GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Les Beeavinu

Administrator
Joined
5 Aug 2002
Messages
79,442
Reaction score
62,601
Location
Sandhurst

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Having just read the latest scores from Wee Dave, and not being able to respond, can I just say that it is an outrage that Michael Turner is second bottom. He hasn't put a foot wrong this season and is probably in the top three.

I am therefore starting a campaign for more votes for our captain. Join me.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Re: GPG Player of the Year

I think not the bottom three as the table does not show every squad member, but only those who have scored points.

However, you are right in saying it's shocking how far from the top he is.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

how can he be on the same points as osbourne thats shocking
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

The basic fact is most football fans get sucked in by moments rather than sustained periods.

Players like Campbell, Peters and to some extent Tabb and Rankin produce moments of magic rather than sustained good play, although the latter two tend to keep a decent level, and that sets them out when you look back on a game

Sodje also produces moments which are eye-catching, and it often gets missed that Turner bails him out time and time again. If we defend well it is often Sodje that gets the plaudits, because he didn't make any mistakes that Turner had to recitify :sorted:

Turner is the unsung hero of our team, no doubt.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Been Superb this season - Turner!

He's coming on in every game his touch is improving and his left peg has certainly had some practice. I would say if the man of the season was to be voted now it would be

1. Framps
2. Turner
3. Sodje
4. Hutch
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

West Ealing Bee said:
The basic fact is most football fans get sucked in by moments rather than sustained periods.

Players like Campbell, Peters and to some extent Tabb and Rankin produce moments of magic rather than sustained good play, although the latter two tend to keep a decent level, and that sets them out when you look back on a game

Sodje also produces moments which are eye-catching, and it often gets missed that Turner bails him out time and time again. If we defend well it is often Sodje that gets the plaudits, because he didn't make any mistakes that Turner had to recitify :sorted:

Turner is the unsung hero of our team, no doubt.

:imwith: I actually think we'd miss him much more than Sodje.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

The main problem with Turner getting votes is that he's not "flashy" like some other players - he simply does his job very well (most of the time) with the minimum of fuss and quite a lot of fans don't really appreciate all the good work that he does. Were, heaven forbid, he to get injured, unless we could get a similar standard of loan player in to cover for him, I'm sure that more people would start to realise how good a job he does.

I would add though, looking at the votes cast, that he is actually 5th on that score (and very nearly 3rd) so maybe that is an anomoly that might be looked at for next season's Player of the Year competition. Perhaps a certain number of points can be added for those (top 3 or top 5, maybe) that gain the highest number of overall votes during the season. After all, if there are only a few people voting on some away games, the vote for that game may not be a fair reflection of the view of the majority that went to that game. Just a thought, like...
 
Last edited:

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

alikat said:
Perhaps a certain number of points can be added for those (top 3 or top 5, maybe) that gain the highest number of overall votes during the season. After all, if there are only a few people voting on some away games, the vote for that game may not be a fair reflection of the view of the majority that went to that game. Just a thought, like...

:drunk:
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

alikat said:
I would add though, looking at the votes cast, that he is actually 5th on that score (and very nearly 3rd) so maybe that is an anomoly that might be looked at for next season's Player of the Year competition. Perhaps a certain number of points can be added for those (top 3 or top 5, maybe) that gain the highest number of overall votes during the season. After all, if there are only a few people voting on some away games, the vote for that game may not be a fair reflection of the view of the majority that went to that game. Just a thought, like...

I think it's been suggested before: the trouble is that one could argue the other way round. There are some players who stand out in away games because we've our backs against the wall - but they will receive far fewer votes than the home heroes.

Suppose 10 voters go to Hartlepool on a cold Tuesday evening and 8 of them vote for (say) Turner after a dour 0-0 draw. He's a clear winner with 80% of the votes.

However, in the home game against Hartlepool, we win 4-0 in front of 150 voters and DJ gets 1 of the goals, is MOM and receives 50 votes: yet because the number of voters is so much higher, he'd have only 33.3% of the vote. End of the season, that could make all the difference.

