I think we should be playing a formation to fit the players we have available if our full strength isn't available.
Why put 2 or 3 players in the wrong positions when we can form a team to their actual strengths.
If rumours were true about Janelt in LB ahead of Thompson, then he really is down the pecking order for his specialist position.
Is Roeslerv injured? If not why not 433 then?
Thompson isn't great as a wing back, but as a LB he may have done ok. He was exposed massively going forward.
Canos back up top with toney and either wissa or Bryan. Something different.
I think your first sentence is absolutely spot on and, for me, sums up our primary issue right now. Yes, as many people have rightly commented, there are lots of mitigations at the moment - injuries, COVID, suspension, squad depth and budget - but it is because of these that the ongoing 3-5-2 needs to be reviewed. At the end of the day the game is only won by the players available and the formation should enable/ empower them to do so. Of course, 3-5-2 will be the right answer sometimes (maybe often); but always?
With the prospect of the imminent transfer window and the eventual recoveries from injury, I think we’ll do OK, and quite possibly more than that, but right now I’m taking more than a little comfort from the woes of teams below us and their contribution to ensuring we still have a cushion above them.