BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

BIAS statement here:
http://www.bias.org.uk/news_story.php?id=287_0

BIAS has reviewed the statement by Bees United (BU) detailing the proposed partnership with Matthew Benham.

BIAS will be preparing questions and we shall be requesting separate meetings with David Merritt (BU Chair) and Matthew Benham and/or his representatives to put issues raised by the Brentford Football Club supporter base to both parties to the deal.

We urge you to consider the issues and to contact BIAS if you have questions you would like to put to David or Matthew.

Please submit your questions via the following e-mail address: [email protected].

Whether or not you are a BIAS or Bees United member we wish all Brentford supporters to fully understand the significance of this proposed deal.

Subject to agreement with Bees United, BIAS plans to host a fans forum on a date to be agreed - but prior to the Bees United members’ meeting on 17th August. At the forum supporters will be able to put questions to Bees United Board members. Please check our website for further updates on the date, time and venue of this event.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

....................seems that this has been on the cards for a while................

Yes, the news article does say that negotiations have been going on for over a year!
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

It's interesting. There are a lot of questions to be answered. I don't want to get all negative at an early stage because I'm sure everything will work out fine. [Famous last words].

The immdiate response is, of course, hurrah £1m+ a year for five years but what happens after that five years? What happens to Lange's Golden Share? What is Matthew Benham doing this for? (And yes I know he's a Bees fan from whenever but it is a legitimate question to ask.) What's going to happen to Bees United's representation on the board? Does Benham choose the board? How much information are BU/Matthew going to provide before the August 17 meeting? Who is going to be Chairman? Who hires + fires the Manager? Who signs players etc?

I'm sure there are more questions.

As I said I'm sure it'll work out fine in the end but there's a lot to clarify I think, especially about what happens after Matthew Benham's five years.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

It's interesting. There are a lot of questions to be answered. I don't want to get all negative at an early stage because I'm sure everything will work out fine. [Famous last words].

The immdiate response is, of course, hurrah £1m+ a year for five years but what happens after that five years? What happens to Lange's Golden Share? What is Matthew Benham doing this for? (And yes I know he's a Bees fan from whenever but it is a legitimate question to ask.) What's going to happen to Bees United's representation on the board? Does Benham choose the board? How much information are BU/Matthew going to provide before the August 17 meeting? Who is going to be Chairman? Who hires + fires the Manager? Who signs players etc?

I'm sure there are more questions.

As I said I'm sure it'll work out fine in the end but there's a lot to clarify I think, especially about what happens after Matthew Benham's five years.

Aren't most of these questions answered in the various reports floating around - GPG, BU website, BFC website.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Aren't most of these questions answered in the various reports floating around - GPG, BU website, BFC website.

Some of them are. I'm sure once I've re-read everything at a sensible hour it'll all be clear to me. :D

As Uncle Banana said: 'The devil is in the detail.'
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

i don't understand!!
can someone clever and helpful summarise it for me & other simpletons in less words please. matthew benham is the hero of BFC hooray yes? or a bad man boooo kill him benham out?

thank you in advance for your continued assistance.
kind regards.

:rolleyes:
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

very long time no post form Jambo, but still at work and this seems big news

being the slack lazy git i am i cant unravel what its all about, but surely its gotta be good, innit?

and totally unrelated but Gashbee loving ya work son and will call ya for some scoops chief
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

i don't understand!!
can someone clever and helpful summarise it for me & other simpletons in less words please. matthew benham is the hero of BFC hooray yes? or a bad man boooo kill him benham out?

thank you in advance for your continued assistance.
kind regards.

:rolleyes:

very long time no post form Jambo, but still at work and this seems big news

being the slack lazy git i am i cant unravel what its all about, but surely its gotta be good, innit?

and totally unrelated but Gashbee loving ya work son and will call ya for some scoops chief

I don't disagree. There is a lot to take-in. However we have a couple of weeks to do that.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

So will it be Benham's decision what his million pounds a year is invested on? Will it impact on this season's playing budget?
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

So this is the early Friday news, that was to be expected from the last GPG Newsletter :sorted:
Appears to be excellent news on the face of it. Dealing with our burden of debt, being one reason to be especially optimistic.
 
