• This is the new server

The New Manager Thread

Who do you want as the next manager?

  • Martin Allen

    Votes: 303 51.0%
  • Anyone but Martin Allen

    Votes: 12 2.0%
  • Andy Scott

    Votes: 16 2.7%
  • Steve Cotterill

    Votes: 30 5.1%
  • Liam Daish

    Votes: 32 5.4%
  • Mick Harford

    Votes: 7 1.2%
  • Ray McFarland

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Gary Johnson

    Votes: 3 0.5%
  • Paul Fairclough

    Votes: 4 0.7%
  • Neale Cooper

    Votes: 2 0.3%
  • Paul Simpson

    Votes: 7 1.2%
  • Graham Westley

    Votes: 5 0.8%
  • Alan Devonshire

    Votes: 21 3.5%
  • Chris Hughton

    Votes: 6 1.0%
  • Scott Marshall

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Martin Keown

    Votes: 2 0.3%
  • Steve Perryman

    Votes: 9 1.5%
  • Adrian Whitbread

    Votes: 9 1.5%
  • Paul Buckle

    Votes: 12 2.0%
  • Nigel Clough

    Votes: 27 4.5%
  • Gary Blissett

    Votes: 12 2.0%
  • Jim Harvey

    Votes: 2 0.3%
  • Anyone but Andy Scott

    Votes: 22 3.7%
  • Mike Newell

    Votes: 51 8.6%

  • Total voters
    594
Status
Not open for further replies.

The New Manager Thread

I think his lack of knowledge of our lower leagues may rule him out.

He was able to pluck people out of nowhere to be successful with Gretna, he has shown he has the ability to talent spot.
 

The New Manager Thread

Having Allen back is like inviting the ex back after she has shagged the nieghbourhood and then walked out on you for the milkman. Shes now been dumped and your eye sight is failing and so is your memory, you want her back for the horizontal dancing and you forget about the rows, the infidelity and the strife, all of which will rear their ugly head within weeks of a fantastic return!

Once the f***fest has stopped she will be the bitch from hell again

she can **** who she likes if she keeps me from the Blue Square.
 

The New Manager Thread

He was able to pluck people out of nowhere to be successful with Gretna, he has shown he has the ability to talent spot.

that he may, but unless he has superhuman ability to talent spot, he is never going to have time to do this before the end of January.
 

The New Manager Thread

better still, pick your partner wisely in the first place and dont let your heart rule your head

but what if your partner was a great lay, and you are not sure if your future conquests are going to be sloppy and sh*t..?
 

The New Manager Thread

He was able to pluck people out of nowhere to be successful with Gretna, he has shown he has the ability to talent spot.

it's a great shout. i liked rowan alexander as a player and what he
achieved at gretna was nothing short of miraculous.
outstanding successs on a budget

he should be interviewed
 

The New Manager Thread

it's a great shout. i liked rowan alexander as a player and what he
achieved at gretna was nothing short of miraculous.
outstanding successs on a budget

he should be interviewed


Anyone get to the bottom as to why he was sacked / left Gretna ? :fishing: :fishing:
 

The New Manager Thread

it's a great shout. i liked rowan alexander as a player and what he
achieved at gretna was nothing short of miraculous.
outstanding successs on a budget

he should be interviewed

Weren't all his achievements bankrolled by Brooks Mileson? You don't go up through 3 divisions solely on flashing the cash admittedly, however nor do you go up through 3 divisions on average gates of 300 on pure talent.
 

The New Manager Thread

Having taken some time to digest the list, I must admit there are some desirable names there.

For me a definite no for Scott, Fairclough, Marshall and Westley. If Johnson is the Bristol City man, then absolutely no chance of getting him and I think the same could be said for Perryman.

Then from the rest I would be relatively happy with Cotterill, Hertford, Cooper, Simpson, Clough, Newell and of course MA.

Regrettably I don't know enough about some of the others, but many on here seem to like Daish and Paul Buckle seems to be doing a good job at Torquay. However, I really don't have much knowledge of their management capabilities.

Anyway what do I know as I initially thought that TB would do a goodish job, until he actually started to assemble a squad. Then from July on the writing was on the wall.
 

The New Manager Thread

Having taken some time to digest the list, I must admit there are some desirable names there.

