BFC report £500,000 loss

BFC report £500,000 loss

we really need to draw Man Utd away in next years fa cup
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

And it will probably be worse next season unless we can find some way of significantly increasing our income and I do not think promotion in and of itself is the solution.

Even if we get promoted I suspect we will need to find additional income to fund a decent playing budget in League One, without a massive loss. And if we're stuck in League Two still...

I'm not sure Bees United will be able to find the funding for next season without tapping up a few of our richer supporters. So expect us to be buttering up the great and the good. I could be being overly pessimistic but what are the odds of us getting decent sponsorship deals; selling pitchside advertising; getting a roof sponsor etc in the current financial climate?

Anyone know a billionaire?
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Well the headline figures certainly look grim but when you read the report, in particular the Chairman's statement, it is pretty clear that the future probably looks rosier and we owe a huge debt of gratitude to a number of people associated with the club for the fact we are still in business. It isn't easy for any club in the lower divisions (understatement) and considering the position we were in a few years ago this could have been a lot lot worse.

In particular I would single out Matthew Benham, David Heath, Alan Bird and Andy Scott as being instrumental in keeping the club alive over the past 12-18 months.

We've staked a lot on promotion this year however and it will be a real kick in the teeth if it doesn't happen.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

That we're still going at all seems testament to a sh*teload of hard work and some hefty generosity. Two things seem to be the message though, implicit or otherwise:

(1) if we don't go up this year we are potentially in some doo-doo

(2) rattling a bucket and raising £1,000 here or there is wonderful and well-meaning and I really don't want to denigrate it - but really doesn't amount to even a small hillock of beans.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Time to stop this nonesense and get someone with money in...

Shaking buckets and asking for fanzines for a few quid is all well meant but it's time to shelve this 'good meaning supporter thing' and allow or search for someone with a bit of dosh to take over.

(Wee Dave, just seen you've stolen my thunder!!)
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Word of thanks to David heath great dedication, Mathew benham for the use of your money, Abee for keeping the pencils very sharp .
As for billionaires they fly over us every day shame one doesnt parachute down DREAM on
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

The independent auditors cast doubt over the company continuing as a going concern - does this mean what I think it means.

Inverstments £99 ? Is this our post office savings account ?

It certainly paints a very gloomy picture but I'm sure if we saw the accounts of nearly all the other L2 and L1 or even Champ. clubs we see a lot worse situations.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

What is alarming is that the operating loss was so high, it was only brought back to £500,000 mainly by £250,000 of Project Management income which was the money Barratts paid for Brian Burgess, Chris Gammon and Matt Dolman for the time that they worked on the Lionel Road project whilst all three where members of the BU board.

It is no secret that the Dickens administration was a complete disaster. Virtually every contract from food and drink through shirts passing through telephony has had to be revisited and/or renegotiated by someone who is doing the job for free. The shop during that time was a complete disaster too - actually costing the club money (yes you read it right). Dickens was the wrong appointment at the wrong time and it has hurt the club financially in a major way and this set of accounts is his legacy. His appointment was probably the BFC board's worst decision (if you ignore some other managerial appointments!). We were lucky he walked out in support of another under-performer and lucky to have two skilled people work for free as the MD and FD. Dickens's disappearance from MK Dons was not Dickens's decision either from what I have heard.

The auditors say in their report that the BFC as a going concern is reliant on support from their bankers, and bankers are not in the mood to extend loans or renew existing ones (e.g overdrafts) in the current economic environment.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

The independent auditors cast doubt over the company continuing as a going concern - does this mean what I think it means.

If you think it means that there are tougher rules and that auditors have to be very careful then the answer is 'yes'. I think that you will see this sort of comment in many more accounts for all businesses in this and future years probably including U.K.plc. :)
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

What is alarming is that the operating loss was so high, it was only brought back to £500,000 mainly by £250,000 of Project Management income which was the money Barratts paid for Brian Burgess, Chris Gammon and Matt Dolman for the time that they worked on the Lionel Road project whilst all three where members of the BU board.

It is no secret that the Dickens administration was a complete disaster once the bodies had been found with virtually every contract from food and drink through shirts passing through telephony has had to be revisited and/or renegotiated by someone who is doing the job for free. Dickens was the wrong appointment at the wrong time and it has hurt the club financially in a significant amount. Probably the board's worst decision (if you ignore some other managerial appointments). We were lucky he walked out in support of another under-performer and lucky to have two skilled people work for free as the MD and FD. Dickens's disappearance from MK Dons was not Dickens's decision either from what I have heard.

