Ref Watch

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ref Watch

Scott Mathieson from Stockport is the man in charge on Tuesday night - one of the most experienced refs on the League list having been there since 1994.
 

Ref Watch

One of the worst refs i've ever seen. disgustingly bad.
 

Ref Watch

I would say his inept performance won us the game as he galvanised both the team and the home support for a cracking second half.
You certainly wouldn't call him a Homer!
 

Ref Watch

Stanley said:
I would say his inept performance won us the game as he galvanised both the team and the home support for a cracking second half.
You certainly wouldn't call him a Homer!
Click to expand...

Yeah good post, he ruined and made the game in equal measure. Knew it wasn't gonna be a good day for him when he fecked up the Minutes silence.
 

Ref Watch

Woeful.
 

Ref Watch

Crap and the linesmen on new road side.
But for the goal they did award us a corner which was a throw I thought
 

Ref Watch

When he cocked up the minutes silence it was never going to go well but he was as bad as i have seen for a long time
 

Ref Watch

The guy was a complete clown. Really not fit to officiate a game of football. Can't remember a ref irritating the crowd that much due to constant poor judgement. It seems like he was Carlisle's 12th man. Was half expecting him to award a retake of the penalty until such time as they scored. Really should be stopped from refereeing matches from now on.
 

Ref Watch

In 59 years of supporting the Bees he is as bad a referee as I can ever remember.

If the Martin Allen quote 'he reffed to the best of his ability' is true then heaven help us when he has an off-day!
 

Ref Watch

wibs said:
What?! How the hell did he do that?
Click to expand...

Blew his whistle to start it as peter gilham was making the announcement telling us why there was a minutes silence.
 

Ref Watch

He was way, way beyond sh*te. As inept a refereeing performance as I've seen for as long as I can remember. Clearly had never played the game and had no idea what constituted a foul. The booking on Clayton was utterly shameful after the countless fouls on him all game and the decision to award a foul against Douglas when he won a great clean header on the edge of the area all of five yards in front of the ref was so poor it was almost laughable.

Criminally poor.
 

Ref Watch

What a clown and was was well out of his depth.Every time we made a challenge he gave them a free kick and how did he miss that handball ?
 

Ref Watch

Worst for a good long time.

What was the penalty for? All I saw was one of their players clearly handle the ball.
 

Ref Watch

It was an almost forgettable match only made worth remembering by the totaly inept performance of the ref.

He would have been out of his depth in an under 7s match.

Hopefully the next time the circus is in town, they will pick him up and take him away.
 

Ref Watch

..............the ref at Portsmouth was poor but this fella was appalling...............the Douglas header was the worst of his howlers.............
 

Ref Watch

I have been watching football for nearly 60 years. I cannot remember seeing such a totally incompetent ref. It worked to our advantage in a strange way as it got the crowd going and was I believe the motivation behind our 2nd half performance. What I cannot understand is how such a complete clown could have been given a league 1 game to referee. As for the lino on the New Road side words fail me.
 

Ref Watch

Clayton's yellow card ??? not for the tackle (wahey) surely ?
 

Ref Watch

Not fit to referee any future league games. Laughable decisions but Beyond a joke
 

Ref Watch

Owlsmoor_Bee said:
He was way, way beyond sh*te. As inept a refereeing performance as I've seen for as long as I can remember. Clearly had never played the game and had no idea what constituted a foul. The booking on Clayton was utterly shameful after the countless fouls on him all game and the decision to award a foul against Douglas when he won a great clean header on the edge of the area all of five yards in front of the ref was so poor it was almost laughable.

Criminally poor.
Click to expand...

And this is coming from a guy that always has plenty of logic in his posts. You cannot get any fairer than Owlsmoor, so this ref must have been a pile of sh*te. and believe me he was, and where did they get the ***** with the Yellow and Red checked flag. Both of them were that bad , that you would have thought that they were tryimg to fix the game for Carlisle. Obviously they were not . I bet the Carlisle fans loved him. Anyone else notice the lino missed so many thro decisions that he waited for the ref to give them, and then put his flag up. An absolute disgrace. Inept is not the word. The pair of these clowns are not fit to run a Sunday morning pub match.
 

Ref Watch

As an ex referee with many years good level experience, it was very sad to see such a poor display from an officiating team. The referee did start the minutes silence before the announcements had been concluded, and then continued in the same muddled way throughout the game. Fans around were commenting quite early on that Carlisle were quite a dirty team and seemed to be getting away with very poor challenges without censure, and there was really no consistency in the yellow cards he did give and those that he should have given and didn't. My only surprise was that one of our players wasn't red carded, as he really did seem to want to punish us at every opportunity. I hope his assessment takes him off the list.
 

