BFC Supporters to Make Historic Decision

  • Thread starter Thread starter Banana
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 0
  • Views Views 3K

Banana

Admin
Joined
7 Apr 2000
Messages
121,524
Reaction score
86,463
Location
London

BFC Supporters to Make Historic Decision

<img src="http://static.seekingalpha.com/uploads/2009/4/23/saupload_buy_sell_hold_die.jpg" width="200" hspace="5" align="left" style="border:1px solid black">In what is quite simply the biggest news since Alan Bennett signed a new two year contact earlier today,Bees United have today announced that they have come to an agreement with Matthew Benham about how to take the club forwards and, according to Matthew, into the Championship.

Earlier today GPG Towers received an embargoed Press Release and since then we have been hard at work to understand what seems to be a quite involved deal and one that, on the face of it, seems to be better than not having that deal. However, we would encourage all voting members of Bees United to take their time and understand all they can about the deal because there is no doubt that this is the most important decision for BFC supporters....EVER

In the limited time today GPG Towers staff have not had time to digest the small detail of the information that BU are making available today, but we have been working the phones and have secured interviews with BU Chairman David Merritt, Matthew Benham (potential new 90% owner of BFC), and BFC Chairman Greg Dyke. More details on the GPG in the coming days including how you can put your questions to them. BIAS will also no doubt have something to say on the subject and GPG Towers will probably be working closely with BIAS in the coming few weeks.

The official press release can be read on both the BFC website and the BU website

The interns at GPG Towers have done their best and distilled the headlines of the deal like this (please note although we have done our best in the time available to be completely accurate, but there may be some misunderstanding in our analysis):
  • Matthew Benham will pour at least £1,000,000 per year, every year for the the next five years. In return Matthew will receive preference shares.
    <br />
  • 1791 voting BU members will decide whether or not to accept the deal via a postal vote after a meeting (n.b. NOT an EGM!) on Monday 17th August at St Pauls Church, Brentford. Matthew Benham will be present at that meeting.
    <br />
  • If the deal is ratified then BU and BFC immediately handover day-to-day control of the club to Matthew Benham and/or his executives (but see below on the board composition).
    <br />
  • Griffin Park will be protected by a “Golden Share” owned by Bees United.
    <br />
  • Martin Lange and the Wheatley brothers immediately sell their shares (at par value) in BFC Ltd (and Griffin Park ltd) to Matthew Benham who will then own 35% of the club
    <br />
  • There are other scenarios but we at GPG Towers feel that the most likely scenario is that in five years time Bees United will handover their 60% shareholding in the club to Matthew Benham in 2014 taking Benham’s effective shareholding to 95% (BU will hold on to 15% of the shares but BU will give any dividends from those shares to Matthew Benham)
    <br />
  • It will be Status Quo in the Boardroom for the time being (apologies to GPGer Rhino for the heart flutter he has no doubt just suffered)
    <br />
  • If BU members vote for the deal and MB decides to take on the club in five years time; his debt is turned into equity essentially reducing the club’s debt by a lot. The remaining outstanding debt will be with the directors, BU and the local council.
    <br />
  • BFC supporters that use AOL are denied important news by AOL but valiant efforts by GPG IT experts save the day
    <br />
  • The GPG has secured interviews with BFC Chairman Greg Dyke, BU Chairman David Merritt and also Matthew Benham. More details on the GPG in the coming days.

We at GPG Towers have always known that the devil is in the detail and we hope that the envelope dropping on BU Members’ doormats this weekend will include more detail than is in the press release. We hope it includes such clarity about what exactly a Preference Share is; what a Golden Share is and how to calculate a “a price fixed by formula”. There are also plenty of unanswered questions that need to be asked of the deal principles (that's Merritt (BU), Matthew Benham, and Dyke (BFC)), but this article is long enough already!

This deal has been over a year in gestation, which should indicate to everyone just how complicated the deal is and today’s press releases, understandably, don’t go into every detail. One thing is for sure that, and it’s no real secret, that some of GPG Towers staff were involved in the discussions in the initial days and congratulations must go to the BU Board for getting to an agreement. Especially to Dave Merritt and Chris Gammon who have been representing your hard earned money in the the club. It should be noted that the entire BU Board (comprising people that support the club like all GPG members) and the entire BFC Board (comprising more of the same type of people – of course!) are unaminously recommending the deal to BU members.