Last edited:

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Reading very carefully through the details provided so far...Im pleased. This deal obviously has taken year to get right and agree on. Which can be seen by the details provided. I think this is a big positive step forward for the club. Like someone stated already interested to know where the 1mil a year will be invested into?
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Seems a no brainer on first glance. My first question is does this investment simply reduce the clubs level of debt by 5 million i.e. we then simply owe MB £4.5m with no additional creditors or will debt remain the same and this go on the playing budget in the hope that LR comes to fruition in this timeframe and the current debt is wiped out? What happens after 5 years, will this investment continue or will MB then own the club and we go back to the current situation?
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Not sure, hopefully a great move forward for the Bees. Will have to read it over again and again to make complete sense of it all, but I hope MB will make us a debt free club in 5 years and take us upwards and onwards.:eek::confused::)
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

One key question - as noted by Gazza Bee - is whether Benham's minimum investment of £1m a year will be used to pay down our massive debts or support the playing squad, or some combination of the two.

Whatever his intentions, given the state of our debts, we really have no choice but to accept this offer.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Seems a no brainer on first glance. My first question is does this investment simply reduce the clubs level of debt by 5 million i.e. we then simply owe MB £4.5m with no additional creditors or will debt remain the same and this go on the playing budget in the hope that LR comes to fruition in this timeframe and the current debt is wiped out?

debt level stays the same, money goes towards general purposes. The extra monies will help set a more realistic playing budget for the division, but note this does not mean we have an extra £1m to spend on players. This is a good deal for BFC and BU, it gives BFC a little bit more room to manoeuvre given the constraints we've been operating under and BU more time to focus on the longer-term issues affecting the club


What happens after 5 years, will this investment continue or will MB then own the club and we go back to the current situation?

BU has an option to payback MB the monies invested in the club by him over the five year period plus the £4.5m owed in debt. If we don't exercise, MB has the right to exercise majority ownership of BFC, leaving BU with a minority stake and ownership of the golden share. If neither party exercises, status quo over debt and ownership remains, with MB writing off the £5m invested in the club during the intervening period
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

At first glance it looks to be a hugely positive and welcome move. I look forward to receiving the documentation and taking time to read it in full.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Thanks GPG Towers for the email, sitting in the sun in Crete I would probably not have checked on GPG for news. Sounds v good but with questions. Not sure if abee can but would love to hear his views on the subject
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Another question. After the 5 year period has elapsed should MB buy the additional shares to take full control will his current £4.5 million loan be written off thus lowering our debt by said amount?
 
Last edited:

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Looks like a fabulous and fair offer to me. Money coming in but not in way that mounts further financial debt on the club, true investment on the playing front, possibiliy reducing pressure on the debt which may make it easier to service (and with possible increased success on the playing front bringing in more revenue to reduce the debt), and of course Mr Benham has options at the end, and why not he is prepared to put an awful lot of money in over 5 years....this is a once in a lifetime chance
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

There seem to be a number of questions about what happens in 5 years time...

So I will ask a similar question...if this offer is not taken up, will the club, with its existing level of debt, still be in existence in 5 years time?

If you can guarantee the answer to be yes, then you can question what Mr Benham is going to do in 5 years.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Another question. After the 5 year period has elapsed should MB buy the additional shares to take full control will his current £4.5 million loan be written off thus lowering our debt by said amount?

yes, Bananaman summarises it very well on the front page
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

I am just going to put here that this is the deathknell for the club and he is going to rob us blind and build flats on GP. I have no basis for this but if we are succesful no one is going to remember it anyway. Otherwise, I told you so.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

I wasn't clear from the OS whether it was an additional £5m or an extra sum to take his total investment up to £5m, but comments here seem to make it clear that it is the former.

In principle, it seems an idea I'd support, but I hope there will be clarification of a few questions (needn't be here, with the voting papers would be OK)

If this were turned down, would MB want repayment of existing loans?
As someone else asked here, will there be set conditions on how it is split between loan repayment and investment in players, or will that be left to Board to decide as we go along?
Are we covered if anything terrible were to happen to MB during the 5 years?
Can we survive without the £5m? If yes, under what constraints (eg a BSP playing budget?)
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Gift horse & mouth!

For once can't we celebrate a fantastic deal for our little club, If it had happened anywhere else in the lower divisions I'd of been green!

This means a real '5 yr plan' for once, and a true chance of the Championship.

Best thing that's happened at BFC for years, excluding abee, shaggy and a certain Mr Scott.

C'mon you reds!!!!!!!
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

There was all sweating on the future of one player when in the background something that will affect the future of the entire club was happening!!

