Youth and Centre of Excellence

SmiffyBee

A Beautiful Lie
Joined
23 Mar 2005
Messages
45,892
Reaction score
9,725

Youth and Centre of Excellence

I am a little concerned that over the last few seasons, the players coming through our own youth system are not deemed up to the standard of the 1st team.

Is this because they are "blooded" too early, exposed to the harsh realities of lower league football and suffer a drop in confidence and / or crowd harrassment ?

Is it because they are not given their chance soon enough ?

Is it because they are not given enough football at conference or regional conference level ?

Recently we have seen ............

Charles, Ide, Dark, Masters, Peters, Carder-Andrews, Aaron Steele, Ryan Watts, Hillier, Palmer, Jay Smith, Scott Weight

.............all passing through Griffin Park and out to elsewhere, usually out of pyramid level football after a few years.

Discuss ? :confused: :sorted: :worm:
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

All the local talent is being scooped up by Premiership clubs, who are allowed to tell 12-year-olds they have a guaranteed professional contract when they reach 17, which is something we can't do.

You seem to forget Michael Dobson and Kevin O'Connor if you're mentioning Jay Smith.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

How does this compare historically? How many youth players that make the grade would we expect to be producing? And how do our rivals compare?
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

That's just the tip of the iceberg. We've only ever occasionally unearthed a gem, but we do tend to drop them in early and expect the finished article when we have an under-19.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

I think that Osborne, Charles and Ide all have a chance of becoming decent footballers.
The ones that I actually saw of the rest were nowhere near good enough and it's as simple as that, isn't it. I don't know what the ratio is but for every Millen there seem to be 100s of Darks and doesn't it go beyond grooming and rest on talent and attitude.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

I guess if they're being plucked by Premiershite clubs its all revelant.How many of the top clubs academy players ever make the first team?Most drift off into " obscurity " in the lower leagues.Our signing today came through West Ams set up didnt he?
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

All the local talent is being scooped up by Premiership clubs, who are allowed to tell 12-year-olds they have a guaranteed professional contract when they reach 17, which is something we can't do.

You seem to forget Michael Dobson and Kevin O'Connor if you're mentioning Jay Smith.

I left out all our successes....and your first point is clearly very valid.

It must be depressing for all clubs "like us" to think this arm of possible revunue / success on the field has been taken by the "top clubs" :sad: :cry:
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Another reason that must not be forgotten is that at our level the amount of funding available for academy football has to be limited and I imagine it is quite a balancing act trying to keep it afloat when the money is desperately needed elsewhere.

Occassionally a nuggett will apear but lets face it to find a nuggett in Shrewsbury where there is little local competition is one hell of a lot easier than in the metropolis where we are factually the lowest London league club, and any player with ambition and skill is unlikeley to be missed by the big London alternatives.

A fact of life I guess and a slippery slope in my view for the future of football in this country as unless a succesful youth level is available across the board the present problems will continue as youngsters will generate to the big clubs, fail to impress and wander out of football, if on the other hand these kids could develop at all clubs a few more of them might go on to have a decent career and even as thet develop break into the big time.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Its a good question but I don't think it has anything to do with the Premiership who are increasingly going abroad for their youths and at the end of the day you only have one main youth team at each age group.

I have no stats to back it up but I get the impression that most of our London FL competitors do better at getting solid professsional players out of their youth system. Certainly the likes of Palace, QPR, Millwall and even Orient seem to generate a reasonable string of players who make it. Watford I gather have a really decent set up and a lot of good players coming through at the moment.

I would guess that, however much it pains us to admit it, that our set up is simply not good enough and hasn't been for quite a while.

It has struck me for some time that those players who do get a chance at least seem to lack some basic techniques to add to some undoubted ability. Osborne is a classic example. Good in the air, pacey etc but his passing skills are Rymans level.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Crewe have produced good youths over the past 10 years, why can't we?
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Crewe have produced good youths over the past 10 years, why can't we?

They spend £1 million a year on their academy.
They have a link-up with Liverpool

We have neither the resource or clout to do either.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Factually, we are not the lowest London league club. :thetruth:


Like it or not we're only just ahead of Daggers & Barnet.........
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

They spend £1 million a year on their academy.
They have a link-up with Liverpool

We have neither the resource or clout to do either.

I see they have now stopped putting in that £1M:cool:
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

That's just the tip of the iceberg. We've only ever occasionally unearthed a gem, but we do tend to drop them in early and expect the finished article when we have an under-19.

