Squad Value

Status
Not open for further replies.
BFC1997

BFC1997

Very well-known member
Joined
12 Feb 2011
Messages
18,035
Reaction score
20,410
Location
Isleworth

Squad Value

Saw a Villa fan tweet and reckon our squad was worth £30m.

Sounded like a lot at first but then realised he meant that it was relatively small. I began going through our squad and doing sums, but I’d like to hear what other people think. My view:

Bentley - £3.5m
Daniels - £150k

Dalsgaard - £750k
Henry - £5m
Clarke - £1m
Field - £250k

Barbet - £4m
Mepham - £1m
Egan - £2m
Bjelland - £500k
Sorensen - £200k

Woods - £6m
Yennaris - £1.25m
Mokotjo - £750k
Sawyers - £2m
McEachran - £500k
McLeod - £250k
Judge - £500k
Kerschbaumer - £250k

Canos - £4m
Watkins - £5m
Jozefzoon - £750k
Archibald - £100k

Vibe - £1m
Maupay - £1.5m
Shaibu - £75k

Total = £42,025,000

Whichever would get us.... 56.03% of Virgil Van Dijk.

I am probably way off the mark with some of these. Would be really interested to know what everyone else thinks our players are worth...


PS. our players are only worth what other clubs are prepared to pay for them, so figures should be based on what you we could get in January, not potential values should they continue to progress.
 

Squad Value

..........£4m for Barbet???...........
 

Squad Value

Watkins is currently by some distance the most valuable player in terms of potential transfer value IMO. I think you’re £4-5m light.
 

Squad Value

I think you’ve undervalued Egan, Judge and Kerschbaumer. Possibly overvalued Jozefzoon, Bjelland and Vibe if you take their length of contact into account.
 

Squad Value

I can't imagine anyone paying £4m for Barbet or £3.5m for Bentley. And £5m for Henry seems extremely optimistic. We paid £1.5m a short while ago and most of the time since then he's been injured so how could his value have gone up so steeply?

The £30m total suggested by the Villa fan might not be entirely unreasonable.
 

Squad Value

I think if someone wanted Watkins in January they would be parting with nearer £8m-£9m.

Sawyers would be nearer £5m

Also you went low with the values due to the injuries with Judge and Mcleod which I understand but presumably you should apply the same logic with Henry as well?

Not sure how you got a value of £200k for Sorenson based on zero performances in the first team so far.
 

Squad Value

I think you are light on a few of those. The other factor that is that we probably would sell some of those for the value you suggest but with hefty sell on clauses
 

Squad Value

BFC1997 said:
Potentially yeah. But what about right now?
Click to expand...

As whyteleafbee says above, I think £8-9m would be the sort of level someone one be having to pay for Watkins right now. I think he really is that bright a prospect.
 

Squad Value

Hard to say really a lot of value is in potential so I doubt we would let Mepham go for anywhere near what you say. Similarly Sawyers.

Last night just goes to show that winning isn't all about inflated transfer values its about teamwork and value for money .

If anyone offers £1.5m for Maupay just let me know when you want me to arrive to drive him there myself.
 

Squad Value

i appreciate that it's a curio "for discussion" but i think it'd be quite a nerdy discussion down the pub - most normal people would surely shrug and say "who cares", cos what does it really matter?

what about Villa's squad value? would it be any better? i doubt it - Hogan would struggle to command a fee at the moment, etc. so not sure what the Villa fan's point would have been. but there's a lot of bitter Villa ***** on twitter at the mo. it's quite funny really lol
 

Squad Value

The test will be if a top team comes to invest in their future with Mepham, if we can all see what he is about so will all the scouts.

Where would you call the sale point over the future ?
 

Squad Value

BFC1997 said:
Saw a Villa fan tweet and reckon our squad was worth £30m.

Sounded like a lot at first but then realised he meant that it was relatively small. I began going through our squad and doing sums, but I’d like to hear what other people think. My view:

Bentley - £3.5m
Daniels - £150k

Dalsgaard - £750k
Henry - £5m
Clarke - £1m
Field - £250k

Barbet - £4m
Mepham - £1m
Egan - £2m
Bjelland - £500k
Sorensen - £200k

Woods - £6m
Yennaris - £1.25m
Mokotjo - £750k
Sawyers - £2m
McEachran - £500k
McLeod - £250k
Judge - £500k
Kerschbaumer - £250k

Canos - £4m
Watkins - £5m
Jozefzoon - £750k
Archibald - £100k

Vibe - £1m
Maupay - £1.5m
Shaibu - £75k

Total = £42,025,000

Whichever would get us.... 56.03% of Virgil Van Dijk.

I am probably way off the mark with some of these. Would be really interested to know what everyone else thinks our players are worth...