I think what we have isn't perfect, but it's the best without our turning to quantum physics.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Paul O'Brien said:
I think what we have isn't perfect, but it's the best without our turning to quantum physics.

I want to hear more about this idea first Paul.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Wee Dave said:
:imwith: I actually think we'd miss him much more than Sodje.


:imwith:

The whole thing with Turner and Sodje reminds me of the centre back situation at Middlesbrough in the 80's. For Turner and Sodje read Mowbray and Pallister. Mowbray was the better player but for some reason, Pallister got all the plaudits and then the big money move to Man U.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

I think they complement each other and if we lost one the other would struggle unless we got a decent replacement. Turner has the positioning and calm head but Sodje has power, pace and aerial dominance. His goals are also pretty vital to us as we are still a low scoring team. Turner needs to start chipping in with a few more.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Les Beeavinu said:
Having just read the latest scores from Wee Dave, and not being able to respond, can I just say that it is an outrage that Michael Turner is second bottom.
Happier now? :D
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Very. I'm delighted that so many people were won over by the power of my argument and shamed into acting. The top four looks more like the season I've been watching now.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

when is the table going t be updated, i think it's about time.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

beeseen said:
when is the table going t be updated, i think it's about time.

quite right. I'll do it after the Bradford result is in.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

It's based on points not votes right?
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

So MOM and votes are only used if there's a tie?
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

DJ won man of the match for every game in Jan. :eek:
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

garybee99 said:
Been Superb this season - Turner!

He's coming on in every game his touch is improving and his left peg has certainly had some practice. I would say if the man of the season was to be voted now it would be

1. Framps
2. Turner
3. Sodje
4. Hutch


:D i don't remember that !!!
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Jimbee said:
DJ won man of the match for every game in Jan. :eek:
He only won the Stockporto one by one vote though.

However, he had a record 215 votes for the Sunderland game :sorted:
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Les Beeavinu said:
Having just read the latest scores from Wee Dave, and not being able to respond, can I just say that it is an outrage that Michael Turner is second bottom. He hasn't put a foot wrong this season and is probably in the top three.

I am therefore starting a campaign for more votes for our captain. Join me.

your campaign's been successful :eek: :sorted:

DJ's rinsing it tho :dj:
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

As much as we loved DJ with the publicity he brought to the club, and the pleasure and excitement he gave us, he is no longer with us and should he really still be included in the list ? After all he can't improve on his postion as he will play no further part in what is going to be a crucial part of the season.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

TW1Bee said:
As much as we loved DJ with the publicity he brought to the club, and the pleasure and excitement he gave us, he is no longer with us and should he really still be included in the list ? After all he can't improve on his postion as he will play no further part in what is going to be a crucial part of the season.

There are 16+ games to be added to the table where he won't get any points.

It's safe to assume he won't win.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Michael Turner has been doing his job at the back superbly all season. He gets on with it, no moans or groans, and has a great understanding with Sodje. He's got stronger as the seasons gone on, especially when he's up against seasoned pro's like Goater, Windass etc He's outjumped them, outplayed them, and in the end he's better then them. When he first played at Chesterfield least season, you could see he had composure and assurity like Ingimarsson and Hreidarsson. He'll go on to better things, if not for Brentford but for a Premiership side. He's my 'Most Improved Player' this season. (although Framps comes close behind)
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

TW1Bee said:
As much as we loved DJ with the publicity he brought to the club, and the pleasure and excitement he gave us, he is no longer with us and should he really still be included in the list ? After all he can't improve on his postion as he will play no further part in what is going to be a crucial part of the season.

If he won he'd still be player of the season, regardless of whether he was still here at the end of it :shrug:
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Wee Dave said:
If he won he'd still be player of the season, regardless of whether he was still here at the end of it :shrug:
Agree - them the rules that were agreed after last season and Tony Rougier suddenly disappered when Mr Allen arrived.

