Should Scott Go?

Should Scott Go.

  • Yes, Resign/Get Sacked Now. You've had your last game

    Votes: 158 35.7%

  • You've got the next 2 games

    Votes: 79 17.8%

  • You've got until Christmas/New Year

    Votes: 106 23.9%

  • No, he's the man to turn this around

    Votes: 100 22.6%
  • Total voters
    443
Status
Not open for further replies.

Should Scott Go?

He isn't going anywhere, don't hold your breath.
 

Should Scott Go?

He wont be sacked, lets face it.
 

Should Scott Go?

First time I have thought this, think it's time to say goodbye
 

Should Scott Go?

braunton bee said:
i would give him one more game and see what happens
Click to expand...

But your thread says "scott must go" ?
Who would you like instead and what would you do differently ?
 

Should Scott Go?

...unfortunately another clueless display,something is not right...
 

Should Scott Go?

We need a midfield. End of. If the current manager can deliver that fine, if not so long and thanks for all the fish.
 

Should Scott Go?

SmiffyBee said:
But your thread says "scott must go" ?
Who would you like instead and what would you do differently ?
Click to expand...

Surely you have seen enough football at our level to realise how poorly managed this club is.

Everybody you talk to including the Radio London commentary team tonight comments on our lack of creativity and long ball tactics

No creativity, too much hoofball, lack of pace, no sharpness in front of goal, players inhibited in the way they play, poor tactical awareness, players played out of position, substitutions too late or all wrong, out of form or tired players continually played, too many poor signings., crowds walking away in droves, fans bickering between themselves.

Do I need to go on. Scott is killing this club.

Who I would like. We will have to advertise like everyone else does unless the Board have had the foresight to tap somebody decent up already. Personally I'd be happy with Magilton but would be willing to see Holdsworth interviewed also.

:wave:

SCOTT OUT
 

Should Scott Go?

Whitton Borders Bee said:
I've turned now. Same tactical mistakes over and over again.

However, I think that digging out the likes of Nick Logan, who may have a different viewpoint is disgusting.
Click to expand...

Yeah! I am too tired, too disappointed and too much in need of a hot chocolate to spend any time defending AS tonight, but Nick Logan deserves no-one's ridicule. As loyal fans go, he is about as good as they come!!
 

Should Scott Go?

Give him 1 more game? Why?

So we can be negative, not have a shot on target and play hoofball one last time?

Or maybe so we can bring Forster on to play right wing after 85mins one more time?

Even if we win on Sat it doesn't paper over the mind numbing product on the pitch that we are having to endure.

I'd give him 15mins and counting.

The board need to realise that they are too going to come in for some stick if they don't act.
 

Should Scott Go?

Bridge Bee said:
Give him 1 more game? Why?

So we can be negative, not have a shot on target and play hoofball one last time?

Or maybe so we can bring Forster on to play right wing after 85mins one more time?

Even if we win on Sat it doesn't paper over the mind numbing product on the pitch that we are having to endure.

I'd give him 15mins and counting.

The board need to realise that they are too going to come in for some stick if they don't act.
Click to expand...

Hear hear!:sorted:

Fresh start f**k off Andy!
 

Should Scott Go?

Apparently Scott is Bees through and through. If he is he must surely want the best for them. Then surely that would be get a new manager in now!!!! Would I get rid of him before Sat? Absolutely! How much worse can it get? Maybe we'll not get one on target at Plymouth. No change there then!!

And yes, I would have MA back now if only for the rest of the season. At least his passion would keep us up and the fan base up. He may play a similar game but the players would want to play for him. They obviously don't want to for Scott.

Thanks and bye bye. :wave:
 

Should Scott Go?

IslandBee said:
Yeah! I am too tired, too disappointed and too much in need of a hot chocolate to spend any time defending AS tonight, but Nick Logan deserves no-one's ridicule. As loyal fans go, he is about as good as they come!!
Click to expand...

Exactly. Mr Logan has done a phenomenal job defending Scott against an avalanche of criticism - and doing it in such a good natured way. The club would be well and truly finished if someone like that deserted it.

