You are the Ref

I

Inappropriate Smilies Bee

Well-known member
Joined
16 Apr 2003
Messages
20,100
Reaction score
9,365
Location
SE13

You are the Ref

not really, but just pretend ok!

In the 80th minute of the match theres an injury which takes 25 minutes (like owusu at bristol city that time). if this is the only stoppage of the half, then how much injury time would you add on, ten or 25 minutes?

:cutthecrap:
 

You are the Ref

kempy said:
10 minutes surely.
Click to expand...

Definitely, the first 10 minutes of the injury represent minutes 81-90 of the game, the rest are irrelevant. You'd add any stoppage time that had already
been accumulated up to the incident and play that much more time, ie if you had already planned on 3 mins extra time, you'd play 13 more in total
 

You are the Ref

Inappropriate Smilies Bee said:
not really, but just pretend ok!

In the 80th minute of the match theres an injury which takes 25 minutes (like owusu at bristol city that time). if this is the only stoppage of the half, then how much injury time would you add on, ten or 25 minutes?

:cutthecrap:
Click to expand...

lol I don't believe you actually got replies.
 

You are the Ref

Jimbee said:
lol I don't believe you actually got replies.
Click to expand...


it was a serious question though. if the answer was 25 minutes then i was thinking if we were losing 1-0 in the 89th minute of a big match we could fake an injury for an hour and a half (one that needs a helicopter or dentist or something) & we would have a whole extra 90 minutes to get the equaliser.

:theorange:theorange
 

You are the Ref

Surely it depends with the board goes up :idea:

Does the 4th official hold up "10" for the entirity of the injury beyond the 10th minute?
 

You are the Ref

......................is it Cheddar???.................
 

You are the Ref

Inappropriate Smilies Bee said:
not really, but just pretend ok!

In the 80th minute of the match theres an injury which takes 25 minutes (like owusu at bristol city that time). if this is the only stoppage of the half, then how much injury time would you add on, ten or 25 minutes?

:cutthecrap:
Click to expand...

I'd send you off you crazy nutterroflrofllol
 

You are the Ref

Take no notice of some of the comments ISB, I think it's a very interesting question that some on here haven't got a clue as to the answer. Not saying I have but I think the answer is 10 mins purely based on the fact that it is irrelevant how long the injury takes (bloke could be lying there all night), if there are ten minutes left and the injury takes it beyond the 90th minute then the game is at and end but the lost 10 mins must still be played. Hence ten mins. My God I can't believe I've thought that one out either
 

You are the Ref

TW1Bee said:
Take no notice of some of the comments ISB, I think it's a very interesting question that some on here haven't got a clue as to the answer. Not saying I have but I think the answer is 10 mins purely based on the fact that it is irrelevant how long the injury takes (bloke could be lying there all night), if there are ten minutes left and the injury takes it beyond the 90th minute then the game is at and end but the lost 10 mins must still be played. Hence ten mins. My God I can't believe I've thought that one out either
Click to expand...

ISB and TW1, please tell me you are both joking - otherwise I'm flummoxed........................although that tends to happen quite frequently these days.lol
 

You are the Ref

You add 10 minutes and play 15 (unless it's Man Utd and there a goal down)
 

You are the Ref

:scratch: thanks for that Westlad... surely you meant to write "you add 10 and play 10 (unless it's Man Utd and THEY'RE a goal down, in which case you play 15)"
 

You are the Ref

....................is it Brie???....................
 

You are the Ref

I would carry on playing until Manchester Rovers finally got the winner.
 

You are the Ref

Mr Tree said:
:scratch: thanks for that Westlad... surely you meant to write "you add 10 and play 10 (unless it's Man Utd and THEY'RE a goal down, in which case you play 15)"
Click to expand...
Meant to write you play 25. Match restarts on 105, 15 mins into injury time, then you play the remaining 10 minutes of injury time.
 

You are the Ref

......................or camembert......................
 

You are the Ref

..............far too cheesy.......................
 

You are the Ref

dunno if u noticed, but Phoenixkeeper fell for this in the Man U-Man City thread ;)
 

You are the Ref

I didn't fall for it, I merely waited to see who would pick up on my deliberate mistake ( and if you believe that......!!! )
 

You are the Ref

......................so..................wotsit to be........................
 

You are the Ref

nobody can answer the question then? :sorted:
was anyone at bristol city that time owusu was down for 26 minutes? i was glued to ceefax til the early hours waiting for the 'FT' to appear by the result.
:love2:
 

You are the Ref

...............that soft spready stuff that the kids eat???................
 

You are the Ref

Jimbee said:
I was there. Thanks.
Click to expand...

was it 26 minutes injury time mate?

was it a neck injury or is it true he had a clause in his contract to have a kip during one match per season?

