Bees Have Won More Penalty Shoot-Outs Than Anyone Else (1 Viewer)

GlasgowBee

Knows **** all about anything
Joined
12 Apr 2000
Messages
5,863
Reaction score
6
Location
Gartham Lock (People's Republic of)
The 24 matches are:

1 - 1989/90 Bristol Rovers AMC lost 3-4
2 - 1990/91 Wrexham AMC WON 3-0
3 - 1994/95 Huddersfield Town Play Off lost 3-4
4 - 1997/98 Colchester United FAC lost 2-4
5 - 1998/99 Walsall AMC lost 3-4
6 - 1998/99 Oldham FAC lost 2-4
7 - 2000/01 Brighton AMC WON 4-2
8 - 2002/03 Bournemouth LC WON 4-2
9 - 2003/04 Barnet AMC WON 3-1
10 - 2004/05 Bristol City FAC WON 4-3
11 - 2005/06 Oxford Utd AMC lost 3-4
12 - 2006/07 Swindon LC WON 4-3
13 - 2006/07 Northampton AMC WON 4-2
14 - 2008/09 Luton AMC lost 3-4
15 - 2008/09 Yeovil AMC WON 4-2
16 - 2010/11 Everton LC WON 4-3
17 - 2010/11 Orient AMC WON 5-4
18 - 2010/11 Swindon AMC WON 4-2
19 - 2010/11 Birmingham LC lost 3-4
20 - 2010/11 Charlton AMC WON 3-1
21 - 2011/12 Barnet AMC lost 3-5
22 - 2011/12 MK Dons AMC WON 4-3
23 - 2012/13 Swindon Play Off WON 5-4
24 - 2014/15 Dagenham LC WON 4-2

All 24 sorted..... :)

15 Wins and 9 Losses.

A 62.5% success rate....... :grey:
Wrexham 1990/91 AMC Bees win 3-0 on pens after a 0-0 draw, is this right? It is not on the list, which would make 24 and another success for the Bees :)

But I may be wrong
 

wanderer paul

https://brentfordfcmemorabilia.wordpress.com/
Joined
28 Oct 2002
Messages
48,855
Reaction score
174
Location
Brentford
Wrexham 1990/91 AMC Bees win 3-0 on pens after a 0-0 draw, is this right? It is not on the list, which would make 24 and another success for the Bees :)

But I may be wrong
Yes. :idea: I was there in Brook Road looking down on the action! So that makes it 24 shoot-outs. :sorted:

charlton jpt
Already on the list........ ;)
 

Banana

Occasionally incorrect
Joined
7 Apr 2000
Messages
70,115
Reaction score
545
Location
London
The 24 matches are: - Yes, now 24!

1 - 1989/90 Bristol Rovers AMC lost 3-4
2 - 1990/91 Wrexham AMC WON 3-0
3 - 1994/95 Huddersfield Town Play Off lost 3-4
4 - 1997/98 Colchester United FAC lost 2-4
5 - 1998/99 Walsall AMC lost 3-4
6 - 1998/99 Oldham FAC lost 2-4
7 - 2000/01 Brighton AMC WON 4-2
8 - 2002/03 Bournemouth LC WON 4-2
9 - 2003/04 Barnet AMC WON 3-1
10 - 2004/05 Bristol City FAC WON 4-3
11 - 2005/06 Oxford Utd AMC lost 3-4
12 - 2006/07 Swindon LC WON 4-3
13 - 2006/07 Northampton AMC WON 4-2
14 - 2008/09 Luton AMC lost 3-4
15 - 2008/09 Yeovil AMC WON 4-2
16 - 2010/11 Everton LC WON 4-3
17 - 2010/11 Orient AMC WON 5-4
18 - 2010/11 Swindon AMC WON 4-2
19 - 2010/11 Birmingham LC lost 3-4
20 - 2010/11 Charlton AMC WON 3-1
21 - 2011/12 Barnet AMC lost 3-5
22 - 2011/12 MK Dons AMC WON 4-3
23 - 2012/13 Swindon Play Off WON 5-4
24 - 2014/15 Dagenham LC WON 4-2

All 24 sorted..... :)

15 Wins and 9 Losses.

A 62.5% success rate....... :grey:
Better write in to Opta and tell them they've got it wrong!
 