For me a definite no for Scott, Fairclough, Marshall and Westley. If Johnson is the Bristol City man, then absolutely no chance of getting him and I think the same could be said for Perryman.

Then from the rest I would be relatively happy with Cotterill, Hertford, Cooper, Simpson, Clough, Newell and of course MA.

Regrettably I don't know enough about some of the others, but many on here seem to like Daish and Paul Buckle seems to be doing a good job at Torquay. However, I really don't have much knowledge of their management capabilities.

Anyway what do I know as I initially thought that TB would do a goodish job, until he actually started to assemble a squad. Then from July on the writing was on the wall.

In total agreement with your analysis Alan. :sorted:
 

The New Manager Thread

MR TREE

Spell it MINUSCULE NOT miniscule - sorry but its the one of the most mis-spelt words along with MIDDLESBOROUGH - thats MIDDLESBROUGH - once a proof reader and all that.
 

The New Manager Thread

Having Allen back is like inviting the ex back after she has shagged the nieghbourhood and then walked out on you for the milkman. Shes now been dumped and your eye sight is failing and so is your memory, you want her back for the horizontal dancing and you forget about the rows, the infidelity and the strife, all of which will rear their ugly head within weeks of a fantastic return!

Once the f***fest has stopped she will be the bitch from hell again

Hmmm... that all seems a bit venomous Glasgow - speaking from experience there??!!! And i should hasten to add that i too have been a member of that particular club. ;-)
 

The New Manager Thread

Shame that Clough senior isnt around to advise Clough Jnr.That would be a good partnership.The Fergie's are doing ok at Posh, "dad what do I do when....."




Having taken some time to digest the list, I must admit there are some desirable names there.

For me a definite no for Scott, Fairclough, Marshall and Westley. If Johnson is the Bristol City man, then absolutely no chance of getting him and I think the same could be said for Perryman.

Then from the rest I would be relatively happy with Cotterill, Hertford, Cooper, Simpson, Clough, Newell and of course MA.

Regrettably I don't know enough about some of the others, but many on here seem to like Daish and Paul Buckle seems to be doing a good job at Torquay. However, I really don't have much knowledge of their management capabilities.

Anyway what do I know as I initially thought that TB would do a goodish job, until he actually started to assemble a squad. Then from July on the writing was on the wall.
 

The New Manager Thread

Hessenthaler throws his hat into the ring

From:http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/li...article_id=501823&in_page_id=1779&ito=newsnow

Andy Hessenthaler is among the candidates to become the new Brentford boss.

The club's chairman, Greg Dyke, is believed to want a boss with lower-league experience to succeed Terry Butcher, who left the club this week after just seven months in the job.

The Bees are hovering dangerously above the League Two relegation zone following five straight defeats. They have also not scored a goal in eight hours and 40 minutes of football.

Former Watford midfielder Hessenthaler, 42, is player-boss of non-League Dover but is best known for keeping Gillingham in what is now the Championship for three years on a shoestring budget.

He has been looking to get back into League management since quitting as Gills boss in November 2004 and was pipped to the Brentford job by Leroy Rosenior 18 months ago.

Hessenthaler said: "I was disappointed not to get the job when Leroy got it. Brentford are a good club in a false position."
 

The New Manager Thread

Hassenthaler is another one who loses more than he wins
 

The New Manager Thread

best known for keeping Gillingham in what is now the Championship for three years on a shoestring budget


"Brentford are a good club in a false position."

:cool:
 

The New Manager Thread

Is there not a big danger that we perform reasonably well in the next couple of games and the board leave Scott in post rather than fork out for a new manager? How long will the process of recruitment take?
 

The New Manager Thread

thats the worry that we get a win on SAT, a draw V MK and then low and behold we offer it to Scott, I can just see it now
 

The New Manager Thread

Now KD has gone maybe Allen can manager the team and the club! That would save a few quid.
 

The New Manager Thread

sod it let's just make the man prime minister shall we? or perhaps king?
 