Thanks to Banana for laying it out in a manner that hopefully makes most things clear

On the face of it it seems like an absolute no brainer as without putting ourselves into yet more debt is there anyway that BU would be able to come up with that kind of money?

What does this mean for the squad? Who knows but hopefully As will continue with his current philosophy of looking for players who will fit in at the club rather than go "all Galactico" on us and start buying players just because he can
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

On the face of it, this appears to come down to "Do you trust Matthew Benham?" which the board clearly do. I guess myonly concerns are around whether there are safeguards in place to ensure another Noades doesn't happen.

However, the massive difference here is of course Benham's past and continued investment which demonstrates his commitment and for that reason, we have to accept the board recommendation.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Looks a sensible deal but needs to be backed up with Lionel Road development that will take the benefits of this transaction forward. Without Lionel Road not a great deal of long term expansion of team budget possibilities, still a tremendous move by Mr Benham.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

if this offer is not taken up, will the club, with its existing level of debt, still be in existence in 5 years time?

BU has tried to accentuate the positives about the deal without, I hope, underplaying what could happen after five years.

What BU has not done in explaining the deal is banged on about the parlous financial state the club is in currently, and suggested there are any possible alternatives.

It's perhaps worth repeating a few numbers. The club's debt is about £9 million, it is still losing money, season after season, and last year's playing budget would be among the lowest in Division One this season.

Matthew Benham is under no obligation whatsoever – if this deal is turned down – to maintain his generosity in continuing to loan the club money interest free with long-term repayment dates.

Is there life for BFC without Matthew Benham? Yes, possibly, but not as we know it.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

On the face of it, this appears to come down to "Do you trust Matthew Benham?" which the board clearly do. I guess myonly concerns are around whether there are safeguards in place to ensure another Noades doesn't happen.

However, the massive difference here is of course Benham's past and continued investment which demonstrates his commitment and for that reason, we have to accept the board recommendation.

Er....it's also a question of "Do you trust the guy that Matthew sells his shares to in <n> years time; and then do you trust the guy that that guy sells his shares too; and then....."

It comes down to "Are there adequate protections in the deal to safeguard the future of the club/ground".
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Er....it's also a question of "Do you trust the guy that Matthew sells his shares to in <n> years time; and then do you trust the guy that that guy sells his shares too; and then....."

It comes down to "Are there adequate protections in the deal to safeguard the future of the club/ground".

Quite.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Like many are going to say no.
It will be like Ibiza 1988 all over again.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

One key question - as noted by Gazza Bee - is whether Benham's minimum investment of £1m a year will be used to pay down our massive debts or support the playing squad, or some combination of the two.

Whatever his intentions, given the state of our debts, we really have no choice but to accept this offer.

:imwith:

In the round I think this is a fantastic deal for BFC. There seem to be enough ties in the deal to make it difficult for MB to flog Griffin Park before a new stadium is built. Hopefully by 2014 we'll be in Lionel Road, in the Championship and earning enough revenue to make the club profitable in the long term.

At that point the club is worth money to an investor so MB is taking a massive punt on getting to that point.

Ultimately the devil will be in the detail so I look forward to the documents we are going to receive as BU members.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

With this deal on the table I think I am happier being a Bee than ooh lets see now, a Magpie
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

This looks a good deal for us. I suspect the BU/fans meeting on the 17th will be well attended!
How many does the venue hold?
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Looks like a good deal on that info.
Well done to everyone invloved in the hard work.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

I would really welcome abees appraisal of this offer
 
Last edited:

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

Great news, it seems.

Key question for me, as other have said, is what will the £1m per year be spent on ?

If players and wages, then fab.

If police horses for the Millwall and Leeds games at GP then not so fab.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

If neither party exercises, status quo over debt and ownership remains, with MB writing off the £5m invested in the club during the intervening period

Cannot see that happening can you!

And for the 5m pounds that he will have invested he will have received preference shares so what will happen to those shares and what entitelemnts do these share have during the 5 years and also after the 5 years.
 

BU to Sell to Matthew Benham?

On the face of it the deal seems ok and will see us through 5 years. Which is when we question what the next step will be. Much I'm sure will then be dependent on what the situation is with Lionel Road.
MB is proven winner in gambling and I woudl hope this gamble could produce good news for the club in 5 years.
 
Back
Top Bottom