The Official Secrets Act lasts a long time you know :)
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Les Beeavinu said:
Having just read the latest scores from Wee Dave, and not being able to respond, can I just say that it is an outrage that Michael Turner is second bottom. He hasn't put a foot wrong this season and is probably in the top three.

I am therefore starting a campaign for more votes for our captain. Join me.

Ever considered running for President? :D
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Wee Dave said:
Ever considered running for President? :D

Well done all for following my instructions but now I need you help again.

I'm setting up an off-shore account and I need your money for "important" projects. These will benefit you all by providing you with with peace and fulfillment, safe in the knowledge that your physical assets will go be used for the good of mankind (less expenses).

Please give generously.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Looks like it's a close one between turner and tabb at the moment. Sodje will surely make a burst for it so it's going to be a three horse race.who do you think is going to win it then?
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Les Beeavinu said:
Well done all for following my instructions but now I need you help again.

I'm setting up an off-shore account and I need your money for "important" projects. These will benefit you all by providing you with with peace and fulfillment, safe in the knowledge that your physical assets will go be used for the good of mankind (less expenses).

Please give generously.

-If you find the right 'lock up' somewhere in Kent, you'll be able to help yourself.....
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Tabb and Turner must be miles clear now musn't they.

Are they :shrug: Anyone know ;)
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

West Ealing Bee said:
Tabb and Turner must be miles clear now musn't they.

Are they :shrug: Anyone know ;)

Yeah yeah yeah :box: I'll do it after the MK result is in.

Maybe. :looks:
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

--------------------------------------------------------
1. Jay TABB (7): 44.83 points -- 787 votes
2. Michael TURNER (5): 43 points -- 895 votes
3. Dudley CAMPBELL (8): 30 points -- 764 votes
4. Stuart NELSON (4.5): 23 points -- 427 votes
5. Lloyd OWUSU (2): 22.83 points -- 479 votes
6. Sam SODJE (3): 21 points -- 421 votes
7. Darren PRATLEY (4): 14 points -- 266 votes
8. Isaiah RANKIN (2): 10.5 points -- 272 votes
9. Sam TILLEN (1): 9 points -- 172 votes
10. Andy FRAMPTON (1): 8.5 points -- 163 votes
11. Kevin O'CONNOR (0.5): 8 points -- 160 votes
12. Paul BROOKER (1): 7 points -- 221 votes
13. Marcus GAYLE (1): 6.5 points -- 191 votes
14. Ricky NEWMAN (1): 6.5 points -- 138 votes
15. Eddie HUTCHINSON (2): 6 points -- 145 votes
16. Junior LEWIS (1): 3 points -- 107 votes
17. Ryan PETERS (1): 3 points -- 95 votes
18. George BANKOLE (1): 3 points -- 36 votes
19. Karleigh OSBORNE (0): 3 points -- 22 votes
20. Scott FITZGERALD (0): 2 points -- 16 votes
21. Alex RHODES (0): 1 points -- 32 votes
22. Calum WILLOCK (0): 0.33 points -- 11 votes
--------------------------------------------------------


I think we need a "votes per point" column :D
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Banana said:
--------------------------------------------------------
1. Jay TABB (7): 44.83 points -- 787 votes
2. Michael TURNER (5): 43 points -- 895 votes
3. Dudley CAMPBELL (8): 30 points -- 764 votes
4. Stuart NELSON (4.5): 23 points -- 427 votes
5. Lloyd OWUSU (2): 22.83 points -- 479 votes
6. Sam SODJE (3): 21 points -- 421 votes
7. Darren PRATLEY (4): 14 points -- 266 votes
8. Isaiah RANKIN (2): 10.5 points -- 272 votes
9. Sam TILLEN (1): 9 points -- 172 votes
10. Andy FRAMPTON (1): 8.5 points -- 163 votes
11. Kevin O'CONNOR (0.5): 8 points -- 160 votes
12. Paul BROOKER (1): 7 points -- 221 votes
13. Marcus GAYLE (1): 6.5 points -- 191 votes
14. Ricky NEWMAN (1): 6.5 points -- 138 votes
15. Eddie HUTCHINSON (2): 6 points -- 145 votes
16. Junior LEWIS (1): 3 points -- 107 votes
17. Ryan PETERS (1): 3 points -- 95 votes
18. George BANKOLE (1): 3 points -- 36 votes
19. Karleigh OSBORNE (0): 3 points -- 22 votes
20. Scott FITZGERALD (0): 2 points -- 16 votes
21. Alex RHODES (0): 1 points -- 32 votes
22. Calum WILLOCK (0): 0.33 points -- 11 votes
--------------------------------------------------------


I think we need a "votes per point" column :D
Just out of interest, then, here's how the table looks sorted by that:
(you sure you still want it?) :D

1. Junior LEWIS (1): 3 points -- 107 votes
2. Calum WILLOCK (0): 0.33 points -- 11 votes
3. Alex RHODES (0): 1 points -- 32 votes
4. Ryan PETERS (1): 3 points -- 95 votes
5. Paul BROOKER (1): 7 points -- 221 votes
6. Marcus GAYLE (1): 6.5 points -- 191 votes
7. Isaiah RANKIN (2): 10.5 points -- 272 votes
8. Dudley CAMPBELL (8): 30 points -- 764 votes
9. Eddie HUTCHINSON (2): 6 points -- 145 votes
10. Ricky NEWMAN (1): 6.5 points -- 138 votes
11. Lloyd OWUSU (2): 22.83 points -- 479 votes
12. Michael TURNER (5): 43 points -- 895 votes
13. Sam SODJE (3): 21 points -- 421 votes
14. Kevin O'CONNOR (0.5): 8 points -- 160 votes
15. Andy FRAMPTON (1): 8.5 points -- 163 votes
16. Sam TILLEN (1): 9 points -- 172 votes
17. Darren PRATLEY (4): 14 points -- 266 votes
18. Stuart NELSON (4.5): 23 points -- 427 votes
19. Jay TABB (7): 44.83 points -- 787 votes
20. George BANKOLE (1): 3 points -- 36 votes
21. Scott FITZGERALD (0): 2 points -- 16 votes
22. Karleigh OSBORNE (0): 3 points -- 22 votes
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Looks like a shoot-out between Turner and Tabb now
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

I see last season's GPG Player of the Season has dropped to 6th. Reckon that's about right unfortunately. :(


--------------------------------------------------------
1. Jay TABB (8): 49.83 points -- 906 votes
2. Michael TURNER (5): 43 points -- 931 votes
3. Dudley CAMPBELL (8): 30 points -- 764 votes
4. Stuart NELSON (4.5): 25 points -- 459 votes
5. Lloyd OWUSU (2): 23.83 points -- 522 votes
6. Sam SODJE (3): 21 points -- 426 votes
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Banana said:
I see last season's GPG Player of the Season has dropped to 6th. Reckon that's about right unfortunately. :(


--------------------------------------------------------
1. Jay TABB (8): 49.83 points -- 906 votes
2. Michael TURNER (5): 43 points -- 931 votes
3. Dudley CAMPBELL (8): 30 points -- 764 votes
4. Stuart NELSON (4.5): 25 points -- 459 votes
5. Lloyd OWUSU (2): 23.83 points -- 522 votes
6. Sam SODJE (3): 21 points -- 426 votes

To a certain point sam has been disapponting this season however he has been the subleect of lots of rumors so..I suppose you could give him the benefit of the doubt...
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Canadian Bee said:
To a certain point sam has been disapponting this season however he has been the subleect of lots of rumors so..I suppose you could give him the benefit of the doubt...
What rumors (sic) has he been subleect to?
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Tabby needs just one more MOM win and the trophy is his!




Trophy? Or glass bowl? What do GPG-ers think? He got a (very nice) glass bowl last time he won it.
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Stilts. Gold ones.:sorted:
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Edmundo said:
Tabby needs just one more MOM win and the trophy is his!.
ummmmmm we could have 6 matches left
 

GPG Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Yeah we did :shrug:
 
Back
Top Bottom