I think the best tribute the club could pay to Nick would be for the Board to phone him in the morning and ask for his agreement before they sack him - as long as he doesn't say no ! :)
 

Should Scott Go?

In August with the signings made, the investment by Benham and the decent finishing position last season I think we all expected us to be "up there" at this stage.
However we are not.
We are not playing nice football. We are not playing any football.
Strikers are injured and midfielders not creating.

However we are not adrift in league one. Andy can pull this round. I will give him till the end of the year at least before calling for the axe.
Leave me off the band wagon til then.
 

Should Scott Go?

cromerbee said:
Apparently Scott is Bees through and through. If he is he must surely want the best for them. Then surely that would be get a new manager in now!!!! Would I get rid of him before Sat? Absolutely! How much worse can it get? Maybe we'll not get one on target at Plymouth. No change there then!!

And yes, I would have MA back now if only for the rest of the season. At least his passion would keep us up and the fan base up. He may play a similar game but the players would want to play for him. They obviously don't want to for Scott.

Thanks and bye bye. :wave:
Click to expand...


AS is and that's the difficult part........

Get Eddie Howe in the summer????
 

Should Scott Go?

SmiffyBee said:
In August with the signings made, the investment by Benham and the decent finishing position last season I think we all expected us to be "up there" at this stage.
However we are not.
We are not playing nice football. We are not playing any football.
Strikers are injured and midfielders not creating.

However we are not adrift in league one. Andy can pull this round. I will give him till the end of the year at least before calling for the axe.
Leave me off the band wagon til then.
Click to expand...

End of the year so then what. We spend the whole of January interviewing and replacing him and miss out on the transfer window.

****ing great idea.

We tried that replacing over Christmas thing before in the Rosenior/Fitzgerald season. It didn't work then either.

Now is the best time.
 

Should Scott Go?

SmiffyBee said:
In August with the signings made, the investment by Benham and the decent finishing position last season I think we all expected us to be "up there" at this stage.
However we are not.
We are not playing nice football. We are not playing any football.
Strikers are injured and midfielders not creating.

However we are not adrift in league one. Andy can pull this round. I will give him till the end of the year at least before calling for the axe.
Leave me off the band wagon til then.
Click to expand...

come on for gods sake
 

Should Scott Go?

Who wanted to go to Dover anyway.

We get a series of good results in October against Charlton, Tranmere, Peterborough and Exeter scoring 11 goals in the processes. Added to that a creditable performance at Brum in the League Cup.

Along comes November and we are back to September form, or perhaps worse. Five 90-minute games so far W0 D3 L2 and only 3 goals, including a penalty equaliser against Bomo.

There is something very wrong, either with the players or the way they are managed i.e. Nicky Forster has scored goals for every club he's played for but he's back here on a 2-year contract and so far he's got a big fat zero from the limited number of matches he's played in.

Plymouth here we come. Now there's a side out of form, but will we beat them
 

Should Scott Go?

SmiffyBee said:
But your thread says "scott must go" ?
Who would you like instead and what would you do differently ?
Click to expand...

Try playing some football and bring some entertainment back to griffin park. Sorry but it's been worse then awful, he's got to go and take TB with him.
I don't expect us to win every game or be top of the league, but I want to enjoy my football again, and that doesn't look like it will ever happen under AS.
 

Should Scott Go?

Give the BFC Board a few days, and I believe they will then make the move to relinquish Mr.S of his job. They will need those few days to be able to put out tentative feelers for those they might feel they would want in order to gauge the reaction of those persons.Wait and see!
 

Should Scott Go?

Dont think its bullys fault as he coaches them the way AS wants him too.
eg Scott says hoof..... bully tells them to hoof and shows them every day how to hoof in the correct manner
 

Should Scott Go?

Ray Wilkins or Martin Allen cos after tonight i am finally burnt with scotty...taken as far as he can so thanks for some good times now it's time to say farewell and good luck Andy. GO
 

Should Scott Go?

