Mac or Connell
If AC was such a good player as has been intimated on this thread then surely a higher level club at some point would have bought him.
He has played at Bnmth, Hereford and Brentford without establishing himself at any of them and whilst football is all about decisions, no manager has ever wanted to make him an integral member of his team.
He has some great strengths and qualities but these are counterbalanced by a large number of deficiencies. All of which have already been argues to death on the GPG!
I would have loved for us to have kept AC in the squad but he was a luxury that we could not afford given how the playing budget needed to be allocated.
Would I swop him for any of Elder, MacDonald or even Bowditch - no.
To be fair Charlie's had a few clubs himself,
Brentford
Southend
Ebbsfleet
Crawley
Stevenage
Margate
Colchester
Torquay
Cheltenham
Charlton
Id still take him over Conell though