The New Manager Thread

Steve King, Lewes FC, currently top of the Blue Square South with 40 pts from 18 games:

"Steve King took over at the Dripping Pan in the summer of 2003, and quickly set about moulding the Rooks into a side that could challenge for promotion from Ryman Division One south. However what followed surpassed all expectations, with the championship being clinched at the end of April 2004, and then another promotion being achieved via three tortuous play-off games in five days. The team then confounded all the experts yet again by finishing in the play-off positions in the first two Conference South seasons, only to be denied the chance to play in them because of their ground".

Don't know anything about him, but: (1) this sounds pretty consistent; (2) he'd know the southern non-league scene; and (3) he's not a has-been or never-will-be regurgitated from the football league.

i live near lewes and i tell you what
the fans down there hate him!
 

The New Manager Thread

The New Manager Thread

i live near lewes and i tell you what
the fans down there hate him!

I find that very hard to believe !!

They are top of the league, and flying ahead this season...what's to hate :confused:
 

The New Manager Thread

I dont want Hessanthaler NO WAY
 

The New Manager Thread

I find that very hard to believe !!

They are top of the league, and flying ahead this season...what's to hate :confused:

He's on the Ron Noades' belt of lovely people. For not too dissimilar reasons too.
 

The New Manager Thread

No No No to MA

You cant turn the clock back. His time with us was brilliant but it's history now, and who can tell for sure if he could repeat what he achieved before?
I dont think Dyke for one moment wants him back, not that I tale any notice of what he says.
And what would MA want to come back for anyway?
No money
Worse players
Lower league.

Liam Daish was my choice 6 months ago and still is
BUT
This guy seems not to be wanted by any gpg'er, but take a look at what he has done with Dover Athletic this season

http://www.dover-athletic.co.uk/index.php

The man I'm refering to is Andy Hessenthaler.
Excellent knowledge of lower leagues. I live in Dover and the club was really in the doldrums until he was appointed. Surely he's worth interveiwing
__________________
 

The New Manager Thread

No No No to MA

You cant turn the clock back. His time with us was brilliant but it's history now, and who can tell for sure if he could repeat what he achieved before?
I dont think Dyke for one moment wants him back, not that I tale any notice of what he says.
And what would MA want to come back for anyway?
No money
Worse players
Lower league.

Liam Daish was my choice 6 months ago and still is
BUT
This guy seems not to be wanted by any gpg'er, but take a look at what he has done with Dover Athletic this season

http://www.dover-athletic.co.uk/index.php

The man I'm refering to is Andy Hessenthaler.
Excellent knowledge of lower leagues. I live in Dover and the club was really in the doldrums until he was appointed. Surely he's worth interveiwing
__________________

Oh yeah, Hess. He's not been mentioned at all for, well, at least a few posts. ;) Aside from his denial of interest, the impression I get is that he wants the job badly and gets linked with it every time. Maybe he should be given a tryout and see what he can do. I imagine he would have the hunger and desire for it even if it is expressed in a different way than, say, MA.

I've been unsure about Hess in the past, but I am now coming around to the idea that he may be worth a try.
 

The New Manager Thread

"Andy Hessenthaler has rubbished reports in a national newspaper"

Would you believe it???? The same paper as that carrying "Ide's" comments.

The same paper that Tony Flood sells stories off the GPG to :suspect:

;)


Oh well.back to Plan B
 

The New Manager Thread

As for my choice......the previous Luton manager M. N. who is used to slim pickings, smaller budgets, small crowds, clapped out stadia and a dodgy board......allegedly.

See any merits anyone ?
 

The New Manager Thread

As for my choice......the previous Luton manager M. N. who is used to slim pickings, smaller budgets, small crowds, clapped out stadia and a dodgy board......allegedly.

See any merits anyone ?

Smaller budgets? The one at Luton is £6 million per year. lol
 

The New Manager Thread

OK .....4 out of 5 ain't bad...
Can't believe its £6million though
 

The New Manager Thread

As for my choice......the previous Luton manager M. N. who is used to slim pickings, smaller budgets, small crowds, clapped out stadia and a dodgy board......allegedly.

See any merits anyone ?

I wouldn't have an issue with him. Some managers have a knack of promoting lower league teams and although he has only done it once you get a feeling about him.
 