Marcus Bent :sad:
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

I coach boys at u-17 level in Cambs and the standard of football is quite good. I have seen very good players try out for professional clubs and get released soon afterwards. There isn't a queston mark over their ability but maybe it's a mentality of possibly not wanting it enough, and if they don't get it straight away they can't be bothered to work harder. Of all the boys that have come through my club, and that's over 200 a year about 10 have had trials with 1 offered a pro contract at Southend this year. The percentages of boys making it in miniscule and it will always be that way. Hopefully the way the FA is now training coachs to teach football properly then in a few years we will see a slight improvement, but it will take time as it develops, like the french system that took 10 years to mature players like Henry.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

I've got to echo Stanley's concerns. For some time now it seems that we have spent a lot of money on our youth set-up, but the supply of players has been poor (& i'm actually someone who rates Osborne & thinks he could develop into a really good player).

I think there is a issue regarding the gap between youth football and League 2 & this does cause a problem - particularly when players have to come into a poor team. However there must be a concern about the overall quality of the players produced & how we recruit them for the youth set up as a whole. Do we really 'sell' our set up, the possibility that youngsters could get opportunities for league football much sooner rather than languishing in Chelsea's reserves (if they're lucky) & then disappearing, etc? Are our coaches good enough??

Given our likely lack of resources for the forseeable future this area should either be really concentrated upon or alternatively possibly abandoned. It must cost a fair amount of money at present & I'm not sure that we get value for that - except for the FIC programme which might influence the possibility of new stadium.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Going back over the last 10 years, we've had O'Connor, Dobson and Tabb as definite successes (though Tabb at least came to us relatively late). Osborne may also make it. We've then had Smith, Somner, Charles, Ide, Williams who have all played a fair number of games without really making it, plus Julian, Masters and many others who played a handful of games. [Im sure I'll have forgotten someone]

I'd guess that is below average for a club of our size/league position, but as a London club we probably face more competition than others.

There are intangible benefits from having the youth set up (FitC plus families who start attending games because their kid is linked to the club), so those plus the players coming through might just about justify the costs
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

I left out all our successes....and your first point is clearly very valid.

It must be depressing for all clubs "like us" to think this arm of possible revunue / success on the field has been taken by the "top clubs" :sad: :cry:
I'd also say the same of the non league scene, the likes of Charlton etc are all over it now :sad:
Watford I gather have a really decent set up and a lot of good players coming through at the moment.
They didn't spot me though :wave: , the one that got away :D
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Like it or not we're only just ahead of Daggers & Barnet.........
Which makes us not the lowest :shrug: so what's your point?

No one else has said it yet so I'll give it a bash...
QUIN AND MARSHALL OUT! :D :fishing: ;)

Seriously though, I seem to recall we go through this debate every single season. A lot of promising kids you see in little teams, schools or even down the park are snapped up by clubs with a lot more money and resources. We're not doing too badly, I'd prefer we keep plodding along for the next few years and get the club back on an even keel before we start thinking about any expansion of youth development, reserve teams, etc. In any line of training, the success rate isn't anywhere near 100%. It hasn't helped that we couldn't keep some of them (Ide and Osborne particularly) in the youth set-up for another season, but needs must. If they were deemed to be completely not ready, they wouldn't have been called up. I'd like to have kept some of our more promising young players but the club's not currently in a position to retain when people are offering money. Perhaps in a few years' time we will be able to reject the offers and retain them and make a concerted push for the Championship with players whose loyalty will be rewarded.

Got to be blooded at some point, it's a man's game after all.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Personally I think its the scouting and the management throughout the age groups.
I've played (when i was younger) at youth football level against/with some top quality footballers who were never picked up by clubs.
And on the other hand I played in a school football team which had 7 players at Pro Clubs (1 player was even at Brentford) and to be quite honest apart from 1 player who was a Luton for a while and now plys his trade at Hillingdon Borough, they were very average/poor players. I myself had trials with a couple of clubs (I knew in my heart of hearts I wasn't good enough) but the general feeling you get when your at trials is...We have 16 lads we'll stick with these and see what happens as we can't be a*sed to find/give anyone else who could be better a chance. This goes for other lads who were on trial at the same time as me, who were clearly better than what they had on show there already.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

I played against Brentford Youth when I was younger and they had one or two decent lads playing who had pace and a few tricks. Then they had average lads who filled the CB positions and being a CF I was marked by Jamie Bates. He was average but the only one to make it, my thoughts were that it is so easier to give steady eddie defender types a go rather than the skilled lot who also tended to have the attitude to go with their ability. At the time they were told to professional and not get involved in any verbals with us and any OTT tackling was prohibited, I was a gobby fecker (even as a teenager) and talked Jamie to death but not once did he reply and he even shook my hand at the end as he went on to make a good career out of football and selling his wife.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

and selling his wife.
:laugh:

:imwith: when i was playing youth football, it was always the lads that looked older than what they were that were picked out, never the lads that had obvious talent :shrug:

if you could lay on your back and keep the ball up with your head for 30 mins, but were a bit skinny and had no hair on your nuts you were screwed :thetruth:
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Crewe have produced good youths over the past 10 years, why can't we?