The auditors say in their report that the BFC as a going concern is reliant on support from their bankers, and bankers are not in the mood to extend loans or renew existing ones (e.g overdrafts) in the current economic environment.

:imwith:
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

For some reason I've always expected or have expected for a few seasons that the nice Matthew Benham was going to take over ownership of the club in name. Doesn't he really own us already really? I had this ideal image of MB in control , a money making achiever with the good folk (I won't name them again as they know who they are) gainfully employed to provide this gorgeous future that in the short term ends up in Lionel Road and in the long term can go anywhere. I've been reading too much Babs Cartland...:sad:
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

The auditors say in their report that the BFC as a going concern is reliant on support from their bankers, and bankers are not in the mood to extend loans or renew existing ones (e.g overdrafts) in the current economic environment.


Fortunately then the reliance on bank borrowing is pretty low and the interest charge for the year of only £52k in relation to a pretty high debt (approaching £7m even excluding the interco loan) is testament to the excellent work by many at the club (including Bees United :)) in getting the vast majority of it onto better structured interest free terms.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Healthier than i would have expected actually. Fingers crossed Mr Benham hasn't been credit crunched. Anyone know the revenue figures?
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Also i'm not really sure what this staement quite means: "Exceptional income reduced the net loss to £499,960 which is still a nonsense for a club/business of our size".

Is he saying it's a nonsense for a small or a big business? Because i wouldn't consider it a nonsense for a small lower-league football team. Tres confusing.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

I would think he means that relative to the turnover of only £2m that a loss of 25% is too high , eg a nonsense. Which is probably true but then football isn't like other businesses.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

In hindsight should MA have given the extra monies he wanted? also Is this loss one of the biggest in many a year :(
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

I guess it confirms what most people really thought. Also with the current financial crisis it's not going to improve in the short term. Maybe those who doubt the wisdom of a stadium, which should dramatically improve our off the field revenues, will start to see why it's so important.

There is no real comfort to be drawn from the probability that we are not the only club struggling to survive. However, the one good thing we have, that others don't, is a few practical and sensible directors who have/are working extremely hard to ensure that Brentford survive. Also we are lucky to have St. Matthew and I for one hope that the credit crunch does not force him to rethink his support of the Bees.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

In hindsight should MA have given the extra monies he wanted? also Is this loss one of the biggest in many a year :(

No and no. If hindsight is to be used re the Martin Allen reign, I would rather that in hindsight he had given Steven Hunt and Jay Tabb new contracts when they wanted them. We might have been looking at a £1m windfall now if he had.

Martin Allen was a nearly man and I'm not sure more money would have helped. I don't believe the same can be said for Andy Scott however and I am comfortable that we are giving him the best shot at promotion this year even if it stretches the budget a bit.

As for the loss, it is high but pales into insignificance compared to some we have seen over the years.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

How does this compare to other clubs similar to ours?
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

For some reason I've always expected or have expected for a few seasons that the nice Matthew Benham was going to take over ownership of the club in name. Doesn't he really own us already really? I had this ideal image of MB in control , a money making achiever with the good folk (I won't name them again as they know who they are) gainfully employed to provide this gorgeous future that in the short term ends up in Lionel Road and in the long term can go anywhere. I've been reading too much Babs Cartland...:sad:

i mentioned this here https://griffinpark.org/forums/showpost.php?p=1345037&postcount=223 but nobody, apart from one person ;), commented any further. It came about with a conversation with someone........................

when you have approx. £4 million on the line, you'd have thought he'd want some say!
 
Last edited:

BFC report £500,000 loss

Time to stop this nonesense and get someone with money in...

Shaking buckets and asking for fanzines for a few quid is all well meant but it's time to shelve this 'good meaning supporter thing' and allow or search for someone with a bit of dosh to take over.

(Wee Dave, just seen you've stolen my thunder!!)

I assume this is a wind up? How much money has Matthew Benham put in? :rolleyes:

Or do you really believe there is anyone out there who will just write cheques out without any payback. Even Abramovich isn't doing that. :nono:
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Whilst we all hope and expect to get promotion this year, it does appear, reading this report, that we are "putting all of our eggs in one basket". I do hope therefore that there is a strategy in reserve should we fail to achieve our objective thise season. God help us !
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Repeat after me:

We WILL go up this season;

We WILL move to Lionel Road;

We WILL break even,
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

We WILL go up this season;

We WILL move to Lionel Road;

We WILL break even
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

These figures are truly shocking and basically underlines that if Lionel Road dies so does BFC.