There are some immediate questions that we've managed to track down answers to. As indicated above, we at GPG Towers have heard that there is unlikely to be any immediate upheaval in the board room (except perhaps Petrus will be added to the Wine List) with the investor directors all having extended their loans to stay on the BFC board as part of the deal. However, we also understand that a new full-time CEO will be appointed after the deal is signed, sealed and delivered which could presumably mean an end to the current executive arrangements. We've no idea what the future of BU representation will be on the board which currently number Dave Merritt, Alan Bird, Donald Kerr and Greg Dyke – although we are in little doubt that Greg will continue as Chairman.

There will be one change to the BFC Board as GPG Towers understands that Ian Jones will stand down as a BFC director after the deal is approved and his £200k loan will be repaid in full from (effectively) BU funds. When we spoke with BU Chairmen Dave Merritt earlier who comfirmed that no other changes to the BFC Board have been discussed, and that, in any case, they are within BU's control (as majority shareholder) for, at least, the duration of the initial five year period.

GPG Towers also spoke with the BU Chairman today about the monthly Standing Orders that BU members pay to Bees United and asked him if BU members will be expected to continue them and where this revenue will go. David Merritt replied “Absolutely! BU is in this for the long term. This deal increases the level at which Brentford FC can operate for the five year partnership, but it's not unlimited. All money raised by BU will either go into supporting the Club (raising the level for BFC even further, giving us an even better chance of success) or maintaining the long term protection for the Club via BU ownership (of ordinary shares and of the Golden Share). The question should be "How can non-members join BU", because if anyone ever doubted that BU would be a force for good for Brentford FC they surely cannot doubt it now. Every member, every pound, will continue to help BFC.”.

We also asked why ex Chairman Lange and the Wheatley brothers (who are sons of an former BFC director) will give up their stakes in BFC and Griffin Park Ltd for (effectively) bugger all. David replied that it is because they realise it is a good deal for Brentford FC, and all of them have the best interests of the Club at heart. David went on to state that he has met with and spoken to Martin Lange and Wheatley brothers, and all three of them started from the position of "what's in it for Brentford FC?". They all have a strong emotional link with the Club and want to see it do well. Their actions speak for themselves, and that BU are very grateful to them as should be every supporter of BFC. We at GPG Towers see no reason to give a special GPG free membership (perhaps for life) to these three people.

Dave went on to say that he urges all BU members to read the documents sent to them in the mail carefully (GPG Towers understands that they will be posted 1st class today (Friday)). He went on to point out that there is a lot in the mailed package and members sure make sure they understand the implications before casting their vote. Obviously Dave agrees with GPG Towers and encourages every BU member to attend the meeting on the 17th August. GPG Towers also wholeheartedly endorse the observation by the BU Chairman that if it wasn't for BU then supporters wouldn't have a say in deals like this. (We discuss later if er.... actually we do or not!)

Dave closed by reminding all at GPG Towers of how good a deal he thinks this is for both Bees United and for Brentford FC and that he is hoping for a massive vote of support from BU members

Well, we certainly can’t disagree with Dave Merritt, and we also agree with him that each and every BU member should understand what they are voting for. Initially we can’t disagree with the BU Chairman and we note that anyone voting against the deal also needs to understand the entire consequences of doing so .

Finally we bring you the what small print there is which is attached to the press release:

The Proposal – The key points of the proposed partnership are:
  • MB immediately buys a minority shareholding of ~35% from ex-Chairman Martin Lange (25%) and the Wheatley family (~10%), for nominal sums.

    • For a five year period:
    • MB commits to invest a minimum of £1m per annum as preference shares.<br />
    • BU continues as majority shareholder.<br />
    • MB has effective operational control of BFC, including an ability to appoint/veto executives as appropriate.<br />
    • The current BFC Board continues to be responsible for the management and supervision of the executives.<br />
    • As a result of MB’s annual equity investment, BFC is not expected to require further loan financing for the five year period. <br />
    <br /><br />
  • At the end of five years there are three possibilities:
    • Possibility One – BU can buy MB’s shareholding for a price fixed by formula (based on his investments and a fair return based on the value of BFC at that time).<br />
    • Possibility Two – If BU do not exercise this option, MB has the option to buy a significant element of BU’s shares, giving him 75% ownership of the Club, in return for conversion of his £4.5m loans into equity, substantially strengthening the balance sheet of the Club. BU would continue as a minority shareholder and creditor to the club, with BFC Board representation, and with a golden share protecting against the inappropriate sale of Griffin Park or any future ground.<br />
    • Possibility Three – If neither BU nor MB exercise their options then BU will continue as majority shareholder, MB will continue as minority shareholder and significant creditor (he would still be owed £4.5m by BFC), and there would be no further commitment from MB for additional funding.

Latest news can be found on this thread​
 
Back
Top Bottom