General General BFC Transfer Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

General BFC Transfer Thread

Interesting question.

I really think we need to sign another forward that can play no. 9 (Schade is not that man) and an Onyeka type midfielder than can also run past players with the ball and pass.

The chances of us signing a no9 to sit on the bench are between very little and none. If we do it will be someone who can operate across the front 3. We aren't spending big money on someone who won't get a game.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

I agree with this statement.

However I don't see Benham going for it significantly this month, by significantly I mean a Dango level of layout on a player(s).
If there's a chance to get someone like that though, i don't think we'd be shy. I can see us bringing in a first-team midfielder at least, if someone we like is available.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

The chances of us signing a no9 to sit on the bench are between very little and none. If we do it will be someone who can operate across the front 3. We aren't spending big money on someone who won't get a game.

We went for Beier
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

What about Makama from Norwich? Only 21 and having a good season in a poor side…..8 goals in 21 games
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

I thought he is an out and out striker
You could be well right, I didn’t realise he could play along the front 3
Wonder if we will make another try to get him? Although doubt Dortmund or player will entertain us..
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

I think some sort of cross between Ronaldo and Messi (in their prime of course). We need someone that can dribble past entire teams before slotting the ball home calmly from 40 yards into the top corner of the goal and then doing a stupid goal celebration. About 5 times a match will do.
I wide take a prime Ronaldo but Brazilian Ronaldo to fight with are other Brazilian goal getter for the number 9 (can but dream)
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

We went for Beier
I wonder if our idea about the next forward to buy have changed now we know Thiago can score goals in this league. When we last went shopping we didn't know and many posters has doubts.

Conversely has he done so well do we need to plan for life without him sooner than we thought in the last window?
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

I wonder if our idea about the next forward to buy have changed now we know Thiago can score goals in this league. When we last went shopping we didn't know and many posters has doubts.

Conversely has he done so well do we need to plan for life without him sooner than we thought in the last window?
My brain hurts, being dragged one way then the other!
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

We have 20 home grown players in the first team squad at the moment.
Those are home grown in nation, for Europe we’d also need home grown at club. IIRC, right now that’d be Balcombe, Henry, and Yarmo.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

Cox, Eyestone, Balcombe, Arthur, Maghoma, Onyeka, Peart-Harris, Konak, Donovan, Nunes.

All part of the first team squad but very very limited PL minutes between them.

Thats 3 GKs, 1 CB, 4 CMs and 2 FWs.

You’d expect then that we might see some outbounds in the “heavier” areas of the squad, either loans or permanents. Maybe not until after the shop window of the FA Cup fixture takes place.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

We do need to think about Norgaards replacement. Henderson is doing a good job for the moment but obviously isn't a long term solution.

The real benefit of having Henderson on board is that it's given us time to make a considered decision and two windows to make what will probably be a difficult signing.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

We do need to think about Norgaards replacement. Henderson is doing a good job for the moment but obviously isn't a long term solution.

The real benefit of having Henderson on board is that it's given us time to make a considered decision and two windows to make what will probably be a difficult signing.
Bang on. Henderson is a great leader and player to have in the dressing room but it would be ideal to get our long term target in early and learn from Henderson. Also Henderson can’t play full 90 minutes every game.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

We do need to think about Norgaards replacement. Henderson is doing a good job for the moment but obviously isn't a long term solution.

The real benefit of having Henderson on board is that it's given us time to make a considered decision and two windows to make what will probably be a difficult signing.
Isn’t that Konak? Will be interesting to see if he gets more minutes as the season progresses.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

We do need to think about Norgaards replacement. Henderson is doing a good job for the moment but obviously isn't a long term solution.

The real benefit of having Henderson on board is that it's given us time to make a considered decision and two windows to make what will probably be a difficult signing.
Im personally thinking Yarmo given his lack of goals/assists to date - gives us a good pivot with his pressing and passing from the 6 position which means someone like Milambo could be our 8 with Dams 10 depending on the game.

Could also deploy YY as a more defensive 8 against the top 6 with Konak/other in the 6 role.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

I wonder if our idea about the next forward to buy have changed now we know Thiago can score goals in this league. When we last went shopping we didn't know and many posters has doubts.