I am not criticising anyone and in fact many people are worthy of our praise.

But any company will not survive if it relies only on cost cutting and not supplement this with sales growth.

I left BU long ago after it`s support for ER, but I don`t think anybody cannot acknowledge what a difficult job BU and it`s partners have in try in set a breakeven budget for BFC and steering the ship until a billionaire drops in for a cold pie.
 
Last edited:

BFC report £500,000 loss

No and no. If hindsight is to be used re the Martin Allen reign, I would rather that in hindsight he had given Steven Hunt and Jay Tabb new contracts when they wanted them. We might have been looking at a £1m windfall now if he had.

Martin Allen was a nearly man and I'm not sure more money would have helped. I don't believe the same can be said for Andy Scott however and I am comfortable that we are giving him the best shot at promotion this year even if it stretches the budget a bit.

As for the loss, it is high but pales into insignificance compared to some we have seen over the years.

I agree and am Im encouraged by Dyke publicly backing AS financially as best the club can.

It's seemed like a catch 22 situation for the past few years, save and consolidate or gamble to succeed. Penny pinching has worked terribly for us during the 06/07 season and led to some truly awful footballing decisions for the club right through to 2008.
I thought that was the time to back the manager financially, whever MA was there or not and i'm glad it's happening now.

I believe the club from top to bottom hass learnt the hard way and improving it's financial awareness even in these recession hit days.
For all MA's heroics he let Tabb drift away, ostracised Hunt, promised the world to DJ and Sodje and offered KOC, Framps and Brooker premiership length contracts which have affected finances since.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

For all MA's heroics he let Tabb drift away, ostracised Hunt, promised the world to DJ and Sodje and offered KOC, Framps and Brooker premiership length contracts which have affected finances since.

Contracts for Frampton and O'Connor had nothing to do with Allen IIRC.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Contracts for Frampton and O'Connor had nothing to do with Allen IIRC.

We also received a fee for Frampton & he wasn't even a year into his contract, so probably saved us money rather than cost us.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Contracts for Frampton and O'Connor had nothing to do with Allen IIRC.

Correct. Paying O'Connor and Frampton (then both defenders) top, top dollar was driven by......guess who...... Dickens.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Contracts for Frampton and O'Connor had nothing to do with Allen IIRC.

Cheers for the clarification. I should have attributed it to the club at the time as a whole rather then single out MA for them.

How much did we receive for Frampton? Were there any clauses attached?

Was the contract for him then a gamble that paid off or a calculated move taken with knowledge that clubs were interested in him?
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Correct. Paying O'Connor and Frampton (then both defenders) top, top dollar was driven by......guess who...... Dickens.

You sure. O'Connor is on last half year leg of a 3 year deal. Dickens joined during Roseniors tenure but after their contract deal. :fishing:
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Correct. Paying O'Connor and Frampton (then both defenders) top, top dollar was driven by......guess who...... Dickens.

:confused: so MA had no say what's so ever with his (2) players length of contract, you can't blame it all on Dickens surely?
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Cheers for the clarification. I should have attributed it to the club at the time as a whole rather then single out MA for them.

How much did we receive for Frampton? Were there any clauses attached?

Was the contract for him then a gamble that paid off or a calculated move taken with knowledge that clubs were interested in him?

I can't answer why he was given the contract although I suspect the fact that just about everybody else had left and we wanted to keep him were factors.

This was the official announcement of his departure and in today's accounts it said we got some appearance money from Millwall for him.

I'm sure a few people know the details but whether they are in the public somewhere I don't know.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

:confused: so MA had no say what's so ever with his (2) players length of contract, you can't blame it all on Dickens surely?

Allen left before those deals were signed.

Rosenior might have been involved, he certainly should have been.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

BFC report £500,000 loss

You sure. O'Connor is on last half year leg of a 3 year deal. Dickens joined during Roseniors tenure but after their contract deal. :fishing:

Dickens started in early September 2006.
According to this O'Connor signed after that.
According to this Frampton was a little earlier, and may have been pre-KD.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Dickens started in early September 2006.
According to this O'Connor signed after that.
According to this Frampton was a little earlier, and may have been pre-KD.

Bearing in mind that KD joined in September 06 I doubt very much he was much involved in the discussions of these contracts, which were being negotiated for quite a few months prior to his arrival.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Dickens started in early September 2006.
According to this O'Connor signed after that.
According to this Frampton was a little earlier, and may have been pre-KD.