PS. our players are only worth what other clubs are prepared to pay for them, so figures should be based on what you we could get in January, not potential values should they continue to progress.
Click to expand...

Watkins is probably the player who would command the biggest fee even now so I 'd increase his value.

The rest I think Nico is worth a bit more and Barbet about half your value at the moment and Mepham before too many games will be circa £5M given the bin dippers have just paid £75M for Virgil Van Dyke

Incredible to think that only 6 or 7 years ago we weren't paying transfer fees and only once in a blue moon did we have players that we sold and made money on or who went onto play at a higher level!

We were a plucky, game battling team who occasionally upset a bigger club in the league cup but were happy to be a mid table third division club, happy days are here.
 
Last edited:

Squad Value

Have any of our players ever been sold for as much, or more, as the consensus on this board thought they should have been?
 

Squad Value

pompeybee said:
Have any of our players ever been sold for as much, or more, as the consensus on this board thought they should have been?
Click to expand...

Button, Dean, Colin, Jota, Tarky, Hogan and Gray went for as much as was expected I reckon.

Was hoping for more from Moses, Dallas, and Bidwell
 

Squad Value

BFC1997 said:
Button, Dean, Colin, Jota, Tarky, Hogan and Gray went for as much as was expected I reckon.

Was hoping for more from Moses, Dallas, and Bidwell
Click to expand...

We were never going to get more for Moses due to his exit clause. £3m or nothing!
 

Squad Value

Expect the club and Alan Judge hope he can get back to something like his old self and someone will come in with an offer around say three million for us and double wages for him.
 

Squad Value

BFC1997 said:
Saw a Villa fan tweet and reckon our squad was worth £30m.

Sounded like a lot at first but then realised he meant that it was relatively small. I began going through our squad and doing sums, but I’d like to hear what other people think. My view:

Bentley - £3.5m Little low IMO
Daniels About right

Dalsgaard - £750k As above
Henry - £5m Too high
Clarke - £1m About right
Field - £250k As above

Barbet - £4m Half that maybe 3
Mepham - £1m Too early but around that mark
Egan - £2m Spot on
Bjelland - £500k As above
Sorensen - £200k No idea

Woods - £6m I would want nearer 8
Yennaris - £1.25m Way too low add another mill
Mokotjo - £750k About right
Sawyers - £2m Way too low. Nearer 5 IMO
McEachran - £500k Correct
McLeod - £250k Injury related i guess and if back playing regular then 1-2mill
Judge - £500k As above 3-5 mill if back at the same level.
Kerschbaumer - £250k Correct

Canos - £4m Low, would like to think 5-6
Watkins - £5m Add anoither 4
Jozefzoon - £750k About right
Archibald - £100k No idea

Vibe - £1m Too high with contract situation
Maupay - £1.5m Correct
Shaibu - £75k No idea.

Total = £42,025,000

Whichever would get us.... 56.03% of Virgil Van Dijk.

I am probably way off the mark with some of these. Would be really interested to know what everyone else thinks our players are worth...


PS. our players are only worth what other clubs are prepared to pay for them, so figures should be based on what you we could get in January, not potential values should they continue to progress.
Click to expand...
 

Squad Value

BFC1997 said:
Saw a Villa fan tweet and reckon our squad was worth £30m.

Sounded like a lot at first but then realised he meant that it was relatively small. I began going through our squad and doing sums, but I’d like to hear what other people think. My view:

Bentley - £3.5m
Daniels - £150k

Dalsgaard - £750k
Henry - £5m
Clarke - £1m
Field - £250k

Barbet - £4m
Mepham - £1m
Egan - £2m
Bjelland - £500k
Sorensen - £200k

Woods - £6m
Yennaris - £1.25m
Mokotjo - £750k
Sawyers - £2m
McEachran - £500k
McLeod - £250k
Judge - £500k
Kerschbaumer - £250k

Canos - £4m
Watkins - £5m
Jozefzoon - £750k
Archibald - £100k

Vibe - £1m
Maupay - £1.5m
Shaibu - £75k

Total = £42,025,000

Whichever would get us.... 56.03% of Virgil Van Dijk.

I am probably way off the mark with some of these. Would be really interested to know what everyone else thinks our players are worth...


PS. our players are only worth what other clubs are prepared to pay for them, so figures should be based on what you we could get in January, not potential values should they continue to progress.
Click to expand...

I genuinely think you have undervalued all of our players here...bar Barbet! I would imagine that the club will over achieve against each of the players if and when we sell!
 

Squad Value

Bush Tuckerman said:
I genuinely think you have undervalued all of our players here...bar Barbet! I would imagine that the club will over achieve against each of the players if and when we sell!
Click to expand...
Sawyers would command a fee way more than £2m Imo.
 

Squad Value

Watkins is worth about the same as Hogan IMO, if not a tad more.
 