TW3Bee

Well-known member
Joined
26 Oct 2005
Messages
54,911
Reaction score
147
Location
Lampton Village
Wrexham 1990/91 AMC Bees win 3-0 on pens after a 0-0 draw, is this right? It is not on the list, which would make 24 and another success for the Bees :)

But I may be wrong
Jason Cousins launched his penalty into the upper tier of the Wendy House.
 

Chorlton Bee

Active member
Joined
11 Aug 2007
Messages
4,204
Reaction score
1
Location
Manchester
120th minute equaliser I thought we were going to win it.
Holloway was their hero that night I think, they were certainly singing his name. First time id heard goodnight Irene too I think
 

jlove

Well-known member
Joined
17 Dec 2002
Messages
32,320
Reaction score
133
Location
Vaison-la-Romaine
Manchester United won't be challenging our record at any time soon!
 

wanderer paul

https://brentfordfcmemorabilia.wordpress.com/
Joined
28 Oct 2002
Messages
48,855
Reaction score
174
Location
Brentford
Better write in to Opta and tell them they've got it wrong!
:D

I don't think there are any errors or anymore to add?

I'm surprised the stats boffins included the shoot-outs previous to 1992. ;)

Well I assume they did, as they say it was 23 shoot-outs, when we now know it's 24! :)

Maybe they missed Wrexham too? :fishing:
 

Banana

Occasionally incorrect
Joined
7 Apr 2000
Messages
70,115
Reaction score
545
Location
London
:D

I don't think there are any errors or anymore to add?

I'm surprised the stats boffins included the shoot-outs previous to 1992. ;)

Well I assume they did, as they say it was 23 shoot-outs, when we now know it's 24! :)

Maybe they missed Wrexham too? :fishing:
I suspect it was the play-off
 

kainiemi

Member
Joined
30 Aug 2006
Messages
446
Reaction score
0
have we any stats on reserve/development/youth teams penalty shoot-outs?

this seems to be a ready made article for the programme
 

Full Metal Jacket

Active member
Joined
11 Sep 2013
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
0
As a percentage (61%) our success rate is good but not exceptional. In fact there are quite a few other clubs with better percentages. If just two out of our 14 successes had gone the other way we'd be on a success rate of approx. 50% - which would be I suppose the expected long run average. So, it's probably just a bit of random fluctuation which will even itself out eventually. There's no statistically valid reason to think that we've been particularly better than average or that we're inherently good at winning shoot-outs.

As someone else has already remarked, the really surprising thing is just how many shoot-outs we've been involved in. I can't think of any reason why that would be so, again, probably just a random statistical variation.
 

kevalutonbee

Well-known member
Joined
11 Aug 2004
Messages
17,490
Reaction score
3
Location
In the wrong
Wrexham 1990/91 AMC Bees win 3-0 on pens after a 0-0 draw, is this right? It is not on the list, which would make 24 and another success for the Bees :)

But I may be wrong
Coldest I have ever been at Griffin Park. The groans when it went to extra time were only beaten by the groans when it went to pens as all around me everybody just wanted to go home and get warm.

As well as Cousens pen that showed up on Heathrow radar didn't Benstead save every penalty he faced?

With regard to the Brighton one weren't we technically away at Griffin Park because the Withdean was doing a passable impression of a paddi field?
 

badgerbee

Mafeking Avenue........gets you there!!!!
Joined
28 Jan 2008
Messages
13,943
Reaction score
101
Location
Langport, Somerset
Considering we lost 5 out of the first 6, that's a pretty good percentage rate since - 14 successes out of the last 18 ......... 78%!!!
 

nick logan

Well-known member
Joined
6 Apr 2000
Messages
30,553
Reaction score
120
Location
Essex
Wrexham 1990/91 AMC Bees win 3-0 on pens after a 0-0 draw, is this right? It is not on the list, which would make 24 and another success for the Bees :)

But I may be wrong
Just realised , i was at all of them but never would have guessed it was so many.

won 14 of the last 18 too :eek:
 

badgerbee

Mafeking Avenue........gets you there!!!!
Joined
28 Jan 2008
Messages
13,943
Reaction score
101
Location
Langport, Somerset
The 24 matches are: - Yes, now 24!