IIRC both justifications to the board were done by KD who was keen to improve these two contracts. In one of his conversations with me in his early days KD was on about this subject. I believe that the collective wisdom of the GPG was the same so it is no surprise that KD thought it was a good idea.

Of course Rosenior would have been involved but he wasn't exactly Mr Pushy and was selected by the board largely because he was easier to manage than Mr Allen.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Bearing in mind that KD joined in September 06 I doubt very much he was much involved in the discussions of these contracts, which were being negotiated for quite a few months prior to his arrival.

I agree that's likely.

However, it's not impossible the players concerned had their demands met once the new "boss" was in place to agree it.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Don't fully understand but isn't it a simple fact that this club continues to live beyond its means which in the real world is surely financial suicide.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

IIRC MA recommended that BFC offer contracts to both KOC and Framps, BFC offered deals, can't remember who by, and Rosenior backed those deals for 2 important members of the team, at that time.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Don't fully understand but isn't it a simple fact that this club continues to live beyond its means which in the real world is surely financial suicide.

I agree with you but if we live within are means surely we couldn't be competitive and suffer constant relegation. Until a certain point when living within our means makes us competitive. It would seem like a lack of ambition from the club and i believe although can't obviously prove it would drive away fans and commercial revenue. Your point is clearly a textbook way to run any business but surely cannot be implemented in practice. It could have huge negative consequences but it would be interesting to see what level the club could compete at if they did follow your idea. Although i don't suggest we try.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

Have only had a quick glance but I note they have incorrectly spelled the word reconciliation on the cash flow statement :eek:

I would add that this sort of observation honed from years of experience would normally cost my clients about AU$500 however I will waive my fee in this case.

Like others have said there's a lot of debt not just financially but in gratitude to a number of people who have given their time and money to BFC. Thanks :wave:
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

I agree with you but if we live within are means surely we couldn't be competitive and suffer constant relegation. Until a certain point when living within our means makes us competitive. It would seem like a lack of ambition from the club and i believe although can't obviously prove it would drive away fans and commercial revenue. Your point is clearly a textbook way to run any business but surely cannot be implemented in practice. It could have huge negative consequences but it would be interesting to see what level the club could compete at if they did follow your idea. Although i don't suggest we try.

Can people stop using the phrase 'lack of ambition'. This wouldn't matter so much if we weren't laden with debt. But we are. So every penny we add in the name of ambition is another nail in Brentford's coffin imho (although the death might be more that of a thousand cuts). I would like us to get out of this division but committing long term suicide in the name of 'ambition' seems madness to me.

However if people want to continue to act as if Brentford FC operates without attachment to the real world then fine. However much Brentford FC is more than a business to us as fans it is, in the end, just a business and if current financing isn't sufficient to keep us going then we need to either work out what is or except that League Two/the Conference is what we have to put up.

However that option seems unacceptable to most fans so let's find someone/something that fills the gap. Or pray for a miracle.
 

BFC report £500,000 loss

One way to wipe out our losses

Wanted to suggest a possible way to wipe out our losses next year - I'm not convinced it is a good idea long term but if there is a real worry about our ability to continue as a "going concern", it might be advisable/necessary.

Why don't we add a £5/£6 "survival supplement" onto matchday ticket prices with an equivalent amount (£115-£138) added to season ticket prices?

A supplement at this level would be likely to generate the £500,000 needed to cover this season's losses, even given the inevitable drop off in attendances as a result of the price rise.

If attendances dropped to an average of say 3,000 because of the price rise and, presuming we play 26 home matches including cup games, then we would need to raise the cost of each match ticket by £6.40 to generate £500,000.

As I mentioned, I'm sure this would put some people off but it could be marketed as a "survival supplement" rather than a simple price rise to limit the damage.

I'm not sure it makes sense to risk alienating existing fans/putting off new fans with such a big price increase. But, if our finances are still in as bad a shape as last season (and they almost certainly are, if not worse), maybe it's a decision that we need to take.

Facing the bleak future as it is, rather than just dreaming that some sugar daddy is going to come in and save us (it ain't gonna happen), we're going to have to make some drastic choices if we want to survive.

Remember how fragile out existing position is. If Matthew Benham were to be credit crunched (and I have no knowledge about his financial situation), Brentford FC would probably be finished for good.
 
Back
Top Bottom