Noades

Goodie or Hoodie?

  • Noades - overall he was good for BFC

    Votes: 13 4.2%
  • Noades - overall he was bad for BFC

    Votes: 298 95.8%

  • Total voters
    311

Banana

Admin
Joined
7 Apr 2000
Messages
121,411
Reaction score
86,381
Location
London

Noades

Good guy or not - you decide!

Good guy: he's extended his interest-free loans when, strictly speaking he didn't need too - but did he had another buyer?

Bad Buy: Lied to us about "funding the club"

Everyone - this isn't a scientific vote - but we'll be revealing the results to Greg Dyke at the end of the month. If you have a view - one way or the other - PLEASE VOTE
 

Noades

I don't think there's really any doubt that Noades shafted our club big time. Is there seriously ANYONE who thinks that Noades has been "good for the club"??
:mad1:
 

Noades

BoroBee said:
I don't think there's really any doubt that Noades shafted our club big time. Is there seriously ANYONE who thinks that Noades has been "good for the club"??
:mad1:

Let's get the votes in and then we can let Dyke know on the 31st.

Personally I was hugely disappointed with Dyke's comments at the Fans' Forum. He hasn't been briefed or was at Old Trafford whilst people were being raised from their beds and threatened with law suits during Noades tenure as Chairman.

We (that's the GPG) will take the Dyke the results of this poll whether or not it represents my views or Edmundos views.

Speak out BFC fans!
 

Noades

Noad£s is an arsehole and no Bees fan should have an opinion to the contrary.:mad1:
 

Noades

Started off a good guy I suppose and then became a s##t.

However not defending Mr Noades but in Division 3 our gates were terrible especially for a team that loads of money spent on it an riding high in the league. He probably thought why bother when nobody is coming through the turnstyles.....

He did bring Jay Tabb to the club as he reminded us after his debut against Luton Town.

Hate him not covering the debts he created and the way he ran the club into the ground in order to get Altonwood tax benefits.......

Overall a man out to make himself and Altonwood a lot of money at Brentford's expense.
 

Noades

Can I urge those supporters that wish to vote "against the grain" that they do so. We really want to convey to Dyke the true feeling of readers of this messageboard.

Grateful Thanks.

Eddiesarmy that may include you as long as you're not a doppleganger for thefatcd
 

Noades

A sad individual who deserves a real slap for what he did to us.
I was up for a real united front being shown should he have been coming to GP in the PO last season. I wasn't up for a "holding hands and booing" kind of welcome and I'm normally into Help the Aged and not hurt them.
I hated the time we had with him in charge and never wore a grey wig and went to very few games as I hate being held over a barrel and this is how this pig seems to operate.
Rant over.
 

Noades

Tempted to vote Good, just to provoke a conversation! :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

No seriously, one good year of buying our way out of a very poor division does not make up for the rest of the years of continual raping and pillaging of our beloved club.

He has ****ed us big time, and it will take more than a token gesture of the interest free loan for him to win me back.

****
 

Noades

Bad
I have to say I was completely misled by this guy..........too late now:nono:
 

Noades

Very bad

However, had he left Mickey Adams as manager and simply remained chairman rather than massaging his own ego, that may have been a different story :sad:
 

Noades

So far its

Bad: 50
Good: 0

If it carries on like this Noades will be demanding his £1m loan back too :(
 

Noades

good I think tony blair for another term would be better then Noades ever:eek:
 

Noades

My response to this is the same as I have posted on a different thread, that is, I am truly staggered that Greg's apparent understanding of NOades reign appears to need updating. How could he consider welcoming that scumbag back to BFC. :confused: :sad:
 

Noades

Is it naive to think that GD is playing a canny game?

He is after all in a position of responsibility as chairman and noades is still, all emotion set aside, a financial contributor to the club and from a business point of view keeping other wolves from the door, though I think he wears a sheepskinned coat himself.

It would then be amiss of GD to openly criticise. We as fans can, and he as a fan could, but as a chairman he has to be wise with his public persona...lets not treat GD like an idiot.

I voted bad, by the way
 

Noades

I agree with you glasgow bee GD is unlikely to stand up and call noades a **** ata fans forum. Unlike other of our rogue directors, some of whom even voice opinions on ex players. :nono:
 

Noades

Who voted good?
 

Noades

I hope he dies a slow and painful death.
 

Noades

GlasgowBee said:
Is it naive to think that GD is playing a canny game?

He is after all in a position of responsibility as chairman and noades is still, all emotion set aside, a financial contributor to the club and from a business point of view keeping other wolves from the door, though I think he wears a sheepskinned coat himself.

It would then be amiss of GD to openly criticise. We as fans can, and he as a fan could, but as a chairman he has to be wise with his public persona...lets not treat GD like an idiot.

I voted bad, by the way

Fully agree Glasgow. Anybody who thinks that GD is not fully aware of the RN situ and is simply doing his (GD's) job, aint paying attention. GD is a public figure and our chairman. That position carries a responsibility to behave with a degree of decorum and diplomacy. Dyke probably does think that Noades is a vvanker but I for one would be appalled if he came out and said it. For pete's sake, he brings some long-needed professionalism to this club: dont knock him for it - applaud him.
 

Noades

What, omg, who are the 3, what is going on here, an extention on a loan, so what, he almost killed the club, we were safe when he took us over, and he took advantage of our financial security so run us dry for his gain. please put your reasoning for saying he wasa good, please.
 

Noades

Sadly I don't think we can name and shame the three turncoats who voted 'against the grain', but I think we definitely deserve an explanation from them.
 

Noades

The harm Webb did was short term in nature (other than the anecdotal evidence to suggest that the capitulation against Crewe led to many of the last generation of fans giving up on the club permanently, but this isn't really borne out by attendances now). He stripped us of our assets and made a nice profit on sale, but the club he sold was solvent. We spent more on players under Mickey Adams than under any manager since apart from Noades during his Championship Manager days.

If the club ever manages to get to the promised land of Lionel Road and promotion, perhaps a revisionist history of Noades might be charitable to say that his dreadful and self-serving management of the finances caused enough of a shock to create the right circumstances for the supporters to take back the club and get to that outcome (something which the club had not been able to achieve before). But the reality is that Noades could have really taken this club forwards himself but instead he hobbled it for his own benefit.
 

Noades

i voted bad, and why you ask.....cause he almost destroyed something i love.
utter money grabbing c**t and if i ever see him............well :mad1:
 

Noades

look at Reading and Madjeski.

look at Brentford.

debate over.
 

Noades

I cannot believe that 8 people think that he was good for the club. I assume that is a pis@ take.
 

Noades

I don't think it is all that significant that 4% have responded yes. It's irrelevant noise from being an interweb survey. The majority of Brentford fans are aware of the damage he caused under his mismanagement of the club.

There would be a much higher proportion of yes's as well if you just canvassed people going through the turnstiles.
 

Noades

Noades was and still is a complete ****** of the highest order. I would love to bump into him one day........:mad1:
 

Noades

northoltbee said:
Noades was and still is a complete ****** of the highest order. I would love to bump into him one day........:mad1:


I always find it amazing that the vast majority of Brentford supporters share this view but once people get elected to the BU Board, they seem to have their minds taken over and suddenly he isn't that bad a chap after all.

Maybe those prawn sarnies have something special in them...
 

Noades

Brickie Chap said:
Maybe those prawn sarnies have something special in them...

I think, more likely, it is the stark realisation that "Uncle Ron" has got the club firmly by the metaphorical balls. When faced with that reality, the only response is to smile weakly and say "How far should I bend over, Sir?".
 

Noades

Perhaps and we should never EVER forget to thank JM and SC for putting us in that position :sorted:
 

Noades

No question, Noades got us into this mess.

Spend, spend, spend was his policy, yet he told us that he was "funding" the club with his own money, which turned out to be a lie. He funded the club by extending our overdraft beyond our means. He has not put up a penny of his money, he only used "guarantees" to appease the bank manager.

Noades lied to us. Simple as that, and then blamed us thick pratts for not filling the stadium every week. He then attempted to sell Griffin Park and move us to Woking without a new home. Just think what life could be like right now! Playing in front of 2000 at Woking for the last 4 seasons with no new home in sight, whilst Noades sits in Spain living off the GP sale proceeds, and GP getting knocked down to build some fancy flats. In the meantime, BFC would have gone bust with the reduced revenue, and there's no doubt in my mind that we would be in the Conference by now.

And there's 11 people who think Noades was good for us?:rolleyes:
 

Noades

Was it not David Webb that started the whole demise of Brentford??
 

Noades

Dangerous said:
Was it not David Webb that started the whole demise of Brentford??


Wasn't it QPHa in the late 60's? Wasn't it Lange for knocking down the Royal Oak? Difficult to say.
I personally blame Noades. I even remember you (Dangerous) having a right old rant at Thame United about Noades and how he was dangerous for the club. How prophetic you were.........:(
 

Noades

Dangerous said:
Was it not David Webb that started the whole demise of Brentford??
Martin Lange, for failing to hand over the club to someone that did not want to rape it. He also got his loans back from BFC, with interest. :wave:
 

Noades

markbfc said:
Martin Lange, for failing to hand over the club to someone that did not want to rape it. He also got his loans back from BFC, with interest. :wave:


and he still owns a large slice of BFC/GP which he still won't pass on to BU. or even sell to an investor? (abee for instance?)
Webb didn't kill the club with overdrafts, he just took the money from transfers and ran......because Lange sold out to him.......Noades has been the biggest to**er in our history.
 

Noades

It wasn't QPHa it was Jack Dunnett MP - I hate f**king politicians (sorry Luke heheh - oh yeah I forgot you stood down :sorted: )

The club has never been the same since that fiasco but god bless Peter Pond-Jones (remember him?) and the rest of he rescue team.

Back to topic (again rofl ) Noades is a **** and BU are gutless lemmings :fishing:
 

Noades

at the time Mr Webb was starting the rot of our club, RN did come in a remove him from us, who can say what would have happened to us if Webb stayed in charge? RN did give us back control of Griffin Park ground (something Palace doesnt have) which is singlehandedly our strongest bargining chip if we ever get the chance to go to Lionel Rd. the collapse of the transfer market didn't help his spend now get the money back later plans, but most of us were duped into thinking he was some sort of saviour what with the wigs and stuff.

i will admit to voting yes for this reason.....

Thanks to Ron we know not to trust another "football fan" businessman without seeing the cold hard facts of their plans. we have control of the club and when we come out of this we know its down to us the die hard fan not the rich t****r with a hidden agenda.

he screwed us over but we are the more the wiser for it
 

Noades

Humpers74 said:
i will admit to voting yes for this reason.....

Thanks to Ron we know not to trust another "football fan" businessman without seeing the cold hard facts of their plans. we have control of the club and when we come out of this we know its down to us the die hard fan not the rich t****r with a hidden agenda.

he screwed us over but we are the more the wiser for it

Of all the reasons to vote "yes", that is probably the closest to acceptable.

Behind the antics of W£bb and Noades formed an entirely more educated and politically-driven fanbase. I still think that overall the damage done by RN warrants the "no" vote, but full credit for explaining your reasons.

It is such a shame that problems created by previous owners mean that nobody can just turn up and enjoy (?) the football anymore.
 

Noades

Humpers74 said:
RN did give us back control of Griffin Park ground (something Palace doesnt have) which is singlehandedly our strongest bargining chip if we ever get the chance to go to Lionel Rd.
I'm really not sure what you mean by this statement. RN did not "give us back control of Griffin Park" - he gave control of it over to the creditors, ie the bank and, by a sleight of hand, himself. Palace hasn't got its own ground because Simon Jordan refuses to grovel to Noades in the manner of Bees United. Whether Jordan or BU are right in their approach is a matter of taste, I suppose, but Jordan had and has a stronger hand.
 

Noades

Humpers74 said:
. the collapse of the transfer market didn't help his spend now get the money back later plans,
The Bosman ruling was in place when he tookover. He even referred to it in his first interview with Beesotted. Don't fall for that one.
 

Noades

Unfortunately it was a gamble that didn't pay off - i think he thought that if he flaunted enough money, fans would come flocking - meaning a progression that in time would enable him to recoup what he put in. I think this was his "definition" of "funding" the club. I reality, what it has done, has made us learn how to live frugily, and from hand-to-mouth from one season to the next. There's only one person at fault for that - Ron Noades. A bad error of judgement by him should not have been punished on us!!
 

Noades

Bucks Bee said:
Unfortunately it was a gamble that didn't pay off - i think he thought that if he flaunted enough money, fans would come flocking

I don't buy that - as far as I'm concerned, he just wanted to get his hands on some West London real estate. End of.
 

Noades

Bucks Bee said:
Unfortunately it was a gamble that didn't pay off - i think he thought that if he flaunted enough money, fans would come flocking - meaning a progression that in time would enable him to recoup what he put in. I think this was his "definition" of "funding" the club.
I don't buy that. I reckon his intention was always to rack up losses to subsidise his taxes while draining away the value of Griffin Park, then cash in and ride off into the sunset leaving us playing at a tinpot non-league ground.
 
Back
Top Bottom