1 - 1989/90 Bristol Rovers AMC lost 3-4
2 - 1990/91 Wrexham AMC WON 3-0
3 - 1994/95 Huddersfield Town Play Off lost 3-4
4 - 1997/98 Colchester United FAC lost 2-4
5 - 1998/99 Walsall AMC lost 3-4
6 - 1998/99 Oldham FAC lost 2-4
7 - 2000/01 Brighton AMC WON 4-2
8 - 2002/03 Bournemouth LC WON 4-2
9 - 2003/04 Barnet AMC WON 3-1
10 - 2004/05 Bristol City FAC WON 4-3
11 - 2005/06 Oxford Utd AMC lost 3-4
12 - 2006/07 Swindon LC WON 4-3
13 - 2006/07 Northampton AMC WON 4-2
14 - 2008/09 Luton AMC lost 3-4
15 - 2008/09 Yeovil AMC WON 4-2
16 - 2010/11 Everton LC WON 4-3
17 - 2010/11 Orient AMC WON 5-4
18 - 2010/11 Swindon AMC WON 4-2
19 - 2010/11 Birmingham LC lost 3-4
20 - 2010/11 Charlton AMC WON 3-1
21 - 2011/12 Barnet AMC lost 3-5
22 - 2011/12 MK Dons AMC WON 4-3
23 - 2012/13 Swindon Play Off WON 5-4
24 - 2014/15 Dagenham LC WON 4-2

All 24 sorted..... :)

15 Wins and 9 Losses.

A 62.5% success rate....... :grey:
Thought it was time to revisit this after plenty of comments yesterday around "Unbelievable!!! We finally managed to win a shoot out"
Now 16 wins out of 25.
Success rate up to 64%.......
Only lost 4 out of the last 19.....
If only we could have held out for a draw on 4th August....
 

TW3Bee

Well-known member
Joined
26 Oct 2005
Messages
54,911
Reaction score
147
Location
Lampton Village
Pretty much remember all of these, but don't remember being able to watch them.
 

wanderer paul

https://brentfordfcmemorabilia.wordpress.com/
Joined
28 Oct 2002
Messages
48,855
Reaction score
174
Location
Brentford
Thought it was time to revisit this after plenty of comments yesterday around "Unbelievable!!! We finally managed to win a shoot out"
Now 16 wins out of 25.
Success rate up to 64%.......
Only lost 4 out of the last 19.....
If only we could have held out for a draw on 4th August....
Needs updating.

Didn’t we lose to Cambridge after penalties last season?
 

wanderer paul

https://brentfordfcmemorabilia.wordpress.com/
Joined
28 Oct 2002
Messages
48,855
Reaction score
174
Location
Brentford
The 26 matches are: - Yes, now 26!

1 - 1989/90 Bristol Rovers AMC lost 3-4
2 - 1990/91 Wrexham AMC WON 3-0
3 - 1994/95 Huddersfield Town Play Off lost 3-4
4 - 1997/98 Colchester United FAC lost 2-4
5 - 1998/99 Walsall AMC lost 3-4
6 - 1998/99 Oldham FAC lost 2-4
7 - 2000/01 Brighton AMC WON 4-2
8 - 2002/03 Bournemouth LC WON 4-2
9 - 2003/04 Barnet AMC WON 3-1
10 - 2004/05 Bristol City FAC WON 4-3
11 - 2005/06 Oxford Utd AMC lost 3-4
12 - 2006/07 Swindon LC WON 4-3
13 - 2006/07 Northampton AMC WON 4-2
14 - 2008/09 Luton AMC lost 3-4
15 - 2008/09 Yeovil AMC WON 4-2
16 - 2010/11 Everton LC WON 4-3
17 - 2010/11 Orient AMC WON 5-4
18 - 2010/11 Swindon AMC WON 4-2
19 - 2010/11 Birmingham LC lost 3-4
20 - 2010/11 Charlton AMC WON 3-1
21 - 2011/12 Barnet AMC lost 3-5
22 - 2011/12 MK Dons AMC WON 4-3
23 - 2012/13 Swindon Play Off WON 5-4
24 - 2014/15 Dagenham LC WON 4-2
25 - 2019/20 Cambridge U LC lost 4-5
26 - 2020/21 Wycombe W LC WON 4-2