Not as many as some think. They have made some signings of young players from local clubs that they have sold on, but not that many have actually come through from their academy and sold on for large sums in the last 10 years. They had more success between 20 to 10 years ago.

We have a FITC scheme which is not an academy and are probably reliant on acadamy players being released as 14 & 15 years olds. Acadamies sign players from the age of 8.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

the skilled lot who also tended to have the attitude to go with their ability.

The thing is these players turn out to be gems if you put the time into them.
I bet Wayne Rooney had some sort of attitude as a kid. DJ Campbell had an attitude as a youngster. You can name many but you need to take a chance on these types of players and put the time into grooming and trying to knock the attitude out of them. Just dropping them or not giving them a chance in the first place is not the way to do it.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

The thing is these players turn out to be gems if you put the time into them.
I bet Wayne Rooney had some sort of attitude as a kid. DJ Campbell had an attitude as a youngster. You can name many but you need to take a chance on these types of players and put the time into grooming and trying to knock the attitude out of them. Just dropping them or not giving them a chance in the first place is not the way to do it.

Charlie Ide.:idea:

I agree but it's easier to stick with a Steady Eddie. ON here we all say that replacing Heywood is easy as his type is ten a penny whereas a goalscorer is nigh on impossible. I think we are wrong on both counts really.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Charlie Ide.:idea:

I agree but it's easier to stick with a Steady Eddie. ON here we all say that replacing Heywood is easy as his type is ten a penny whereas a goalscorer is nigh on impossible. I think we are wrong on both counts really.

Steady Eddie is fine but alot of youth teams rarely mix it up.
I agree Charlie Ide thought he was a big time Charlie (No Pun intended) but I think the youth section should grow a pair of balls and take chances.
Clearly someone was in Charlies ear telling him he was the next best thing and he decided not to try. I also believe Terry Butcher may have to take some of the blame for this as I believe he ruined him as well. It would appear that man Management was not his strong point.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Personally I think it's symptomatic of the game as a whole in England. I feel we generally go for players who are athletic ahead of anything else. It's generally pace, size and strength ahead of technical and mental ability. You can get so far with just the former but if you really want to progress up the leagues then you need the technical aspect as well..

In general players who come into the first team from the youth team are somewhat lacking in the basic skills (KOC being one of the few exceptions). I feel we need a different emphasis from the bottom up if we are to start producing better youngsters. This applies across the country by the way, not just at Brentford...
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

I feel we need a different emphasis from the bottom up if we are to start producing better youngsters. This applies across the country by the way, not just at Brentford...
:imwith:
Smaller balls, smaller spaces :yes: Get them on the beach doing keepy uppies with rolled up socks :sorted:
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Can you expand on this. Thanks.

I was just refering to Northamptonbees comment on that it seems they prefer the steady eddie instead of taking a chance with someone with a bit more talent but a little bit of an attitude.
I was mearly stating if the reason for this is because they don't want the aggro of someone with a bit of fire in their belly then they should put them in their place or try and channel it in a way to make them a better footballer. Instead of just steering clear of them.

The main point I was stating was that there are great young players playing in the local leagues i.e Sunday Youth or be it in the Allied Counties leagues (under 18's)that are slipping through the net.
When I was playing in the Allied Counties league there were some awesome players, who if you spoke to them they had never even had a sniff of a pro club near them.
I can't really fully understand our Youth's scouting system.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

When I was playing in the Allied Counties league there were some awesome players, who if you spoke to them they had never even had a sniff of a pro club near them.
I can't really fully understand our Youth's scouting system.

If they had never had a sniff from any pro club, it can't be just our scouting system. :confused:
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

they prefer the steady eddie instead of taking a chance with someone with a bit more talent but a little bit of an attitude.

What evidence do you have to back this up? Please let me know on here. The club takes on players they think might make it as a pro, nothing more, nothing less. :wave:
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

If they had never had a sniff from any pro club, it can't be just our scouting system. :confused:

Sorry I was mean't to put on there "Our Youth System and any other local Pro clubs).
But my point is that if alot of the other teams are not bothering then we really should start.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

What evidence do you have to back this up? Please let me know on here. The club takes on players they think might make it as a pro, nothing more, nothing less. :wave:

I never said it was true. We were saying thats what it feels like?
Theres a big difference. :wave:

I'm saying though based on ability alone there are players in certain local leagues (As I said the Allied Counties, etc) that are better players than what we have had to show over the years from our youth sections.

One for instance is a kid called Robert Fitzgrald local lad in Hayes playing in Hillingdon Boroughs Reserves and their Under 18s snapped up by Yeovil?
He's a quality little player.
Now how do we not spot these players and Yeovil do? He must have been worth a gamble as he wouldn't have cost a penny?
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Now how do we not spot these players and Yeovil do? He must have been worth a gamble as he wouldn't have cost a penny?