Squad Value

Nada Bee said:
Watkins is worth about the same as Hogan IMO, if not a tad more.
Click to expand...

He probably isn't just yet but will be very soon if he maintains progress. I would wager he'll be our record transfer received within next two seasons if we're not challenging for promotion or already in the Premier League.

He'll play in the Premier League unlike Hogan
 

Squad Value

this is the most pointless thread since Nada Bees "how old is everyone" thread and poll rofl
 

Squad Value

BFC1997 said:
Bentley - £3.5m - £3m....a few too many mistakes to be more than that, if he irradiates them, then it will be higher.
Daniels - £150k - 400k I would say...he was seen as pretty solid for Scunthorpe.

Dalsgaard - £750k - £1.25m, international and decent LD. 750k is too light IMO.
Henry - £5m - Probably...
Clarke - £1m - Too low nowadays, £1.5m. He's versatile too which is a decreasingly common trait.
Field - £250k - Probably...

Barbet - £4m - £3m
Mepham - £1m - £3m...every 5 games he starts he'll probably go up by half a mill. He's only just turned 20.
Egan - £2m - Agreed
Bjelland - £500k - Agreed....unfortunately.
Sorensen - £200k - Erm....I don't know lol

Woods - £6m - Probably.
Yennaris - £1.25m - I reckon we could get £2m...
Mokotjo - £750k - £1.25m
Sawyers - £2m - £3m
McEachran - £500k - £1m maybe...
McLeod - £250k - Injuries puts this about right...
Judge - £500k - £1.5m....if he plays well then about £4m
Kerschbaumer - £250k - Maybe even less....

Canos - £4m - £5.5m...will rise.
Watkins - £5m - £7m.
Jozefzoon - £750k - £1.25m
Archibald - £100k - Fair...maybe a bit less.

Vibe - £1m - I'd say so...
Maupay - £1.5m - We bought him for more, he's still developing but yes this currently is about right.
Shaibu - £75k - Also about right.

Total = £42,025,000 - £52,275,000
Click to expand...

That's what I make it as, certainly not bad....but £30m the Villa fan said is definitely too low.
 
Last edited:

Squad Value

Currently worth what someone is willing to pay
 

Squad Value

Gee Bee said:
Currently worth what someone is willing to pay
Click to expand...
Especially if it's a fire sale. It's good to see the optimism, though, keep it up!
 

Squad Value

nocoat said:
this is the most pointless thread since Nada Bees "how old is everyone" thread and poll rofl
Click to expand...

All the threads on here are pointless. It's a board for discussion.
 

Squad Value

jlove said:
Especially if it's a fire sale. It's good to see the optimism, though, keep it up!
Click to expand...

Not a fire sale at all, we have proven time and again that a fire sale offer isn't acceptable and get to a value that someone is willing to pay that the club club also deem acceptable. In some cases over priced!!!
 

Squad Value

BFC1997 said:
Saw a Villa fan tweet and reckon our squad was worth £30m.

Sounded like a lot at first but then realised he meant that it was relatively small. I began going through our squad and doing sums, but I’d like to hear what other people think. My view:

Bentley - £3.5m
Daniels - £150k

Dalsgaard - £750k
Henry - £5m
Clarke - £1m
Field - £250k

Barbet - £4m
Mepham - £1m
Egan - £2m
Bjelland - £500k
Sorensen - £200k

Woods - £6m
Yennaris - £1.25m
Mokotjo - £750k
Sawyers - £2m
McEachran - £500k
McLeod - £250k
Judge - £500k
Kerschbaumer - £250k

Canos - £4m
Watkins - £5m
Jozefzoon - £750k
Archibald - £100k

Vibe - £1m
Maupay - £1.5m
Shaibu - £75k

Total = £42,025,000

Whichever would get us.... 56.03% of Virgil Van Dijk.

I am probably way off the mark with some of these. Would be really interested to know what everyone else thinks our players are worth...


PS. our players are only worth what other clubs are prepared to pay for them, so figures should be based on what you we could get in January, not potential values should they continue to progress.
Click to expand...

Just shows how quick Football changes.

As I think it is now safe to say that one on this lists value can safely be revised upwards. I for one at the time did not really didn’t think you were far out.

Happy days especially as we still have him for now :)
 

Squad Value

kaebess said:
Just shows how quick Football changes.

As I think it is now safe to say that one on this lists value can safely be revised upwards. I for one at the time did not really didn’t think you were far out.

Happy days especially as we still have him for now :)
Click to expand...

Looks like being a busy summer for the DoF. Several players with contract up or in the final year. Add to the potential offers we could receive. Around 12 players could be in discussions.
 

Squad Value

Bjelland now has no transfer value as he is out of contract in the summer, 500k for Josh, I think we would have taken that if anyone offered it.
 

