Saturday's referee

[B2B]

has he ever been seen in the same place as no coat? are they twins?

 

[WarrenBee]

Had a very good game I thought (don't know about No coat though).

 

[GP200]

..................a good display........................

 

[Markybee]

Excellent young ref.

Note to other young ref at Notts Co, Mr Olivier USE YOUR LINO FOR PENS...like Mr Cook did

Note to Attwell. You can learn a lot from watching this afternoons chap. He's sensible, intelligent and honest.

 

[Willo]

Nocards :shrug:

 

[super J]

I thought he should have given a card to their guy who gave away the penalty. Apart from that he was very good, although it was an easy game to ref.

Nice to see a young ref who doesn't seek the spotlight that Attwell does and want to be centre of attention all the time. I liked how he waited for the linesman to signal for a penalty because his view was restricted.

 

[coconino]

Two cards, apparently, for Ahmed and Prosser, but I didn't see either of them given.

 

[busheybee]

Nocards :shrug:

I'm sure there were at least a couple. He did do well thoyugh. Veyr sensible and unfussy. Just got on and did his job well without grabbing the limelight.

 

[GP200]

Two cards, apparently, but I didn't see either of them given.

..............defender for a challenge on Charles in the first half at the halfway line...................

 

[sonofabee]

Two cards, apparently, for Ahmed and Prosser, but I didn't see either of them given.

I thought Davidson got booked for the challenge on Bean and Prosser for taking Charlie out as he went round him again

 

[robBEEh]

I thought Davidson got booked for the challenge on Bean and Prosser for taking Charlie out as he went round him again

Correct

 

[coconino]

..............defender for a challenge on Charles in the first half at the halfway line...................

Yes, seems that Ahmed (whose dad I met on the train home) got one for an unfair challenge on Bean, and Prosser the same for a challenge on Charlie. I saw the incidents but somehow missed seeing the cards.

 

[coconino]

Ah, BBC says Ahmed, but Vale's match report says Davidson.

 

[The H]

what would vale know, they don't know a great ground when they see one....

 

[Davee]

He looked soo young! But had a great game, not sure the Vale fans would agree.

 

[coconino]

 

[West Ealing Bee]

Ah, BBC says Ahmed, but Vale's match report says Davidson.

BBC takes a PA feed, I was sitting next to the guy from Port Vale. We both had it as Davidson.

 

[Markybee]

Davidson was booked in the 9th minute from memory. He was the one sent of at their place.

 

[Jimbee]

I actually thought he was about to book whoever went down for the penalty until the nice linesman did his job.

 

[Les Beeavinu]

I actually thought he was about to book whoever went down for the penalty until the nice linesman did his job.

I wondered what he was doing. I thought maybe he was checking that the trip was in the area.

 

[benfleetbee]

www.refworld.com/referee/130/1

 

[benfleetbee]

And for every good ref there's www.refworld.com/referee/177/0

 

[Stanley]

A good ref for sure, well done to him.

It was to be honest an easy game to ref, but I am sure tw*twell would have managed to have sent at least one player off and ruined it for some.

I am not sure he wouldn't have seen Woods blinding tackles as dangerous play for one.

 

[FarnhamBee]

I thought maybe he was checking that the trip was in the area.

Not that it mattered in the end but I think the trip was just outside but Marvin managed to land well inside

 

[nocoat]

Yes, that was mentioned yesterday..... :blush

 

[FarnhamBee]

has he ever been seen in the same place as no coat? are they twins?

Hmmm...

 

[GP200]

................spooky.......................

 

[nocoat]

Kindly airbrush my barnacle out in future!!

 

[leatherhat]

i'd say he is more maddogging than nocoat

 

[WarrenBee]

I never knew nocoat was in the Deer Hunter.

 

[BuzzBeeSi]

Thought he was pretty biased towards us to be honest.

 

[Jimbee]

i'd say he is more maddogging than nocoat

Did he get a bottle of Just for Men for Christmas?