:thetruth:
 

You are the Ref

80th minute - Injury

90th minute - the fourth official holds up 10 minutes injury time (assuming no other stoppages in match)

105th minute - play resumes

115th minute - final whistle
 

You are the Ref

.............................Red Leicester............................
 

You are the Ref

#2

NEW QUESTION - a player is caught short to powder his bottom during a match and doesn't want to disappear for a few minutes & reduce his team to ten men temporarilly - so he has a dump in the middle of the pitch. is this a free kick? yellow card for ungentlemanly conduct? red card? if the "offence" takes place in his own penalty area is it a penalty?

:love2:

please reply urgently as i am on my iphone, playing for my pub team, have already been booked and am fooking bursting!!!

:love:
 

You are the Ref

if i was the ref, i'd probably interpret your actions as a sign of dissent. obviously, you would protest that you were dying for the loo, but that, clearly, would also be dissent. straight red, play suspended while groundsman is contacted and asked to bring a pooper-scooper onto the pitch.
 

You are the Ref

Inappropriate Smilies Bee said:
NEW QUESTION - a player is caught short to powder his bottom during a match and doesn't want to disappear for a few minutes & reduce his team to ten men temporarilly - so he has a dump in the middle of the pitch. is this a free kick? yellow card for ungentlemanly conduct? red card? if the "offence" takes place in his own penalty area is it a penalty?

:love2:

please reply urgently as i am on my iphone, playing for my pub team, have already been booked and am fooking bursting!!!

:love:
Click to expand...

If this happed at the Cottage I would award the dumpers team a 3-0 win.

:sorted:
 

You are the Ref

Was it Garry Neville today who dashed down the tunnel pulling his pants down as he went for what seemed like a crap justbefore he came on as a sub ?
 

You are the Ref

Inappropriate Smilies Bee said:
NEW QUESTION - a player is caught short to powder his bottom during a match and doesn't want to disappear for a few minutes & reduce his team to ten men temporarilly - so he has a dump in the middle of the pitch. is this a free kick? yellow card for ungentlemanly conduct? red card? if the "offence" takes place in his own penalty area is it a penalty?

:love2:

please reply urgently as i am on my iphone, playing for my pub team, have already been booked and am fooking bursting!!!

:love:
Click to expand...

............................sh*t ground.............no pants..................
 

You are the Ref

Changing tack completely anyone know how Belletti got a red card and Vidic didn't other than the fact the Hilarious in the Chelski goal was having a mare and Barry probably would have scored from that angle?
 

You are the Ref

kevalutonbee said:
Changing tack completely anyone know how Belletti got a red card and Vidic didn't other than the fact the Hilarious in the Chelski goal was having a mare and Barry probably would have scored from that angle?
Click to expand...

Poll on R5 this morning was explaining the Vidic decision on the basis that Agbonlahor was "going away from goal"; true he was going slightly to his left but you often have to go round a defender/keeper, which means going slightly to one side. I reckon 9 out of 10 refs (at least) would have produced the red card in a league match as he was still in on goal
 

You are the Ref

You can go away from goal and still be denied "an obvious goal-scoring opportunity".

What exactly to the laws state on this issue?
 

You are the Ref

Banana said:
You can go away from goal and still be denied "an obvious goal-scoring opportunity".

What exactly to the laws state on this issue?
Click to expand...

The thing is, it is open to interpretation and thats where accusations of bias start.

Agbonlahor would have had to take at least one touch to straighten up once he had gone past Vidic. Dowd may have assumed that this would have brought Evra into play, meaning Vidic wasn't the last man. However, the fact he never even booked Vidic leads me to suspect that he just cocked it up.
 

You are the Ref

i don't think it was such a howler from the ref at all personally and was certainly not the type of synical "professional foul" that this law was brought in to stop (after viv andersons book).

:bound:
 

You are the Ref

Inappropriate Smilies Bee said:
i don't think it was such a howler from the ref at all personally and was certainly not the type of synical "professional foul" that this law was brought in to stop (after viv andersons book).

:bound:
Click to expand...

I think that very few fouls in the box meet that description as the threat from the penalty is often greater than from the chance. But, the way most refs use it now, Vidic should have gone
 

You are the Ref

kempy said:
He should have got a yellow for leaving the field of play.
Click to expand...

And then another one for returning to the field of play without permission
 

You are the Ref

Ref was trying to make up with with Mr Ferguson....he will now get a Christmas card in December.
 

You are the Ref

Porgey said:
Good answers!! :computer:

So the original question remains then - what if he had done it on the field of play?
Click to expand...

Public indecency offence under civil law with n thousand witnesses?
 
62 More Posts...
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Back
Top Bottom