Dumped out of the FA cup by a team in a lower division.
Out of the Carling cup (Was unlucky there).
Dropping further down the league table.
Gates getting lower.
Fans running out of patience, apart from Mr Logan, whom I honestly respect.
How much worse does it have to get before the board act?
Sorry Mr Scott, no doubt you have done your best, but now it's time for you to go.

I agree with Cromerbee, bring back MA for the remainder of the season, and see how it goes from there.
Unfortunatly, I have this feeling that the board will do **** all.
 

Should Scott Go?

W10 bee said:
Ray Wilkins or Martin Allen cos after tonight i am finally burnt with scotty...taken as far as he can so thanks for some good times now it's time to say farewell and good luck Andy. GO
Click to expand...

Nooooo please not Raymondo.

Martin oyesssssssss please. FA Cup run, Play Offs, feel part of the club again, bacon sandwiches the Fri before cup games, warm drinks at the training ground, always free to chat..... yes please. Someone get me his number and I'll call him asap.
 

Should Scott Go?

DavidgRushden said:
Give the BFC Board a few days, and I believe they will then make the move to relinquish Mr.S of his job. They will need those few days to be able to put out tentative feelers for those they might feel they would want in order to gauge the reaction of those persons.Wait and see!
Click to expand...

Tend to agree with you. Here's hoping they can get some bites from those feelers !
 

Should Scott Go?

He should def be asked what his plan is to turn things around if he is to stay in charge after tonight.

He has openly dismissed tippy tappy football so a change of tactics won't happen.

Maybe we should go even more negative, play 4-5-1 and play for draws, at the same time as asking the FA to bring penalty shoot outs in for drawn league games.
 

Should Scott Go?

JTofBFC said:
End of the year so then what. We spend the whole of January interviewing and replacing him and miss out on the transfer window.

****ing great idea.

We tried that replacing over Christmas thing before in the Rosenior/Fitzgerald season. It didn't work then either.

Now is the best time.
Click to expand...

The squad and club are a million miles away from the Leroy era. I think he's due a little more time for the results (attractiveness of performance and luck don't count in the table) achieved before the MKD game.
As much as we moan about going out of the FA cup these results happen. Plymouth is many, many times more important than Aldershot.

As a side issue. The people being sh*tty to supporters of this club who defend Scott are really getting on my wick now. Let's have debate. Not vitriolic 'I told you so's'. Any real Brentford fan is never happy when we lose or are struggling in the league.
 

Should Scott Go?

cromerbee said:
Apparently Scott is Bees through and through. If he is he must surely want the best for them. Then surely that would be get a new manager in now!!!! Would I get rid of him before Sat? Absolutely! How much worse can it get? Maybe we'll not get one on target at Plymouth. No change there then!!

And yes, I would have MA back now if only for the rest of the season. At least his passion would keep us up and the fan base up. He may play a similar game but the players would want to play for him. They obviously don't want to for Scott.

Thanks and bye bye. :wave:
Click to expand...

There are very few managers "through and through" I think MA was the exception for us in many many a year, also the same for players sadly they move on very quickly and kiss badges where they are next at. But what our board should take note of is the number of long distance supporters who keep tabs on every game, Scotland, Czech Rep, Australia, USA etc. This club could continue to have a solid fan base but as others have said AS is losing that.
Let's get passion back to this club and it will stop the niggling digs at "good supporters" like Nick Logan et al

I really do think it is time to act as it does look to me that AS has lost the players (too many ins and outs) and has lost the majority of the supporters, and that it is when it is time act. That is my opinion and others have theirs

I have always liked AS when I have spoken to him (on a number of occasions) but I think the proof is in the product. He certainly wouldn't be in alan Sugar's last 10 candidates with the way the football as a marketing tool is being run at GP
 

Should Scott Go?

SmiffyBee said:
However we are not adrift in league one. Andy can pull this round. I will give him till the end of the year at least before calling for the axe.
Leave me off the band wagon til then.
Click to expand...

JTofBFC said:
End of the year so then what. We spend the whole of January interviewing and replacing him and miss out on the transfer window.