Conversely has he done so well do we need to plan for life without him sooner than we thought in the last window?
Either way, we need another No 9 asap. Thiago is playing injured and is probably playing too many minutes for his long-term good. Yesterday was a perfect example of why the argument that Schade is his stand-in doesn't hold water. Thiago should probably have been subbed off if we want him to start against Everton, less than 70 hours after the last game finished, but Schade wasn't having one of his better games so made no sense to stick him in the middle rather than take him off.
I'm not particularly bothered if we strengthen at CB or midfield (certainly don't need a full back) and there's no point buying another young wide forward but we desperately need another proper CF. That's in Thiago's interests as well as the club's.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

Either way, we need another No 9 asap. Thiago is playing injured and is probably playing too many minutes for his long-term good. Yesterday was a perfect example of why the argument that Schade is his stand-in doesn't hold water. Thiago should probably have been subbed off if we want him to start against Everton, less than 70 hours after the last game finished, but Schade wasn't having one of his better games so made no sense to stick him in the middle rather than take him off.
I'm not particularly bothered if we strengthen at CB or midfield (certainly don't need a full back) and there's no point buying another young wide forward but we desperately need another proper CF. That's in Thiago's interests as well as the club's.
Schade was superb again yesterday
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

It’s really a shame Milambo is injured. I would have hoped he would have settled in by now. Hes the type of midfielder we’re missing who’s got a bit of skill and pace to get round a player I just think our midfield are all to similar. The Tottenham game just showed that. Great work off the ball but on the ball it’s poor.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

It’s really a shame Milambo is injured. I would have hoped he would have settled in by now. Hes the type of midfielder we’re missing who’s got a bit of skill and pace to get round a player I just think our midfield are all to similar. The Tottenham game just showed that. Great work off the ball but on the ball it’s poor.
We are calling out for a Milambo/JDS figure within the squad.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

If there’s value to be had, you never say never.

The one thing about getting a back up striker. With Fabio out injured, and the cost, I think we would’ve hoped by now to have a clear vision of whether he can fill in as that CF player back up. Kev is another option up top.

So the question is both what can any incoming player provide now but also where they sit once we welcome back Fabs and Milambo in particular
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

If there’s value to be had, you never say never.

The one thing about getting a back up striker. With Fabio out injured, and the cost, I think we would’ve hoped by now to have a clear vision of whether he can fill in as that CF player back up. Kev is another option up top.

So the question is both what can any incoming player provide now but also where they sit once we welcome back Fabs and Milambo in particular
I know Carvalho played CF in the Championship but I've seen nothing to suggest he can successfully do that at this level.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

If there’s value to be had, you never say never.

The one thing about getting a back up striker. With Fabio out injured, and the cost, I think we would’ve hoped by now to have a clear vision of whether he can fill in as that CF player back up. Kev is another option up top.

So the question is both what can any incoming player provide now but also where they sit once we welcome back Fabs and Milambo in particular
Don’t worry about Fabs & Milambo there out until next season. Make the squad a lot stronger now and worry about that when there back. ACL is a big injury to come back from. Personally we need another 9
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

I know Carvalho played CF in the Championship but I've seen nothing to suggest he can successfully do that at this level.
We’ve not really seen much of him at all or in a primary position he and the team have been coached around rather than him coming into an existing shape. I think he could have the potential to be a Maupay style little striker who is good at finding the right place to be and tucking away chances.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

An out an out CF is easily the most difficult player to source,a hell of a lot of dross in the prem in that position at the moment and a lot of even that awful standard would cost you 20m. Unless a deal of value or a good pedigree youngster is available I think we’ll keep what we’ve got.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

An out an out CF is easily the most difficult player to source,a hell of a lot of dross in the prem in that position at the moment and a lot of even that awful standard would cost you 20m. Unless a deal of value or a good pedigree youngster is available I think we’ll keep what we’ve got.
and then some people think that Gary Linekar Mk 2 will happily sit on the bench.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

An out an out CF is easily the most difficult player to source,a hell of a lot of dross in the prem in that position at the moment and a lot of even that awful standard would cost you 20m. Unless a deal of value or a good pedigree youngster is available I think we’ll keep what we’ve got.
That’s clearly the Brentford Way! I’m amazed that anyone posts about “a back-up striker” when the only back-up player I can recall us signing in the Premier League era was Sergio Reguilón on loan, once it was clear we had injury issues at left back.