The New Manager Thread

I know that opinion seems split on whether or not we should get Martin Allen back (if he will come back or not), but my point is this. Whether you like him or not he attracts players who want to play for Brentford, who have been sold on for profit, involves the fans in the club (fans v players, notes on website, access to training ground etc), attracts media attention, and most importantly has a great rapport with the majority of fans and puts bums on seats. On the downside he can seem a bit of a meglomaniac and should concentrate on team and fan affairs not budgets and general running of the club (if this is to be believed). I personally think he is the tonic we need provided the board can resolve any issues as well as the man to bring the fans back to GP. I am sure the other candidates have their qualities but I doubt any would have the immediate impact Martin would have. Sometimes its better the devil you know and in our case that is what is needed after the last 3 mistakes. PS, If Brentford is a FANS run club now as we are always being told then why dont the club take our opinions seriously on who we want in charge. After all we are the ones who pay to come to watch. The least they could do is read this poll.
 
Last edited:

The New Manager Thread

I know that opinion seems split on whether or not we should get Martin Allen back (if he will come back or not), but my point is this. Whether you like him or not he attracts players who want to play for Brentford, who have been sold on for profit, involves the fans in the club (fans v players, notes on website, access to training ground etc), attracts media attention, and most importantly has a great rapport with the majority of fans and puts bums on seats. On the downside he can seem a bit of a meglomaniac and should concentrate on team and fan affairs not budgets and general running of the club (if this is to be believed). I personally think he is the tonic we need provided the board can resolve any issues as well as the man to bring the fans back to GP. I am sure the other candidates have their qualities but I doubt any would have the immediate impact Martin would have. Sometimes its better the devil you know and in our case that is what is needed after the last 3 mistakes. PS, If Brentford is a FANS run club now as we are always being told then why dont the club take our opinions seriously on who we want in charge. After all we are the ones who pay to come to watch. The least they could do is read this poll.

Agree 100%. Some people have a moan at his daily website updates but I really liked them. I felt I was in daily contact in regards to the comings and goings around the training pitch, peoples personalities amd what he was expecting. All we have had come out of the club in the last 2 years is stone wall silence. A very brief preview of a game which usually just tells you tells the time and the place, a very brief summary of the last press conference and nothing in between. No updates or statements from the board, the managers or the players. In fact I hardly bother using the website anymore!
 

The New Manager Thread

Agree 100%. Some people have a moan at his daily website updates but I really liked them. I felt I was in daily contact in regards to the comings and goings around the training pitch, peoples personalities amd what he was expecting.

So did I, and though I don't think he'd come back, (he'd be mad to, everything to lose and nothing to gain in terms of reputation) the other thing i miss is the way he managed upwards, not in terms of wanting to take over and run the club, just the way that he seemed to get everyone on their toes. In the words of the hackneyed bumper sticker joke 'Jesus is coming....look busy'

In a less technically developed time, I also used to really enjoy Coppells programme notes. I used to read them first, and buy the programme because of them. Really intelligently written, un-patronising and honest.
 

The New Manager Thread

Luton have a £6,000000 playing budgetlol
 

The New Manager Thread

I've been unsure about Hess in the past, but I am now coming around to the idea that he may be worth a try.

:imwith:

Obviously depends on who applies but I would have thought he would be worth an interview at least. I don't think the achievement of getting Dover to the top of the league should be overlooked.
 

The New Manager Thread

As for my choice......the previous Luton manager M. N. who is used to slim pickings, smaller budgets, small crowds, clapped out stadia and a dodgy board......allegedly.

See any merits anyone ?



..................to which a board member replied...............



Smaller budgets? The one at Luton is £6 million per year. lol






:confused:








:sneakoff:
 

The New Manager Thread

not sure he will be as good as first time, but I am getting all moist at the thought of MA returning.....

Tank tops are back in !!!!!!!! :sorted:
 

The New Manager Thread

I saw Adrian Whitbread after the Grimsby game last saturday, so he is definatley in the area, available and most probably interested (as he is watching the bees)
 

The New Manager Thread

not sure he will be as good as first time, but I am getting all moist at the thought of MA returning.....

Tank tops are back in !!!!!!!! :sorted:

There will be tears of joy in the Flybee household if he does - of that there's no doubt. Can you imagine the atmosphere if come boxing day Martin Allen's red and white army is ringing round GP as the team run out?.....:) :) :)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom