he was allowed the freedom to seize the moment and grasp a golden opportunity than for the club to make a selfish and fruitless attempt to stand in his way.

In today's Mirror DJ says, "I'm very grateful to Brentford for giving me this opportunity". This has done nothing but good for Brentford's reputation and respect.
 
Last edited:

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

I voted no, but only because I was so disappointed to see him go. It is a good fee though and the club needed the money, also no player should have to be held back etc. Its just a big disappointment for the fans after such an outstanding performance for us recently.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

ParaParaBee said:
I voted no, but only because I was so disappointed to see him go. It is a good fee though and the club needed the money, also no player should have to be held back etc. Its just a big disappointment for the fans after such an outstanding performance for us recently.
Doesn't sounds like a "no" to me :scratch:
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Banana said:
Doesn't sounds like a "no" to me :scratch:

I guess I'll go with BRENTFORD_TILL_DIE's answer, short term no-long time yes. It feels like a kick in the stomach at the moment but time will probably show it to be a good move.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

YES!!!!!!!!!!!!! BS should have had a little ambition.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

I bet he doesn't destroy his reputation with ill-judged remarks and behaviour towards Brentford and its supporters, unlike a certain M****n R******s.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

FarnhamBee said:
It doesn't feel good - but yes.

Having slept on it it's not so bad :cry:

Lil' FB wasn't as bothered as I'd thought he'd be...

"but we need the money Dad & Martin's always saying he wants our players to play in the Prem..."

...if a ten year old can deal with it then :shrug:

I'm glad yours could, mine couldn't still a very fed up 10 year old this morning:(

He was happy about Sam though
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

i think that a lot of doubters re going to feel better about
dj's departure if the team give a perfomance against walsall
and CW looks the part
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

We are going to miss DJ big time. Where are goals going to come from? The lad was looking like scoring every time he got a chance. Don`t see how we had much choice. Skint aren`t we! Money on the table from a prem. club = transfer. Good luck DJ, you may need it, this transfer could simply be too soon.

Maybe LLoyd and the new bloke will hit it off together, or Scott Fitz will take his chance and produce the goods. Who knows. Come on you Bees.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Having slept on it definitely had to take the cash and give DJ the opportunity.
The worrying thing is the fact we were so willing to also let Sodje and Hutch go at the same time. Whilst I doubt Hutch would command more than £50K in the market it is worrying that we were still happy to accept such an offer. How desperate are we ? I would rather the new board clearly stated the position we are in rather than Greg Dyke spouting off about how we will be in the Championship within 5 years and bigger than QPR blah blah blah........At least properly manage the fans expectations then these kind of things wont come as such a massive kick in the b******s.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

What's this about an offer for Hutch? Who from - the RNIB? Seriously - a bid for Hutch? Why wasn't it accepted? Nah, its a wind up you silly person!
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

No because we could have got more than the 400K we have now at the end of the season and I fear we have very little chance of seeing the extra money.

One thing puzzles me. If 210 people to date think that the we did the right thing in selling DJ why are presumably some of these same people happy that Sam is still here when we could have doubled our money last night and got closer to getting the SP off our back?
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Because we can go up without DJ and we can't without Sam. :sorted:
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Jimbee said:
Because we can go up without DJ and we can't without Sam. :sorted:

Hope you are right, fear you are not

Start to see on Saturday - come on Fitz and Callum and get fit soon Alex
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Jimbee said:
Because we can go up without DJ and we can't without Sam. :sorted:


RUBBISH!!

To get promotion you need a goalscorer...no argument!
And we've just sold ours for 400k

The money will get swollowed up by the massive debt, we'll still be around £9million in debt and we wont go up, thus loosing the opportunity of making more money next year in the Championship and on selling players at the end of the season at greater prices.

I voted a definate NO

As for not standing in the way of DJ.
He is contracted to BFC and at the first official approach by Birmingscum they should've been told that no-one is for sale thankyou...and **** off!
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Edmundo said:
I bet he doesn't destroy his reputation with ill-judged remarks and behaviour towards Brentford and its supporters, unlike a certain M****n R******s.
Q*R weren't in the premiership
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

wish he could have gone after we had been knocked out of the cup.
We would have won at Charlton with him
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

west london bee said:
As for not standing in the way of DJ.
He is contracted to BFC and at the first official approach by Birmingscum they should've been told that no-one is for sale thankyou...and **** off!

And what would that have done for team morale.

Like it or not at the moment this club is a stepping stone for the players who want to get to the very top.
When a Premiership club comes knocking we can't turnm it down, or expect the player to.

Why should he continue to try if we are going to stop him going anywhere.

We need to look at the bigger picture on this one, I belive we have got a good price, kept the players believing they can achieve and move on from our club and allowed ourselves to improve our ground.

It might be that we suffer on the pitch without DJ but we weren't a one man team and you're wrong if you think otherwise.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

My head says Yes.

My heart says No.

I'm STILL gutted but it HAS to be.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

west london bee said:
RUBBISH!!

To get promotion you need a goalscorer...no argument!
And we've just sold ours for 400k

The money will get swollowed up by the massive debt, we'll still be around £9million in debt and we wont go up, thus loosing the opportunity of making more money next year in the Championship and on selling players at the end of the season at greater prices.

I voted a definate NO

As for not standing in the way of DJ.
He is contracted to BFC and at the first official approach by Birmingscum they should've been told that no-one is for sale thankyou...and **** off!

We were top of the League half way through the season and DJ had scored the sum total of 4 goals. Since then, he's got another 8, 3 were in the Cup and 1 was against Southend. He's had a great month but that's all. Work it out for yourself.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Many more wannabe players will now knock on Brentford's door, after seeeing how MA/AWs coaching has transformed DJ. Credit must be given to them and the scouts for this.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

lardy arse in doors says its only a game and get over it ,I hope I havent broken her nose ,it wont look good in the divorce courts.I voted yes,but ,no.but yes.but no......
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

bee1958 said:
Many more wannabe players will now knock on Brentford's door, after seeeing how MA/AWs coaching has transformed DJ. Credit must be given to them and the scouts for this.

:imwith:
Absolutely.

But I still can't see where the goals needed to get us out of this division are going to come from.
This club has made a very big and obvious statement with this deal. See you all in League 1 next season.

My vote?.............. No. :sad: Wrong time, not enough money.
Think about it. Birmingscum had been following DJ for approx 6 weeks. They only made a move following his elevated profile, fearing that another premiershite club was going to beat them to it. It therefore made sense to hold out for a better offer, because I truly believe that one was just around the corner.
Don't agree with what's been done. Don't like what's been done. Do however understand the money aspect, AND wish DJ all the very best for the future.
Good luck Son.:wave:
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

when you 'sign' for brentford - as a supporter not a player - you must know that brentford is, and always has been, a selling club. it is a fact. it is the way it survives.

every few years a favourite or exciting player is sold on and, hard as it is, it is the name of game when supporting a small club.

dj has moved-on rather quicker than most (usually they have stayed 18 months or a couple of seasons) but the club is in dire straits at the moment.

mansley, docherty, sinton, cross, houston and hermann were a few of my particular favourites over a long period of bees watching --- there were others too.

it is essemtial that fans accept this and continue to support our manager and new chairman - difficult as it may be at the moment.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Although i believe after a few days thought it was the right decision, i still think that the fee we secured was less than it ought to have been. HAving had a chat with my mate who is a WBA ST holder, he has heard about DJ from me, seen him on MOTD and so on and would rate him as much better than Earnshaw. Proverbially his jaw hit the floor when i told him Brum had secured DJ's service for 1/2mil (think he wanted to know why Bryan Robson hadnt nipped in a bit quicker with at least double).

However at the end of the day had we told the scum where to stick it, we would have achieved nothing and made MA's job much harder. We survive on taking chances on good lower league players or those who are out of favour elsewhere they are told that Brentford will be a vehicle for propelling/restarting their career and if someone comes in they will be allowed to go. Morale and belief in MA would have disappeared overnight if DJ had not been allowed to further himself.

Of course we can still win promotion, yes we will need someone to bang in a few goals of course, but i still think the target of promotion would have been much more seriously affected by the departure of the likes of Sam, Tabby, Turner and co. We should remember that we managed to finish 4th last season with a negative goal difference.

Anyway for all we know Mr Willock could be even more prolific than DJ.....i remember he was very tricky to play against last season and I believe he scored 14 goals in a relegation side not bad when you consider our top scorer scored less than that and we finished 4th.

We CAN get promotion....:wave:
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

northantsbee said:
HAving had a chat with my mate who is a WBA ST holder, he has heard about DJ from me, seen him on MOTD and so on and would rate him as much better than Earnshaw. Proverbially his jaw hit the floor when i told him Brum had secured DJ's service for 1/2mil (think he wanted to know why Bryan Robson hadnt nipped in a bit quicker with at least double).

Earnshaw has scored over 100 goals in his career and is a year older than DJ. He's also played over 20 times for his country, scoring 9 goals and he's scored in every division.

Much as I like DJ, he ain't in that class. Yet.
 

The definitive poll: Were the club right to sell DJ?

Les Beeavinu said:
Earnshaw has scored over 100 goals in his career and is a year older than DJ. He's also played over 20 times for his country, scoring 9 goals and he's scored in every division.

Much as I like DJ, he ain't in that class. Yet.

Thats what I said, but my mate was adamant Earnshaw is lazy and rubbish apparently, he would have paid someone to take him away. Only going on what i have been told.......
 
Back
Top Bottom