Squad Value

WARFIELD BEE said:
Bjelland now has no transfer value as he is out of contract in the summer, 500k for Josh, I think we would have taken that if anyone offered it.
Click to expand...

What I heard is that DOF have put Lasse on commission, if he can sell Josh in China, he gets a decent cut
 

Squad Value

kaebess said:
What I heard is that DOF have put Lasse on commission, if he can sell Josh in China, he gets a decent cut
Click to expand...

Tbf I thought he might appeal to a Chinese club, could see him excelling there and he was once the next big thing at Chelsea.. just what they want
 

Squad Value

Invipai said:
That's what I make it as, certainly not bad....but £30m the Villa fan said is definitely too low.
Click to expand...

Percentage wise money spend against worth now I would say we are way ahead of Villa.
 

Squad Value

BFC1997 said:
Saw a Villa fan tweet and reckon our squad was worth £30m.

Sounded like a lot at first but then realised he meant that it was relatively small. I began going through our squad and doing sums, but I’d like to hear what other people think. My view:

Bentley - £3.5m - £4m
Daniels - £150k - £0

Dalsgaard - £750k - £1m
Henry - £5m - £7m+ (potentially)
Clarke - £1m - £250k
Field - £250k - £0 - sell on

Barbet - £4m - £2m
Mepham - £1m - £15m (all going well!)
Egan - £2m - £2.5m
Bjelland - £500k - £0
Sorensen - £200k - £? (unknown as yet)

Woods - £6m - £6m
Yennaris - £1.25m - £500k
Mokotjo - £750k - £500k
Sawyers - £2m - £4m
McEachran - £500k - £0
McLeod - £250k - £500k
Judge - £500k - £750k
Kerschbaumer - £250k - £150k

Canos - £4m - £3m
Watkins - £5m - £10m
Jozefzoon - £750k - £500k
Archibald - £100k - £0 - sell ons

Vibe - £1m - £3m (incredible figure received)
Maupay - £1.5m - £1m
Shaibu - £75k - £100k

Total = £42,025,000 - £60.25m (I think?!)
Click to expand...

My twopenneth worth. :shrug:

It’s all a bit CM2018 really. :)
 

Squad Value

wanderer paul said:
My twopenneth worth. :shrug:

It’s all a bit CM2018 really. :)
Click to expand...

Of course. Just a bit of fun.

The only area I think we seem to be in significant disagreement on is Nico. Young-ish, versatile, captain material and can score goals. I would have thought he might be worth a pretty decent fee
 

Squad Value

BFC1997 said:
Of course. Just a bit of fun.

The only area I think we seem to be in significant disagreement on is Nico. Young-ish, versatile, captain material and can score goals. I would have thought he might be worth a pretty decent fee
Click to expand...

His worth to us is higher than his apparent value to others. He's unflashy and versatile. Opponents don't quite notice him in the way that they regularly single Woods out as making us tick.
 

Squad Value

wanderer paul said:
My twopenneth worth. :shrug:

It’s all a bit CM2018 really. :)
Click to expand...

Surely this should be what the club believe the players are worth; i.e. do you rally think if we received an offer of £500k for Nico we'd sell him? I would have thought players like Nico, Mokotjo would be minimum £2m before we would even entertain selling.
 

Squad Value

aw a Villa fan tweet and reckon our squad was worth £30m.

Sounded like a lot at first but then realised he meant that it was relatively small. I began going through our squad and doing sums, but I’d like to hear what other people think. My view:

Bentley - £3.5m Little low IMO
Daniels About right

Dalsgaard - £750k As above
Henry - £5m Too high
Clarke - £1m About right
Field - £250k As above

Barbet - £4m Half that maybe 3
Mepham - £1m Too early but around that mark
Egan - £2m Spot on
Bjelland - £500k As above
Sorensen - £200k No idea

Woods - £6m I would want nearer 8
Yennaris - £1.25m Way too low add another mill
Mokotjo - £750k About right
Sawyers - £2m Way too low. Nearer 5 IMO
McEachran - £500k Correct
McLeod - £250k Injury related i guess and if back playing regular then 1-2mill
Judge - £500k As above 3-5 mill if back at the same level.
Kerschbaumer - £250k Correct

Canos - £4m Low, would like to think 5-6
Watkins - £5m Add anoither 4
Jozefzoon - £750k About right
Archibald - £100k No idea

Vibe - £1m Too high with contract situation
Maupay - £1.5m Correct
Shaibu - £75k No idea.

Total = £42,025,000

How things have changed,1 million for Mepham......
 

Squad Value

Canos value will have gone right down, Mephams up. Wonder if we might squeeze more out of Kersch in the summer too
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Share this page

Back
Top Bottom