All 26 sorted..... :)

16 Wins and 10 Losses.

A 61.5% success rate....... :grey:
Updated.
 

TW3Bee

Well-known member
Joined
26 Oct 2005
Messages
54,911
Reaction score
147
Location
Lampton Village
Touche - I left the Swindon play-off shootout and walked around the ground as I was too nervous after Trottagate,,,,
That Swindon one was amazing.
I'd watched the game from under the floodlight pylon on the corner of Ealing Road and New Road, and when the penalties came I stood behind the stand.
I wasn't the only one.
 

wanderer paul

https://brentfordfcmemorabilia.wordpress.com/
Joined
28 Oct 2002
Messages
48,855
Reaction score
174
Location
Brentford
The 27 matches are: - Yes, now 27!!

1 - 1989/90 Bristol Rovers AMC lost 3-4
2 - 1990/91 Wrexham AMC WON 3-0
3 - 1994/95 Huddersfield Town Play Off lost 3-4
4 - 1997/98 Colchester United FAC lost 2-4
5 - 1998/99 Walsall AMC lost 3-4
6 - 1998/99 Oldham FAC lost 2-4
7 - 2000/01 Brighton AMC WON 4-2
8 - 2002/03 Bournemouth LC WON 4-2
9 - 2003/04 Barnet AMC WON 3-1
10 - 2004/05 Bristol City FAC WON 4-3

11 - 2005/06 Oxford Utd AMC lost 3-4
12 - 2006/07 Swindon LC WON 4-3
13 - 2006/07 Northampton AMC WON 4-2

14 - 2008/09 Luton AMC lost 3-4
15 - 2008/09 Yeovil AMC WON 4-2
16 - 2010/11 Everton LC WON 4-3
17 - 2010/11 Orient AMC WON 5-4
18 - 2010/11 Swindon AMC WON 4-2

19 - 2010/11 Birmingham LC lost 3-4
20 - 2010/11 Charlton AMC WON 3-1
21 - 2011/12 Barnet AMC lost 3-5
22 - 2011/12 MK Dons AMC WON 4-3
23 - 2012/13 Swindon Play Off WON 5-4
24 - 2014/15 Dagenham LC WON 4-2

25 - 2019/20 Cambridge U LC lost 4-5
26 - 2020/21 Wycombe W LC WON 4-2
27 - 2020/21 WBA LC WON 5-4


Won 17 Lost 10

63% success rate.
 

Untouchable

Once called a bastard by a Judge
Joined
5 May 2014
Messages
1,433
Reaction score
130
We’ve won 16 of our last 21 penalty shoot outs.

Thats a 76% success rate since the turn of the century.

Just need to find a way of conquering the play offs now.
 

Jay Bee

Active member
Joined
24 Jan 2001
Messages
7,612
Reaction score
16
Location
Not around here much anymore
Thought it was time to revisit this after plenty of comments yesterday around "Unbelievable!!! We finally managed to win a shoot out"....
I think people combine the nerves of a shoot out with memories of our record at taking penalties in open play which at times in the last decade (or longer) has been pretty dire.

Also in my formative years watching the Bees we lost the first 4 shoot outs per that list, the first of which was Huddersfield, so I take nothing for granted...
 
Last edited:

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top Bottom