Ref Watch

...and while i'm at it, why are the linos so out of shape, the one paddock side wasn't obese but his costume (he was only playing the part of a lino) was snug to say the least.
 

Ref Watch

Absolute sh*te, couldn't keep up with play, unbelievable decisions its a contact sport but any bee player raised a foot higher than a length of grass, breathed in or out it was a free kick! Shambles at the minute silence. Disgrace not fit to run, let alone a Sunday league match or a professional game! Not helped by his two pricks on the touch line who didn't have the balls to make their own decisions!
 

Ref Watch

The worst decision was Douglas winning a header just outside their box and being penalised for not managing to defy gravity and colliding with the defender.
 

Ref Watch

Try to be fair and objective when commenting on refs and remove the red and White blinkers

Today however I was getting to the stage of wishing for Andy D'urso !!! With regards to the free kicks and penalty he gave against us I don't have any major issues, however that only works if the ref is even handed. The defenders were manhandling Clayton throughout the game and I expect only his partner has been as close with arms round him!! The booking he got beggars belief as does the one JD picked up

I cannot allow myself to believe that he had any bias but throughout the game there did seem to be a disproportionate number of fouls given. Mr Rosler was obviously not impressed and it would be very interesting to see what score he gets from the assessor!!

Please god we do not have to endure him again
 

Ref Watch

I've seen some dodgy refereeing decisions in my 40 years watching Brentford, but this has to be one of the worse if not mystifying.
 

Ref Watch

I agree with everything that has been said on this thread. The referee was a complete bandit, who's incompetence was numbing.
But what can be done to get this bloke reported to ensure that he does not ref at this level again ? (or any level for that matter)

The League need to be made officially aware of idiots like this.
 

Ref Watch

I took the kids to Zippos Circus at Richmond on Friday Night, didn't know I see another two clowns so soon, one in the middle and the other running the line New Road side the next day!
 

Ref Watch

Mick.C said:
I took the kids to Zippos Circus at Richmond on Friday Night, didn't know I see another two clowns so soon, one in the middle and the other running the line New Road side the next day!
Click to expand...

.............the car with no doors in the car park was a giveaway...............
 

Ref Watch

I took my 6 year old daughter who spent the entire game on the Ipad, the only interaction was when she burst into hysterics when I shouted "that is not a foul you stupid moron".
Before CD got booked logan was clearly tripped down the wing, that is why CD went in with vigor through frustration but he still got the ball as clean as a whistle.
Beyond a disgrace. Please put him out to graze with Atwell whilst we still have some sanity.
 

Ref Watch

Absolutely clueless, haven't seen a ref so bad before. I often say the worst refs are the one's who ruin the game as a spectacle, and he did just that. Too whistle happy, too many free kicks given when he could have just let the play flow, majority of them being fouls that neither side even appealed for. How they ended up with no bookings and we had three was inexplicable, every time one of our players were slightly late it was a booking, where when it was a Carlisle player all they got was a talking to. Thought the penalty was actually the correct decision as it was a clumsy challenge from Craig but just before that we had a clear penalty turned down when Harlee headed towards goal and their defender blocked it with his hands in the air. Giving a foul on Douglas when he won a clean header near their box was laughable and then booking Clayton near the end which was probably his only foul of the game proved his incompetence.
 

Ref Watch

We all moan about refs fairly consistently but this incompetent fool actually illustrated quite nicely how comparatively good 'most' refs actually are .....you know they've had a good game when you don't notice them but this bloke took it to another level....
 

Ref Watch

ladbroke said:
Apparently apologised to Douglas after the game.. so said the man himself...
Click to expand...

Does that mean we can appeal his card ( and others ) or does that not apply to yellows??
 

Ref Watch

I've seen some rubbish ref's at GP in over 60 years, but that man took it to a whole new level of incompetence and was by far the worst I've ever seen, I lost count on how many times he blew the whistle, was it a new one?, was he trying it out?, but whatever he was doing it would be an insult to even let him run the line in the Sunday League, Can the club put in an official complaint?, or are they not allowed to comment.
 

Ref Watch

You can appeal a straight red, but leave yourself open to having the original ban increased.
 

Ref Watch

The most inept refereeing performance I have ever seen. Could easily have cost us us 2 or 3 points-thankfully it didn't but I sincerely hope he doesn't referee again until he goes on a 'refresher' course to remind him what fouls are or aren't!
 

Ref Watch

Les Beeavinu said:
The worst decision was Douglas winning a header just outside their box and being penalised for not managing to defy gravity and colliding with the defender.
Click to expand...

Several minutes later a Carlisle player did the same thing and in front of the ref and got nothing.
 
368 More Posts...
Status
Not open for further replies.

Share this page

Back
Top Bottom