Who were they? You'd expect David Lloyd and Mike Atherton to have a slight favouritism towards the fairer county of the North.
Well, here are copies of my emails sent and reply on this subject. I have a senior contact at Sky who provided me with the initial contact name.
Dear xxxxx,
Sorry to trouble you but I really must complain about the totally biased commentry on this match.
You have 3 ex Lancs players (Atherton, Cork, Allott), an ex Surrey Player (Butcher, who will certainly not talk Middx up) and the pathetic Colevile (Surrey "fan") doing his usual village idiot impersonation.
Why no chat with Gus, Chris Rogers at close of play etc everything has been from a Lancs perspective.
Absolutely pathetic,
Yours in disgust,
Hugh C Edwards
(unbiased Middx Life Member)
Their reply :-
Dear Hugh,
My name is Bryan Henderson and I am the Executive Producer of cricket at Sky Sports. I am responding to your email to xxxx.
I'm sorry the coverage is not to your satisfaction and that you are in fact "disgusted" with our efforts.
I also don't agree with your views however I'm afraid. The story yesterday was Glenn Chapple hence why he was interviewed post play. We have spoken to Chris Rogers twice during the match. The interviews count is exactly level between the two teams. Angus Fraser asked not to speak to us this week or take up the offer of commentary.
While it's true we have three Lancashire ex players the commentators were rotad to do this match before the game was chosen.
I have spoken to Paul who whilst accepting he wants Lancashire to win takes great exception to any accusation of biased commentary.
Michael Atherton is one of the most respected commentators in the world.
Naturally I am going to defend my team but I am genuinely concerned you feel the way you do.
Very happy to discuss further. Thank you for watching and for getting in touch.
Kind regards
Bryan
To which I have replied :-
Dear Bryan,
Thank you very much for taking the trouble to reply to my message, I didn't
answer your email earlier as I have been absolutely riveted to your coverage
of the cricket, I doubt if I have missed more than a dozen balls over the 4
days.
I have been a member of Middlesex CCC for well over 40 years and a life
member for 28 years, having seen my first game at Lords when Compton, Edrich
and Jack Robertson were plying their trade. You could say that I am a
passionate supporter but that would be an understatement. Hence my
disappointment to see you field such an array of Lanky and Surrey
commentators.
I must say that I found the coverage today much better and don't know if
that was due to other comments by Middlesex fans (see their comments on the
MTWD forum) or a realisation that their game was up. The absence of Mike
Atherton (sorry, not my favourite after the "dirt in the pocket" incident)
and what seemed like greater use of Nick Knight (someone who I have a lot of
respect for).
The one guy I have no time for is Charles Colvile (sorry again, but always
looking to stir something up that doesn't exist and making himself look like
a complete amateur). Great when he gets taken to task in particular by
Dominic Cork.
Enough rambling, I look forward to your winter coverage (but definitely not
the IPL).
Regards,
Hugh Edwards