****ing great idea.

We tried that replacing over Christmas thing before in the Rosenior/Fitzgerald season. It didn't work then either.

Now is the best time.
Click to expand...

The reason AS should be replaced now is we are still in a position where all is not lost so a replacement now will have something to work towards and not just a relegation battle from day one. AS is not the Manager to turn things around and it is now very apparent hopefully the Board can see it as well!
 

Should Scott Go?

Look back to when spurs were at bottom of the league couple years ago then the was sack or left Harry took over suddenly players are happy they quickly turn their season round ended up getting champion league place .maybe its time for AS do do the humble thing and leave with dignity as 1 will never use my season ticket again until he leaves waisted money for the year. l bet you bring in a new manager you will see how quickly the players will change maybe the player don't like playing for him any more.
 

Should Scott Go?

rambo said:
hopefully the Board can see it as well!
Click to expand...


hear-no-evil.jpg
 

Should Scott Go?

Low End Bee said:
The squad and club are a million miles away from the Leroy era. I think he's due a little more time for the results (attractiveness of performance and luck don't count in the table) achieved before the MKD game.
As much as we moan about going out of the FA cup these results happen. Plymouth is many, many times more important than Aldershot.

As a side issue. The people being sh*tty to supporters of this club who defend Scott are really getting on my wick now. Let's have debate. Not vitriolic 'I told you so's'. Any real Brentford fan is never happy when we lose or are struggling in the league.
Click to expand...

Agree with your comments about being sh*tty to each other on here, but it goes both ways remember that. I just want the best for my club and I don't think AS will ever achieve it. I would rather come 18th playing football then 18th playing the crap we are currently playing. I don't care who the next manager is, I just want to enjoy my football again.
 

Should Scott Go?

There will be "told you so" from me, I'm gutted at this crapness in front of me.:(

However some of the waank that came from people saying that the football world had spoken and any doubters were idiots after AS's joke MOM award was shameful. Feck the football world as I watched those games, they didn't.
We're in trouble and have been for a while, 3 wins on the bounce won't change my mind but every loss hurts and they need to stop.

Fans aren't mugs.
 

Should Scott Go?

SmiffyBee said:
In August with the signings made, the investment by Benham and the decent finishing position last season I think we all expected us to be "up there" at this stage.
However we are not.
We are not playing nice football. We are not playing any football.
Strikers are injured and midfielders not creating.

However we are not adrift in league one. Andy can pull this round. I will give him till the end of the year at least before calling for the axe.
Leave me off the band wagon til then.
Click to expand...

Give him to the end of the year to do what?

We can not sustain the level of results required to push for the play offs!

We cannot expect the squad to respond to a Manager changing his footballing ethos midway through the campaign. Not that he would or could.

We cant seriously be allowing him time to scout players to purchase in January window. I would not let him choose someone in an Amsterdam window let alone a transfer window!

Oh I know lets give him to the end of the year to get us to Wembley for the JPT.

Lets give him to the end of the year when home attendances are below 4000

Lets give him another 6 weeks because he is Brentford fru and fru mate!

Lets give him to the end of the year to say the longest goodbye in he clubs history.

The board should have acted after Rochdale. Anybody who knows the slightest thing about FOOTBALL knew then that he was not the man to take us forward.

But if you will excuse the plageurism, (sic) Hey Ho, its Brentford innit!
 

Should Scott Go?

Forgive me if i'm wrong.....but hasn't AS signed a 5 year contract ?
If thats true,theres no way the board will pay him off.
 

Should Scott Go?

love and mercy said:
Dont think its bullys fault as he coaches them the way AS wants him too.
eg Scott says hoof..... bully tells them to hoof and shows them every day how to hoof in the correct manner
Click to expand...

Another insider !
 

Should Scott Go?

chizbee said:
Forgive me if i'm wrong.....but hasn't AS signed a 5 year contract ?
If thats true,theres no way the board will pay him off.
Click to expand...

One year rolling contract with lots of clauses on both sides.
 
894 More Posts...
Status
Not open for further replies.

Share this page

Back
Top Bottom