Perhaps we don't think he's worth the gamble. It's not true they don't cost a penny as the grant the club receives does not cover the cost of running a Centre of Excellence and youth team.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Perhaps we don't think he's worth the gamble. It's not true they don't cost a penny as the grant the club receives does not cover the cost of running a Centre of Excellence and youth team.

Can we just agree to disagree on this will go on forever. :sorted:
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

You've made an inaccurate statement in saying he would not cost us a penny. I am correcting you.

So why could you not give him a trial and if he is better than what we got then release them instead? :sorted:

Wouldn't that make more sense?:confused:
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

I never said it was true. We were saying thats what it feels like?
Theres a big difference. :wave:

I'm saying though based on ability alone there are players in certain local leagues (As I said the Allied Counties, etc) that are better players than what we have had to show over the years from our youth sections.

One for instance is a kid called Robert Fitzgrald local lad in Hayes playing in Hillingdon Boroughs Reserves and their Under 18s snapped up by Yeovil?
He's a quality little player.
Now how do we not spot these players and Yeovil do? He must have been worth a gamble as he wouldn't have cost a penny?

A lot of kids develop late at 16/17 even 18 before they shine and by the same measure some fall away at the same age despite being the next best thing as a youngster. It all seems to depend on the scouting system and how hard/ much resource the club is willing to put into finding these hidden potential gems, not easy I agree.

I think you have a point about attitude over ability, most clubs seem have a major thing over the professional "attitude" over raw ability, of course this is important but to what extent and how much because it makes the coaches lives easier?

Just got a similar feeling that our setup favours the "nice" kids than the DJs of this world. I can just image anybody who speaks out of turn or who has bit of a wild side gets booted out pronto.

At the end of the day its a results business and we don't produce.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

:imwith:
Smaller balls, smaller spaces :yes: Get them on the beach doing keepy uppies with rolled up socks :sorted:


Good point.........but the problems are much deeper rooted, you only have to go over the park on Sunday morning and watch an under 11 match....parents yelling from the touchline " close him down" etc, big pitches and the bigger kids always come out on top. The main problem is people who run kids teams generally don't have the necessary skills to be able to coach young players, they just want them to be minature versions of premier league players. It's an English thing that runs all the way through football in this country, hence we don't breed players like Fabregas, Villa and Asharvin.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

It's not true they don't cost a penny as the grant the club receives does not cover the cost of running a Centre of Excellence and youth team.
But we are running one, so 20 kids or 30 doesn't make much of a difference does it?
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

But we are running one, so 20 kids or 30 doesn't make much of a difference does it?

It's not that simplistic unfortunately. There has to be a coach to boys ratio etc and other regulations. We can't look at players for just one day if they are under sixteen, they have to sign a form tying them to the club for six weeks.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

Which makes us not the lowest :shrug: so what's your point?

No one else has said it yet so I'll give it a bash...
QUIN AND MARSHALL OUT! :D :fishing: ;)

i agree in a way...

i was at brentford for 6 years and to pass through each year it seemed to be ,"its not what u know its who"!! we played in games against the like of chelsea,(which i scored against) arsenal, brighton ect.. but it wasnt that competitive, there was no league basis or cups like there is now, i realise we was playing for our contracts but when your 15-16 you want to win cups and leagues! the only player that made it all the way was to the 1st team was deano wells. dont get me wrong there was no better feeling playing for the club u support but we really do need a better set-up!
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

It's not that simplistic unfortunately. There has to be a coach to boys ratio etc and other regulations.
I see. Thank you.
We can't look at players for just one day if they are under sixteen, they have to sign a form tying them to the club for six weeks.
I see this as the crux of the problem then, as with a lot of unnecessary bureaucracy which obstructs progress. Whose rule is this and why can't it be challenged in a concerted way by a group of clubs in a similar position to us? If this silly rule could be eradicated, kids could be looked at for one or two days and if not good enough shipped out and more brought in, increasing the chance of finding someone worth persevering with, aforementioned attitude problem or not, but with the same number of staff present.
 

Youth and Centre of Excellence

IMO the reason why so many youth team players do not come through the ranks is the lack of a Reserve team. I know everyone will start jumping up and down that we can`t afford to run a Reserve team but I think the gap between First Team and youth team is to big a jump. People like Osborne (No U) and Charles will be on the fringe of the First team until we decide they are not going to make it. The trend seems to be to Loan them out for a season to get them regular games but how much is this a benefit to us when they are playing Non League. If the cash becomes tighter will we ditch the Youth team set up? What would the saving be?
 
Back
Top Bottom