I can’t see we have a desperate need in any position that would trigger spending decent money with the January Premium. On the other hand, there’s probably younger players who we’ve targeted who we want to get signed before the summer souk period starts. We may want to get them signed up now to get acclimatised and ready to roll for pre-season and who may provide cover for unforeseen events this season. The only exception would be if there was a ball-carrier to stand in for Milambo/Carvalho/Dasilva.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

Can't see how he'd qualify for a visa.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

Wasn't aware of that, thought football was still bound by UK employment laws.
I think it is covered by the FA's "Elite Significant Contribution" creteria which has been agreed with the Home Office for visa purposes which allows clubs to sign promising young talent who don't meet the requirements placed on senior players.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

I thought we could sign upto 6 non home grown under 21 years old each season
All seems really complicated having just had a quick read.

“Well, firstly, exit from the EU and its freedom of movement for labour means that PL clubs cannot sign players from overseas at the age of 16, as Arsenal did with Bellerin from Barcelona, or 17 as was the case with Garcia and Van den Berg. Overseas players must be a minimum 18 years of age to enter the UK.

Premier League clubs want to remain competitive with other European football leagues about signing talented players from within the EU, and not to be at a disadvantage with their European rivals.

So, the Premier League and The FA have agreed to additional criteria for “Youth Players”, whereby these players aged 18-19 who have exceptional talent but have not yet had the chance to appear regularly in their clubs’ first teams can accrue points to earn a GBE.

So, these youth players can earn points for being named on team sheets for league matches, even if they remain on the bench for that match. They can earn points for appearing in cup matches for the first team and they can also earn points for playing in the overseas clubs’ development teams (youth or reserve teams) in either domestic or international competitions. Again, the ranking of the club’s leagues plays a role in how many points the player earns for these appearances and a cup appearance has a higher merit than one for a development team.

Furthermore, international appearances at youth level, between Under-17 and Under-23, will now be included in them earning points, with again the countries’ ranking and the level of competitions in which the players played also a factor”

Taken from premier league.com

I have no idea if this guy has enough points or really how they’re accrued😂
 
Last edited by a moderator:

General BFC Transfer Thread

All seems really complicated having just had a quick read.

“Well, firstly, exit from the EU and its freedom of movement for labour means that PL clubs cannot sign players from overseas at the age of 16, as Arsenal did with Bellerin from Barcelona, or 17 as was the case with Garcia and Van den Berg. Overseas players must be a minimum 18 years of age to enter the UK.

Premier League clubs want to remain competitive with other European football leagues about signing talented players from within the EU, and not to be at a disadvantage with their European rivals.

So, the Premier League and The FA have agreed to additional criteria for “Youth Players”, whereby these players aged 18-19 who have exceptional talent but have not yet had the chance to appear regularly in their clubs’ first teams can accrue points to earn a GBE.

So, these youth players can earn points for being named on team sheets for league matches, even if they remain on the bench for that match. They can earn points for appearing in cup matches for the first team and they can also earn points for playing in the overseas clubs’ development teams (youth or reserve teams) in either domestic or international competitions. Again, the ranking of the club’s leagues plays a role in how many points the player earns for these appearances and a cup appearance has a higher merit than one for a development team.

Furthermore, international appearances at youth level, between Under-17 and Under-23, will now be included in them earning points, with again the countries’ ranking and the level of competitions in which the players played also a factor”

Taken from premier league.com

I have no idea if this guy has enough points or really how they’re accrued😂
Indeed, regardless of age, I always though there was a qualifying criteria that needed to be met. A player from the Latvian league without much of an international youth reputation seems a challenge to me.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

Indeed, regardless of age, I always though there was a qualifying criteria that needed to be met. A player from the Latvian league without much of an international youth reputation seems a challenge to me.
AFAIK, we're allowed a certain number of signings who fail the criteria, so long as the theory is that they will reach the criteria in the future. We signed Ji-Soo in this way, iirc.

In Football Manager, you lose spots if the players fail to meet certain criteria. It's kind of a carrot thrown the way of the clubs after Brexit took away some of their abilities to sign players.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

Indeed, regardless of age, I always though there was a qualifying criteria that needed to be met. A player from the Latvian league without much of an international youth reputation seems a challenge to me.
Not EU Regs it is our League who put conditions on transfers.
 

General BFC Transfer Thread

Not EU Regs it is our League who put conditions on transfers.
It's the FA coming to an agreement with the Home Office.

Obviously EU Regs would not apply and the PL is just....a league.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom