League Cup

ladbroke

Well-known member
Joined
15 Jul 2006
Messages
18,269
Reaction score
6,079
Location
Arbroath, NE Scotland

League Cup

With people criticising the League Cup yesterday (mainly on social media and even the BBC website!), do you think it needs a new life sparked into it?

Some of the things that were called about it being devalued were the amount of changes teams make (several made a complete 11 changes from their weekend squads - including Brighton and Fulham, even Wigan made 11 changes.

There were also a lot of grounds with less than half full stadiums, even with reduced ticket prices.

Not to mention the farce with the draws, how they have been done and even where!

Take aside the fact we beat QPR last night, they also made 10 changes. No wonder their fans are pissed off too, We have been in the past when losing to both Oxford and Exeter.

So what should be done, if anything?

Some suggestions included giving the cup a CL spot for the winners, as well as giving one to the FA Cup winners.
Some suggested that the League Cup becomes solely a Football League cup (as in no Premier League teams).
One suggestion I saw was that the teams are forced to play just English/British players and then get rid of the FLTrophy that people have been slamming (evidently) in the past 18 months.
What about ticket prices, regardless of where the game is, being capped at £10 a ticket.

Do you think the League Cup needs changing?
 

League Cup

Not really, only things i'd change is the draw and and maybe a rule of where you have to play a certain amount of players from the previous weekend's match.
 

League Cup

Leave it as it is. Just make the draws at home and use numbered balls. One person draws the home team, one the Away, simple really.

No need to start charging it for the sake of it. Who will the EFL invite to enter? Team from Ireland? Scotland? France? Or past masters, an over 35's international XI?

Just do it simple. It isn't hard.

Team changes, I'm not bothered, it is what it is now.
 

League Cup

With people criticising the League Cup yesterday (mainly on social media and even the BBC website!), do you think it needs a new life sparked into it?

Some of the things that were called about it being devalued were the amount of changes teams make (several made a complete 11 changes from their weekend squads - including Brighton and Fulham, even Wigan made 11 changes.

There were also a lot of grounds with less than half full stadiums, even with reduced ticket prices.

Not to mention the farce with the draws, how they have been done and even where!

Take aside the fact we beat QPR last night, they also made 10 changes. No wonder their fans are pissed off too, We have been in the past when losing to both Oxford and Exeter.

So what should be done, if anything?

Some suggestions included giving the cup a CL spot for the winners, as well as giving one to the FA Cup winners.
Some suggested that the League Cup becomes solely a Football League cup (as in no Premier League teams).
One suggestion I saw was that the teams are forced to play just English/British players and then get rid of the FLTrophy that people have been slamming (evidently) in the past 18 months.
What about ticket prices, regardless of where the game is, being capped at £10 a ticket.

Do you think the League Cup needs changing?

Stop t1tting around with the draw and whack up the financial incentives for progressing to each round so that clubs are more inclined to take it seriously. Make all tickets £10 for adults and kids go free in the first 3 rounds.

I've been fed up with how BFC have approached the cup in recent seasons but last night was brilliant and is up there amongst my favourite games.
 

League Cup

Does anyone who was at Loftus Road seriously think there is anything wrong with the League Cup ??
 

League Cup

About 3/4 of the ground, given they made 10 changes!

so what ? we made 10 in the first round and had about 89 players out injured last night
 

League Cup

And nearly lost. We had to rely on ET to beat a team in a league below.

nearly lost !! should have won long before it went to ET

we made 10 changes they had their first team out , it was a very good result considering.

" we had to rely on ET " :lol:
 

League Cup

nearly lost !! should have won long before it went to ET

we made 10 changes they had their first team out , it was a very good result considering.

" we had to rely on ET " :lol:

Did we win in regular time?

No.

Did we then have to win it in ET?

Yes.

So therefore, by definition, we had to rely on ET to win the game.
 

League Cup

Did we win in regular time?

No.

Did we then have to win it in ET?

Yes.

So therefore, by definition, we had to rely on ET to win the game.

did we nearly lose
no

we just smashed the hooped scum , why are you being a misery
 

League Cup

In answer to the original post, I think it's past rescuing now and will never go back to how it was. Still a worthwhile tournament for getting to play at Wembley and actually winning something, but even that is devalued now, with play off finals held there. It would be great if the winners were given a CL place, but I don't see that happening.

I feel it is currently given the same value that the old Full Members and Simod Cup were in the 80s(remember them?)
Sadly, I feel this tournament will go the same way those did.

Much as last night was a great night for us, one can't ignore the poor attendances and ridiculous amount of team changes, showing the disdain in which clubs hold this cup now and in recent years.
 

League Cup

In answer to the original post, I think it's past rescuing now and will never go back to how it was. Still a worthwhile tournament for getting to play at Wembley and actually winning something, but even that is devalued now, with play off finals held there. It would be great if the winners were given a CL place, but I don't see that happening.

I feel it is currently given the same value that the old Full Members and Simod Cup were in the 80s(remember them?)
Sadly, I feel this tournament will go the same way those did.

Much as last night was a great night for us, one can't ignore the poor attendances and ridiculous amount of team changes, showing the disdain in which clubs hold this cup now and in recent years.

look at the last 10 winners
 

League Cup

I think if you view it as a competition to give squad members and development a chance, it becomes quite good... rather than get annoyed at teams for doing it look to embrace it. Ilias would have barely even made a bench appearance for instance but now we all know of him. Teams do start taking is seriously as you go further though, but the early rounds are excersises in rotation.

With the money involved in the Prem, the money here is insignificant for teams even in our league. In order to get teams to care you either have to up the prize fund, or award the winner a CL spot. I can't see either happening significantly though and it will remain as it is for the foreseeable future.
 

League Cup

I think it's good and I would love us to win one day. Why not, what else have we won?

The regionalisation is very good.

They don't need to over complicate the draw.

I used to love the JPT as well and I'm gutted the B teams have ruined that because it was a great comp.

Yes it would be great if everyone played full strength sides, I think the perception of gaining some sort of real advantage (in the league etc) by playing the ressies in the cup is ridiculously misguided. But two second strings going at it can still create good games and usually at a good price in terms of tickets. Can't beat it.
 

League Cup

The trouble with Norwich game now is that 3 of our reserves are now counted as 1st team regulars after Thursday nights departures
 
Back
Top Bottom